3 ms·
It's not "fairly certain", it's absolutely certain. http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/12/quantum-teleportation-demystified.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/1
by lisper 10y ago
It's not "fairly certain", it's absolutely certain.
http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/12/quantum-teleportation-demystified.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/12/quantum-teleportation-dem...
(Also submitted to HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12549728 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12549728)
- darawk 10y agoIt is not absolutely certain. Quantum theory is an incomplete description of the physical laws of our universe, and the mechanism behind quantum teleportation is not even fully understood within the framework of that theory. So, it is most certainly not absolutely certain that FTL communication by this means is impossible, though it would be fairly surprising. The premise upon which the idea that it is impossible is based is an axiom: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wightman_axioms#W3_.28local_commutativity_or_microscopic_causality.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wightman_axioms#W3_.28local_co... Not a conclusion from data or other, simpler premises. It is an axiom that has nice consequences and is generative of much that describes our observations, but it remains an untestable assumption.
- lisper 10y agoIt is as certain as anything in science. Yes, QM is incomplete, but it places hard constraints on the space of possible completions, and none of them allow FTL communications. FTL would break not only QM and relativity, but causality: it would allow you to send information backwards in time.
- bostonpete 10y agoIt seems to me that's exactly what an alien trying to keep us in the dark would say...
- zeveb 10y ago> It seems to me that's exactly what an alien trying to keep us in the dark would say... Well, Lisp is secret alien technology: http://lispers.org/ http://lispers.org/
- johncolanduoni 10y ago> Yes, QM is incomplete, but it places hard constraints on the space of possible completions, and none of them allow FTL communications. This is entirely incorrect. All of the proofs about broken causality (all of which stem from special relativity, since non-relativistic QM doesn't put the speed of light on a pedestal) assume that the laws of special or general relativity hold everywhere. What you're saying is the equivalent of claiming in 1914 that the theory of special relativity proves that physics cannot operate without an intertial reference frame.
- lisper 10y agoYes, I am assuming that relativity holds everywhere. There is zero evidence that this is not the case. This is what it means to be "as certain as anything in science."
- johncolanduoni 10y agoThat's not a "hard constraint on the space of possible completions". That's assuming the answer to begin with.
- lisper 10y agoNo, it isn't. The mathematical formalism of QM is fully compatible with SR. QM can only be completed within the constraints of SR. To get FTL you would not have to complete QM, you would have to overthrow it and SR and GR and replace them all with something completely different. Not just that, but whatever you replaced it with would still have to account for the observed invariance in the speed of light in all reference frames. QM and entanglement are really red herrings with respect to the FTL question. The impossibility of FTL is a direct logical consequence of the fact that there exists a universal speed reference in space-time. Entanglement only appears to violate this because people don't understand what entanglement actually is and how it works. When you make a measurement on one member of an EPR pair, nothing happens to the other particle. It's still in exactly the same state it was in before the measurement. So there is absolutely no reason whatsoever to believe that FTL could be possible, and a lot of reasons to believe that it's not. Granted, this is not "absolutely certain" (nothing in science ever is) but it's as certain as it gets.
- MichaelBurge 10y agoWhat if you destroy the entanglement by destroying one of the entangled particles? You can't do this by shooting it with a particle accelerator, or else the entanglement infects whatever you hit it with; but you could use an intense field like sending a photon into a black hole or an atom into a neutron star to be ripped apart. Is there a rule for describing the entanglement of the resulting constituent particles with the pre-existing particle? If it's possible to actually break entanglement(so that measurement of a qubit resets to 50%-50% random), it seems like you could transmit information faster than light by preparing a 100%-0% distribution with quantum gates and destroying the particles. Then the first particle would change the distribution of its measurements. And so you could prepare 1000 qubits and measure them every hour, waiting to observe a change.
- lisper 10y ago> What if you destroy the entanglement That is a very good idea, but doesn't work. The only way to "destroy an entanglement" is to bring the entangled particles back together. http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf or the movie version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc And if you get through those you might enjoy this one too: http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-arrow-of-time.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-ar...
- MichaelBurge 10y ago> That doesn't work. The only way to "destroy an entanglement" is to bring the entangled particles back together. Suppose a proton A is entangled with a proton B. If B hits an anti-proton C, it gets converted into pure energy(maybe light and heat?). If it's impossible to destroy entanglement, then the subsystem consisting of the light and heat must be entangled with the original particle. Observations: * The dimension of the vector space has increased, since there may be many constituent photons released. So it may be impossible to assign a specific dimension to any quantum state. * What is the rule for determining the resulting quantum state? Is there a book or article? * If you convert a particle entirely into an electromagnetic wave or gravitational waves, and then reconstruct it, does that preserve entanglement? What is the rule for describing how the dimension of the vector space changes as it undergoes multiple transformations? If entanglement is allowed to propagate to a continuous field, then it seems like you'd have an uncountable infinite dimensional vector space to describe its state.