4 ms·
Hrm, how exactly is it novel? Paper bags from recycled materials are known for years. Sounds like another attempt to patent sliding locks or rounded corners. In
by shmerl 10y ago
Hrm, how exactly is it novel? Paper bags from recycled materials are known for years. Sounds like another attempt to patent sliding locks or rounded corners. Instead of patenting stuff Apple should do something useful.
- Finnucane 10y agoPresumably the 'novelty' lies in the specificity of the bag's design. But even there, it is hard to see--it is not as if bags with loop handles, cardboard stiffeners, and so on, did not already exist. One wonders how close another bag would have to be to 'infringe'. But I like this bit: "Bags are often used for containing items. "
- shmerl 10y agoI wonder more what goes through the mind of those who create such patents to begin with... They really have nothing better to do, or they are intentional parasites?
- camtarn 10y ago"...an item carried within bag 100 will typically apply force to bag 100 at bottom panel 212, due to the gravitational attraction of the item to the earth..." :)
- cwkoss 10y ago"Since an item carried within bag 100 will typically apply force to bag 100 at bottom panel 212, due to the gravitational attraction of the item to the earth, areas near the bottom of bag 100 may be most susceptible to tearing."
- pwg 10y ago> Hrm, how exactly is it novel? It's not. This is just a patent application. All that was needed to get this far was to 1) write some documents and fill out some forms 2) pay a fee.
- collyw 10y agoPatents are granted to novel ideas. It should be novel if you are applying for one.
- pwg 10y agoWell, yes, but there's no filtering for 'novelty' on that portion of the process. So you, provided you want to pay the fee, can apply for anything, novel or not. If it is not novel, then you should never receive a patent on it, but that does not stop you from trying by sending in the paperwork.
- kens 10y agoYou ask how is it novel? Looking at the patent application, the "novel" part is that "conventional bags formed of [recycled] paper are made with 50% or less post-consumer content", but claim one covers "a bag container formed of white paper with at least 60% post-consumer content". Supposedly they had to do non-obvious things (the other claims) to make a 60% bag strong enough. Also they have a drooping, thick handle of 8-stitch knitted paper to avoid a "rough, unfinished feel". On the one hand, it looks like Apple put a lot of work into this bag design and doesn't want it ripped off. On the other hand, it looks like a collection of reinforcements and features that are probably pretty obvious. (Although I don't have "ordinary skill in the art" of bag making, so who am I to say.)