4 ms·
Reading Between the iPhone OS 4.0 Lines
- jsz0 17y agoThe big omission for me was not addressing the notification system. Its never scaled well past the original intent of missed calls / voicemails. A common problem I encounter is a screen full of notifications and the need to unlock the phone to do something. Once I do that they vanish. A Notifications app would be a quick and dirty fix. Just let me go back to them instead of hunting through different applications to figure out what I missed.
- jonknee 17y agoEspecially surprising considering Android has a robust notification system. It's laughably simple on the iPhone.
- aphyr 17y agoAndroid's notification system is one of the things that really rocks about the platform. It's quick to scan, never gets in your way, and works seamlessly.
- warfangle 17y agoAbsolutely. I never kept my iPhone apps up to date, because it was a pain to go into the app store and re-download them. The app store buy/download button had always been problematic for me, anyway - sometimes it would take six tries just to get it to register. Now, I get a notification when there's an update, roll it down, click the notification and click the clear and accurate "download" button. And then I get notified when it's finished. It's really quite nice. (the glowing trackball is fantastic, too: so many times I'd miss an SMS or a call on my phone and not realize it until minutes or hours later)
- jonknee 17y ago> Absolutely. I never kept my iPhone apps up to date, because it was a pain to go into the app store and re-download them. The app store buy/download button had always been problematic for me, anyway - sometimes it would take six tries just to get it to register. The store should let you update all apps at once--when you open the app it goes and checks if there are updates available and if so you'll see them in the bottom right. There's an option for update all.
- tvon 17y agoI think the idea is that once you've unlocked the phone the app icons tell you what items need attention.
- jonknee 17y agoThat's great if you have one screen of apps, but really pathetic when you have to swipe through 5-10 screens so you can see your AP news app has an update. Even worse when you have to then hunt for the update once you get in the app (AP again, or Facebook).
- neonfunk 17y agoNot to mention, you can't ignore a notification so you can look at it later... It's either view or dismiss.
- blasdel 17y agoThey're only one rung above notepad.exe's "Search reached end of document | Ok" dialog, but only because for most of them hitting Ok takes you to the source of the notification. They're a disaster compared to Apple's desktop HCI guidelines that insist on verbed dialogs and disdain "Cancel | Ok"
- cpr 17y agoHmm, scaling back on innovation in the desktop OS is a bit unsettling. The end of the desktop may be here in 5-10 years, but surely there are still interesting things left to do there? Perhaps the ultimate simplification of computing (iPad and derivatives) is the only thing on Jobs' agenda now, innovation-wise.
- blasdel 17y agoI can't really think of any other foundational APIs that would be worth it for them to integrate into OS X at the expense of their infant mobile platforms that still have years of iteration and several more major releases before they're nearly as 'mature' as the platforms they're displacing. OS X is incredibly mature now, while there are still warts (Spotlight is relational with fixed indexes, mobile.me sucks and isn't freemium, etc.), the iPhone OS has those warts too, it's more important to fix them there than on the desktop, and there's tons of incomplete/missing features on top of that that need iterating on. I certainly wouldn't want to see the kinds of consumer-facing features they'd have to pull out of their ass to justify a 10.7 release in the next year or two.
- Perceval 17y agoI'm perfectly fine with future updates more along the Snow Leopard line than more normal updates with major features and UI changes. Add new goodies under the hood, make it faster and more secure, and charge me $29. Couldn't be happier.
- blasdel 17y agoThe problem is that for outfits like them shipping anything takes a huge amount of effort, and they're kind of short on under-the-hood goodies to add. They're also kind of constitutionally incapable of shipping security updates, though it's probably better overall that they don't do ubuntu's 10-updates-per-day regimen. I'd rather they spent their efforts iterating on their mobile products. They have a ton of challenges still ahead of them there, like whatever they're going to try to replace the hierarchical filesystem UI with, synchronization, their mobile ads platform, fixing their notifications UI, integrating browser tabs into the app-switching UI (like WebOS and ChromeOS), etc.
- chime 17y agoI don't get it. If apps can be paused in the background while remaining in RAM, why not swap them to the SSD when memory runs low? Why quit the app completely and expect the app to manage restore etc.? When the app restarts, it is obviously going to read from the SSD. So why not load the state too automatically? If paused apps still have open threads that called every now and then, I can understand. But it doesn't make sense for apps that don't. I would appreciate if anyone could explain this better.
