3 ms·
Index funds, through a reputable and low-overhead fund like Vanguard's; you'll never do worse than the market. They can absolutely go down, so don't put any mo
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
Index funds, through a reputable and low-overhead fund like Vanguard's; you'll never do worse than the market. They can absolutely go down, so don't put any money in them that you might need right away, but as a long-term investment, they'll always give you a rate of return approximating the overall economy.
- umanwizard 10y agoYou're basically saying the same thing as I am. I don't deny that there are better investment vehicles than a savings account. I'm just asking whether there is something of similarly low risk with a better interest rate. Stocks are definitely not lower-risk.
- taurath 10y agoStocks are not low risk. Stocks are not low risk. It bears repeating.
- 1812Overture 10y agoIndex funds aren't individual stocks. They're pretty low risk. If an index goes to 0, T-Bills, CDs, and cash won't be worth anything either, you'll need shotgun shells, generator fuel, and canned food.
- taurath 10y agoIndex funds are stocks. The market contracts - frequently. Over long periods of time its gone up. See the chart below [0] - If you invested all your money in 1965, there is only a 8 year window at the end of the 90s where you would have averaged a 3% return per year. Much of the rest of the time you're looking at negative returns. [0]: https://static01.nyt.com/packages/images/newsgraphics/2011/0102-metrics/triangle.png https://static01.nyt.com/packages/images/newsgraphics/2011/0...
- 1812Overture 10y agoIf you invested at the worst time in the past century that would be bad. If you invested in T-bills or CDs you'd have gotten murdered by inflation in that period too. NYT piece you're referencing says the average annual return over 20 years is 4.1% net of taxes, fees, and inflation. Not too bad.
- BorgHunter 10y agoThis isn't what "near-zero risk" means. Near-zero risk investments are things like savings accounts, CDs, and T-bills. Index funds that track stock-based indexes are intrinsically risky, as you yourself point out, unless you look at time scales of a decade or more.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoNear-zero risk of what? If you mean "risk of decreasing in value", then checking and savings accounts aren't near-zero-risk either; cash tends to decrease in value over time due to inflation, and you're nearly guaranteed to lose money over time (though somewhat predictably). If you mean "risk of disappearing completely", then neither a savings account nor an index fund will do that. A comment further up the thread asked for "very low risk"; the reply to that changed it to "near-zero risk". Better to consider the type of risk you care about, and how much money you want associated with each type of risk. Checking accounts and index funds both make sense as part of an overall strategy. I don't know that savings accounts do, though, except perhaps as a purely organizational tool.
- icebraining 10y agoRisk is about uncertainty - how well you one can predict what will happen to the money.