3 ms·
Property itself doesn't cost the government much: Improvements do. But there are many other ways to pay for the same sorts of services without the same sort of
by Broken_Hippo 10y ago
Property itself doesn't cost the government much: Improvements do. But there are many other ways to pay for the same sorts of services without the same sort of financial burden. I'd much rather someone be able to live in their home (or stay in their business) once it is paid for than risk losing it over property taxes. Some folks pay for their own garbage collection, btw, and still pay for property tax. Some places only have volunteer firefighters, which don't get public funding for equipment outside of donations.
If you need ideas on how to tax folks without property taxes:
1. Income taxes without so many deductions, and a simple tax code. It is perfectly acceptable to give allowances for dependents, for example, or having a smaller rate for folks that earn less. Similar could be done for businesses.
2. Automatic sales tax, preferably included in the shelf price. Including it in the price makes it easy for folks to forget and easier to increase: Exemptions are OK at times (groceries, for example). This could be extended to include many business supplies.
3. A different sort of luxury tax for non-necessary services and items - such as fast food and convenience services, jewelry, and other such things. In addition, you could extend this tax to make tiers for some sorts of things: vehicles, for example: More sales tax upfront for vehicles that are over the median price, that are less fuel efficient, newer than x years, or other such things.
4. Higher fuel tax and vehicle fees coupled with improved public transportation, increased taxes on vehicles that are harder on roads (heavier vehicles, etc). Realistically, folks in cities with mass transport could pay a higher price because it is less of a necessity.
In addition, some things could change to make the services more cost-effective. Police, for example: Indiana has 3 levels of police: State, county, and city. You could combine these and make better use of resources and have less waste. Same can be said with schools, especially funding schools. As it is, poorer areas have less money for schools when it could be pooled statewide and distributed fairly instead. Property-tax funded schools don't save us from this underfunding, and neither will other district-based taxation.
The difference in these sorts of taxes is that they depend on your income and consumption. They are a bit unfair to poorer folks, but if the welfare system is fair, it can account for these sorts of things (by giving money to cover taxes instead of expecting businesses to take away the tax). I know this list isn't perfect or all that well thought out, but gives examples around the stuff.
- twblalock 10y ago> As it is, poorer areas have less money for schools when it could be pooled statewide and distributed fairly instead. Property-tax funded schools don't save us from this underfunding, and neither will other district-based taxation. I'm very much in favor of redistributing school funding, but that's not a tax decision -- it's a spending decision. If something like that ever happens, the money is likely to come from property taxes, as it currently does -- it will just be distributed in a different way.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoSpending decisions affect taxes, including property taxes. In my mind, part of the way to at least lessen the dependence on property taxes (or lower the taxes in general) would be to also redistribute the money on a larger scale. Otherwise, if you get rid of property taxes or lower them to a point, a few areas will likely become underfunded (or more so), assuming that property taxes are generally lower in places with lower incomes. I do figure you are correct, that at least a portion of it will always come from property taxes.