3 ms·
Gnosticism was an amazingly diverse and interesting phenomenon, and this article does not do it justice by oversimplifying so and making it appear so black and
by pmoriarty 10y ago
Gnosticism was an amazingly diverse and interesting phenomenon, and this article does not do it justice by oversimplifying so and making it appear so black and white.
Some Gnostics did believe the demiurge was merely mistaken (arrogantly thinking himself the only true God or blundering in creating when trying to imitate the creation of the true God), others believed him insane, or even intentionally evil.
At root, the Gnostics were wrestling with the problem of evil. That is, how can evil exist in the world (or how can this world be as evil as it is) if God is perfectly good, omniscient, and ominipotent? To perhaps oversimplify it even further: how can imperfection arise out of perfection?
Their solution was to say that "true" God didn't create the world, and didn't create evil, but rather that it was the demiurge (and his minions, the archons) that did it. This demiurge was the creator God of the Old Testament, the false God that what has come to be mainstream Christianity worships.
The Gnostics tried to put as much cosmological distance as possible between their true God and the demiurge. To them not only did the true God not create the world, but he didn't even create the demiurge. The demiurge was created by an intermediary, who mistakenly tried to imitate the true God and created the demiurge.
They further distanced the evil material world that was the creation of the demiurge from the perfect realm of the true God by positing the existance of many intermediary realms and intermediary superhuman beings, each less perfect than the last, the further they get away from the true God and the closer they get to this evil world.
The result is that in their eyes the true God is absolved of responsibility for evil or this evil world, and he can remain perfect, omniscient, and ominpotent as he is infinitely remote from the muck that us material beings dwell in. But humans have a divine spark in them, and are capable of realizing their divine origin and thereby escaping the material prison they are trapped in.. but that is a story for another day.
There's a lot more to say about the Gnostics and their beliefs, but I'll just note that decades ago scholars were debating whether to abandon the terms "Gnostic" and "Gnosticism", as the people and beliefs so designated were so different from each other that using a single term for them would be misleading.
It's a bit like "Hinduism", which is not a single religion at all, but could be thought of as a family of religions, with many different and often conflicting beliefs. So what I say above (and what the original article says) about gnostic beliefs does not necessarily apply to all or even most Gnostics.
Anyone interested in learning more about this is encouraged to read the Wikipedia articles on Gnosticism (which are actually pretty good) and some books. Pagels' books are some of the most popular. But her perspective on Gnosticism is itself but one of many. Hans Jonas is a fascinating source, especially for his additional link to Heidegger. An interesting fictional, non-scholarly source is Philip K Dick, who incorporated his own reimagining of Gnostic ideas in to much of his own work.