4 ms·
Everything is like this though. Humans can't synthesize their own vitamin C, because, as frugivorous apes, we got enough of it in our diets that evolution decid
by bitwize 10y ago
Everything is like this though. Humans can't synthesize their own vitamin C, because, as frugivorous apes, we got enough of it in our diets that evolution decided the energy savings of omitting the vitamin C pathway was worth it. Same thing with cats and taurine.
- logfromblammo 10y agoBut we still have the non-functional GULO pseudogene in our DNA. Every part of the vitamin C pathway is still present, except for that one broken step. If you inject L-gulonolactone oxidase into your liver, you will produce vitamin C. Evolution didn't decide to save energy. It decided that if the users don't notice the bug before the warranty period expires, it isn't worth working the issue.
- sbierwagen 10y agoThe rest of the vitamin C synthesis machinery may be there, but it's obviously not consuming any energy if it's not producing anything. There's also some speculation that eliminating vitamin C synthesis had other beneficial effects, beyond saving energy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L-gulonolactone_oxidase#Consequences_of_loss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L-gulonolactone_oxidase#Conseq...
- M_Grey 10y agoIt takes energy to maintain and replicate that machinery... but then we're full of DNA that seems to be mostly along for the ride.
- dave_sullivan 10y agoEvolution doesn't decide of course, although your comment just brought to mind another thought: Evolution exhausts the lowest energy possibilities first, before moving on to higher energy configurations. The surviving lower energy configurations are then in effect used as legos to create higher energy, more expensive configurations. If any of those building blocks are "deprecated", perhaps this effects things up the line, leading to the probability that cheaper, more basic constructions will survive longer because they have fewer steps in a given dependency chain. Maybe this is obvious to people that understand evolution well, but I hadn't considered it that way before. In this way, upon reaching some equilibrium where there are base features that reliably survive, evolution "decides" to try more complicated things. My abstraction could be totally off though, so feel free to tell me so if that's the case.
- posterboy 10y ago> Evolution doesn't decide > Evolution exhausts So, the remark is not about evolution being passive, but that the ability to decide requires sapience? I think, decidability is elementary to programming and in that sense completely mechanic. Anything else is begging the question of free will and the jury's still out on that one, so your "of course" is illegitimate. > Evolution exhausts the lowest energy possibilities first, before moving on to higher energy configurations. that's basic arithmetic. You can't have all the other numbers without the first. > higher energy, more expensive configurations. Expense and state are not equal. First, energy from the current state has to be expensed to activate some process, that will in turn increase or decrease the energetic state. > If any of those building blocks are "deprecated", perhaps this effects things up the line, leading to the probability that cheaper, more basic constructions will survive longer because they have fewer steps in a given dependency chain. That's a non sequitur motivated by observation. The idea of entropy is from thermodynamics and I'm not fit at that, but I think it is just defined for closed systems. Same basic Issue as with the free will, it depends on your knowledge of the limits of the system. If you deem free will a thing, why would you consider a bigger system, that works on a much larger timescale than humans, that is virtually limitless, to have a lesser degree of freedom, ie. none?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dave_sullivan 10y ago> so your "of course" is illegitimate. > that's basic arithmetic. > That's a non sequitur motivated by observation. Gotta say I'm unconvinced by your argument.
- posterboy 10y agoI was tempted to delete the "illegitimate". I'm sorry for that, I'm a bit tempered. I was going to insert to write more on thermodynamics and philosophy, ie. metaphyiscs, and canceled that edit all together. Note that "observation" is a literal translation of theory and your statement is purely theoretic. In practice we have all kinds of complex "energetic configurations" roaming the earth, locally increasing the entropy.