4 ms·
> Your value shouldn't be tied to where you live per se. If that was the case people wouldn't make $200k in SV, $75k in Omaha, and $9k in Phuket for the same j
by pc86 10y ago
> Your value shouldn't be tied to where you live per se.
If that was the case people wouldn't make $200k in SV, $75k in Omaha, and $9k in Phuket for the same job.
- eropple 10y agoPeople who are near the top of the skill curve, and can present a business case for being paid like it, don't make $75K in Omaha for that job. (They may make $9K in Phuket, but there are additional factors on top of that.) If I left Boston today, I'd still make what I make here. I have considered doing exactly that.
- sidlls 10y agoThat really depends on very much more than your skill as an engineer, and the ability to "present a business case for being paid like it" simply does not apply to the majority of employment negotiation scenarios--even ones involving the very best of the best engineers. Most, in fact almost all employers have fixed salary schedules for their positions and they simply will not deviate from these as a rule, nor will they entertain negotiation around them.
- eropple 10y ago> Most, in fact almost all employers have fixed salary schedules for their positions and they simply will not deviate from these as a rule, nor will they entertain negotiation around them. Most employers will happily tell you that this is the case. That does not mean that it is so. If you rate it, those doors will, at many companies, open. But you have to rate doing something that is Not Normal, and you have to be able to communicate why you rate having the people dealing with your hiring stick their neck out and do something that is Not Normal. This is hard. Few people (not just engineers) can do that. But it can be done.
- sidlls 10y agoIt means exactly that it is so for almost all cases. There are always going to be exceptions, but those are just that: exceptions. There's a reason they're called "exceptions." Edit: the people who set compensation are very rarely the people that decide whether to hire you. The latter may communicate the salary HR dictates to them, but they almost never have negotiation power within their own employers' structure.
- pc86 10y agoI've worked at 20k+ employee companies where these are split into entire separate decision-making structures. Salaries are set by HR and approved far up the chain, and hiring decisions are made by people who do not share supervisors until you're a level below the CEO. When you're hiring a "Programmer II" in a company like that, the salary is not going to change. You might be able to negotiate work-from-home a day or two a week, or an extra week of vacation or something, but you're simply not going to make more than the upper bound of that schedule, and being at the upper bound of that schedule will negatively impact raises until you get promoted. The CEO or COO or CIO is not going to approve a $100k salary for a Programmer II when the band is $60-75k. It just won't happen. On an extremely related note, there is zero ambition and very little technical skill at that company. The vast majority of folks with skill and ambition leave after 2-3 years.
- wpietri 10y agoIt doesn't have to apply to the majority of employment negotiation scenarios. It just has to apply to enough of a particular class of worker to set the market price. I would also suggest your understanding of how often exceptions are made is very unlikely to be based on good data. Employers have ways of hiding that they are paying somebody more than their traditional salary structure when they need to make an exception. And a very strong incentive to do that hiding.
- sidlls 10y agoYes, and the same reasoning would apply to folks suggesting that employers routinely are open to negotiation. On the other hand we have a plethora of anecdotal data (e.g. through Glassdoor and other self reporting places) and BLS salary data by region and classification (https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oessrcma.htm https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oessrcma.htm). The means and medians in these data are quite close. It'd be nice to see upper and lower extremes, modes and other information to gauge the actual distribution, but it strikes me as an extraordinary to claim successfully negotiating higher-than-average wages is typical.
- eropple 10y agoWho's saying anything about typical? I've never been a typical employee in my life. I have, however, been the highest-paid non-manager (or so I was told; this might have been an attempt to shame me into working more for free) in a hundred-person development group, well out of band, because I brought capabilities and skills to the table that they needed more than they needed to Maintain The Integrity Of The Salary Band.
- sidlls 10y agoSo if your point wasn't that employers routinely deviate from their prescribed bands ("as a rule") why did you respond to my comment? What I see is an anonymous Internet Person bragging without context (for all I know your non-typical experience could have been with 99 developers who were seriously below average).
- pw 10y agoI think it has a lot less to do with being at the top of the skill curve than with making the business case for it.
- eropple 10y agoI'm sure that's true. The world is not a technical problem. It just happens that the folks I know in that position more than deserve it from a technical perspective.
- sidlls 10y agoYes what is and, according to the parent what should be, diverge. What this really tells me is that workers in Omaha and Phuket ought to demand more, and that they are selling themselves for far less than the value they create, or else that they aren't actually doing "the same job." Likely both are true.
- mgkimsal 10y agoIn most cases, it is at least partially tied to how much value someone can extract from you, which really has to do with how much value they bring in the market. It's less about the 'value I create' and more about the 'value company X is able to create using my skills'. And... in some measure, you're going to be tied to how good the company itself is. I could give the same deliverable to two companies, and one may be able to make 20x more than the other, owing to other factors like network, sales, marketing, image, etc. In that case, they could probably pay me more as well, because they're earning more, but that then gets in to business vision and politics - do they see the software/tech as a cost-center or a profit-center?
- jsudhams 10y agoAgree with this. Some in south India make 100K USD for the job that would make 140 to 180K in USA. But not everyone though and like other post mentioned it is about the companies perception of your value and most of the Fortune 500 companies have some base setup for each title irrespective of where you live.
- vostok 10y agoI have direct experience with getting offers in an area with cost of living similar to Omaha. With no negotiation, the pay was the same as in the high cost of living area where I chose to live. I don't have direct experience with Phuket, but I've heard of friends who get paid US level contract rates in similar areas.