7 ms·
The other HN thread suggests this not actually a dark conspiracy by Microsoft but simply a case of missing linux drivers for the storage devices. This sounds b
by xg15 10y ago
The other HN thread suggests this not actually a dark conspiracy by Microsoft but simply a case of missing linux drivers for the storage devices.
This sounds believable to me. But I'll put my tinfoil hat on just for fun and pretend it was an intentional move. Could this make sense as a new twist on the old strategy, making it "Embrace, Extinguish, Extend"?
With the WSL, they made it theoretically possible to run Linux software on Windows. With that in place, locking existing users out of Linux might cause a lot less negative backlash as the users can still continue to use their old programs - except under the supervision of Windows. If this catches on, it could actually allow Microsoft to grab some if the more consumer-oriented parts of the Linux ecosystem.
- topbanana 10y ago> some if the more consumer-oriented parts of the Linux ecosystem I'm scratching my head here. Help me out. I've seen extremely limited consumer take-up of desktop Linux.
- Sylos 10y agoWell, it is somewhere around 1.5% to 2% and seems to currently be growing. That's not a whole lot, but still worth targeting.
- makaronin 10y agoIf you read the original reddit thread, you would understand that this is not just a drivers issue. Lenovo intentionally programmed their BIOS so that it reverts any changes to RAID mode making it impossible to install Linux.
- minikites 10y agoOr the bug is that it fails to properly store the initial change?
- aw3c2 10y agoIs it meant as contra Linux though? Or just pro RAID?
- userbinator 10y agoRAID on a machine with a single SSD (and no provision to add another)? It'd make far more sense if the BIOS was setup so the RAID option was always disabled. Edit: it'd be rather amusing and saddening if this whole controversy was caused merely by someone misunderstanding/misreading a perfectly sensible requirement to disable the RAID mode, and instead disabled the other options. Given the level of communication fluency among some programmers, I would not be surprised if this were the case; and the fact that the machine still boots into Windows because it has drivers might've let this slip past QA...
- sveiss 10y agoThe choice seems to be between AHCI and sorta-NVMe, with the latter enabled in 'RAID' mode. Sure, real/standards-conforming NVMe would be better -- and wouldn't require driver shenanigans in either Windows or Linux -- but there should be a performance advantage to 'RAID' mode in this case.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- josteink 10y agoIf it was meant contra Linux, it obviously failed as the Linux installer booted just fine.
- xg15 10y agoTrue - but as the other HN thread (that I can't seem to find anymore ><) pointed out, if Microsoft's requirements were planned as an attack against free software, it would be an unnecessarily complicated and ineffective one: There is nothing stopping anyone from writing Linux drivers for the new RAID mode - and I guess if more models with this setup show up, eventually someone will write one. On the other hand, Microsoft could have easily gotten a much more "robust" lockdown - by simply demanding mandatory, unchangeable Secure Boot like on the ARM tablets. But they didn't do that.
- slipstream- 10y ago>On the other hand, Microsoft could have easily gotten a much more "robust" lockdown - by simply demanding mandatory, unchangeable Secure Boot like on the ARM tablets. But they didn't do that. Didn't you hear that Secure Boot is basically broken?
- Natanael_L 10y agoThose leaked provisioning certs can be blacklisted on new hardware
- josteink 10y ago> - but as the other HN thread (that I can't seem to find anymore ><) pointed out, Flagged as a dupe. It's here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12545966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12545966
- makaronin 10y agoOne guy has done a nice work decompiling the BIOS and found that skipping over the hidden BIOS pages is hard-coded into the firmware. See this https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Installing-Ubuntu-16-04-on-Yoga-900S/m-p/3426178#M8201 https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/Linux-Discussion/Installing-Ubu...
- brokenmachine 10y agoCan they not modify that BIOS code to not skip those pages? I'm sure anyone with enough knowledge to decompile a BIOS would have obviously thought of that idea though. I'm guessing the BIOS images are signed or something? Regardless, this smells evil to me...
