3 ms·
More people-oriented answers: http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/3158 http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/3158 Shortest answer to that question:
by wruza 10y ago
More people-oriented answers:
http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/3158 http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/3158
Shortest answer to that question:
http://physics.stackexchange.com/a/3162 http://physics.stackexchange.com/a/3162
>Imagine at home you put one glove in your coat without looking (and noticing it's only one of the two). After exiting the train you notice it's cold and you pull out that single glove. At this very instant you know it's either the left or the right glove, and you therefore know which one is left at home. However, no information was transmitted by your "measurement". Of course in quantum mechanics this is more complicated because of the not entirely measurable wave function, but this is the basic idea.
- nothrabannosir 10y agoThere are a lot of (justified) comments on that answer. A crucial point of quantum uncertainty is that it's different from classical intuition. Particles behave like waves (e.g. cause interference with themselves) until observed. That doesn't happen with the glove.
- d0mine 10y agoThe essence of the answer is that correlation doesn't imply causation (true). The essence of the comment is that the correlation in a quantum case may be stronger than in a classical case such as the case with gloves (also true). The comment doesn't invalidate the answer unless you think it does imply causation (non-locality). It just says that the answer is not the whole truth: that would be the complete mathematical description of QT with corresponding procedures to connect the math with observations. The glove analogy obviously has its limits. It doesn't make it wrong. Otherwise, the accepted quantum theory is also wrong because it doesn't describe all known phenomena (consider gravity). > "Particles behave like wave until observed" Consider photon: it is neither wave nor particle in a classical sense. The math is such that in some cases it is easier to describe it as wave (interference pattern), in others—as particle (photoelectric effect). It is surprising that the familiar concepts from a human scale (such as wave, particle) are useful in such a wide range of physical phenomena. Though only because they are more familiar does not make them more real than e.g., the concepts produced by the equations of the quantum theory. All models are wrong—some are useful. (In a sense that there is no territory under a map, only more complete or different maps)
- s-macke 10y agoIn this classical picture the decision which glove was in your pocket was made when you put it into your pocket. Still in your pocket, the glove already interacted with the world like a right or left glove e. g. the glove bulged the pocket in a certain way and moved fluff around in your pocket. If the gloves would be quantum objects, the glove would be in a superposition state. At the same time the content in your pocket would be the right and left glove. Hence it would interact with your pocket in both ways before measured leaving your fluff in your pocket also in an undetermined (superposition) state. Things get more complicated here because we talk about huge classical objects with a lot of atoms. And here it is practically impossible to obtain such a superposition because the glove interacts a lot with the environment. E. g. by looking at the bulge of your pocket you might be able to determine the glove type without opening the pocket.
- spacehome 10y agoThat answer is really missing something because it doesn't predict that Bell's Inequality would be violated.