- DanBC 10y agoAlso making it impossible to install Windows 10 downloaded directly from MS.
- buovjaga 10y agoSomeone got through the Lenovo lock with direct BIOS flashing: https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/53ri0m/warning_microsoft_signature_pc_program_now/d7vozf6 https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/53ri0m/warning_micro...
- mikkom 10y agoI think it was confirmed that the computer is locked to windows due to ms/lenovo contract http://imgur.com/a/niewu http://imgur.com/a/niewu
- UK-AL 10y agoYes, because a low level customer support agent is going to be privy to a secret agreement. In reality the agent probably misunderstood what's bring asked.
- leereeves 10y agoLow level customer support agent is probably working off a script.
- UK-AL 10y agoThey probably looked for word linux in a script, and typed in the answer. In reality the script read, "can I buy this with linux installed?", the answer would be only "windows 10 signature edition". They probably don't even know what linux is.
- leereeves 10y agoYes, and someone, not a low-level tech, wrote that script and wrote the reply: > This system has a Signature Edition of Windows 10 Home installed. It is locked per our agreement with Microsoft.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- beagle3 10y agoMore likely, it's a conspiracy against Win7/Win8 users, which hurts Linux users as collateral damage. What likely happened was the ms/lenovo deal was "And Lenovo will make sure win7 and win8 are not supported on laptop", which lenovo solved by switching the hard drive to a mode not even win10 supports, locking it that way (that's the evil part), and putting drivers for it on the lenovo install media, which are win10 only. Thus, this laptop can only ever be installed from the Lenovo win10 media. No win7, no win8, no retail win10 (for now), and .... probably as a (not unwelcome) side effect, no linux. Still, just as evil and despicable.
- deviate_X 10y agoThe problem with this conspiracy is that you can't install Windows 10 on the machine either ...
- beagle3 10y agoFrom retail/downloaded Win10. Buy you CAN from Lenovo images, which are provided to you by Lenovo.
- josteink 10y agoExcept windows 10s drivers are compatible with windows 8 and 7, since the driver model haven't changed since then. So using that install media you can extract the drivers and install older windows versions anyway. So it's a pretty crappy conspiracy :)
- RandomOpinion 10y ago>locking existing users out of Linux A serious question: What gives Linux users the right to expect that Linux will run on any given PC / laptop? Think about it. These PCs/laptops are designed to adhere to Microsoft's Windows PC hardware standards doc (which was never, ever an open standard) and, with few exceptions, only tested against various versions of Windows. Linux users are failing to receive a feature that they were never promised in the first place so it's unclear that they have any valid cause for complaint. Perhaps Linux, BSD, etc. users should be creating their own PC standards doc and asking OEMs to adhere to it instead?
- wepple 10y agoI get your point; I don't buy an iPhone and then complain when it won't load android. however, I've been able to load linux on almost any laptop I've bought for the last 20 years, so they are making a significant change here, and haven't made it particularly widely publicized.
- xg15 10y agoWhat gives Linux users the right to expect that Linux will run on any given PC / laptop? Nothing. It's very well possible that in future, we have Apple devices that only run iOS, Google devices that only run Android/ChromeOS/Whatever and Microsoft devices that only run Windows 10 - and a large server market with a tiny consumer segment of devices that run linux. We'll all be fine in that world. We just won't have any control about our devices anymore. Perhaps Linux, BSD, etc. users should be creating their own PC standards doc and asking OEMs to adhere to it instead? That's actually a good idea in theory - so far that "standard" had been the x86/x64 IBM compatible PC. Except that I fear they lack the market power to actually make such a standard more than a stack of paper. You'd need an OEM network the size of Microsoft or enough capital and brand trust so you can make your own devices. I see neither for linux.
- frik 10y agoSeriously, you have a very limited word view. Learn more about what Personal Computer means, have a look at Wikipedia.
- carapace 10y ago