- guelo 17y agoThe problem with flash memory is that it has a finite number of write cycles, typically around 100,000 though there are techniques that extend that. This is also why the iPhone doesn't utilize a swap file.
- sp332 17y agoModern MLC cells get 1,000-10,000 writes per cell. That's about 1,000,000 writes per drive, with wear leveling.
- gte910h 17y agoYou can't get very good wear leveling with a device that's on for days at a time. Flash as a swap drive is still problematic.
- barrkel 17y agoAssume a constant rate of swapping of 128KB/sec evenly distributed across 16GB of storage space. How long before the whole system collapses, as a function of n write cycles? 16 * 1024 * 1024 / 128 * n = 131,072n seconds ~= 1.52n days ~= 0.0042n years So constantly swapping (which is a very pessimistic scenario for a phone, which spends most of its life idle in your pocket) may expect a lifetime between 4.2 and 42 years, presuming between 1,000 and 10,000 write cycles. I would say it's acceptable.
- wvenable 17y agoAs usual, John Gruber lacks some awareness of the history of the industry and the technical details. The multitasking in iPhone OS 4 is not just similar to Android but also to Symbian and perhaps even the Blackberry. It's a very standard technique that has been used in handheld devices for over a decade. I suppose some jailbreaked iPhone users can comment on whether older iPhone's really can handle multitasking on 128MB of RAM. Considering that most devices have handled "true" multitasking with much less RAM than that over the years I'm not convinced it's truly a problem. They might not be able to hold as many apps in memory at once but that's what you get for having an older device. It'll be slower. But it should still be slightly faster than launching and closing every app all the time.
- enjo 17y agoUnless I'm greatly mistaken (completely possible) symbian is a more traditional multi-tasking system. The UI and everything else was more or less kept in memory with the only caveat being that you had to learn to graciously deal with being shutdown as memory ran low. I also think that the Apple system varies pretty significantly from Android. Android has the concept of 'bundles' and 'servers'. Bundles work similarly to what Apple is doing, but having servers (which multi-task in a more traditional model) enables more consistent background processing. For instance, an alarm clock on Android is often implemented with the GUI 'bundle' on the front-end and a server on the back-end that manages the actual 'when should I sound the alarm?' part of the task.' That's one thing that just isn't possible in the iPhone model.
- wvenable 17y agoI doesn't sound like there is any way for the iPhone OS to selectively unload parts of an app. So, just like Symbian (and every other platform), the entire app stays in memory. The big difference with the iPhone is that there isn't any background threading except when triggered directly by the OS for a specific purpose. That's a fairly minor difference but it would prevent poorly written apps from eating up too much battery life (or doing other nasty things in the background). Having to graciously deal with being shutdown (and restore your state on relaunch) is pretty much the same model as the iPhone OS 4.
- timdorr 17y agoReading through this article, I thought to myself: When did Apple become such an angry, aggressive, and negative company? I remember an Apple where I felt a certain pride in owning their products because they were superior options for me. A company that was gaining marketshare and mindshare through excellent products that just blew away the competition. This new Apple is spiteful and highly defensive. I'm embarrassed to be typing this on a Mac and to have had an iPhone (switched to a Nexus One recently). If Google's moral motto is "Don't be evil", it seems like Apple's is now "Fuck you. punch". What the hell happened?
- adeadcow 17y agoIf you really think about it, Apple has always been like this. They want to control every aspect of their hardware and software. The pride you felt was the result of marketing.
- armandososa 17y agoMuch praise for the multitasking UI on iPhone OS4, but I still think that the cards metaphor of webOS is much better.
- blasdel 17y agoYou're absolutely right, it's a shame that Palm is essentially dead walking. Google's ChromeOS will be picking up the torch of "everything's a tab" when it hopefully ships later this year. Apple hasn't yet backed themselves into a corner where they can't rip it off, but to do it right would require them to not be their usual bossy selves. In an ideal card-based iPhone world, apps would have the option of being document-centric and be able to register for URL-handlers and file-types (both just like on OS X). Unfortunately the new Apple would probably never let them become the default in place of built-in apps (no registering http:// http://, no owning image/jpeg, etc.). I think they'll have to do it eventually, but it might take a while. They might try to let the new multitasking API percolate in the wild first, and develop their replacement for the hierarchical filesystem UI and maybe OTA syncing in the meantime.
- c00p3r 17y agoThe history repeats itself. =) The raise of linux was, in some extent, because "we hate MS" (because they are a monopoly, too rich, etc - does not matter). Now its Apple in focus and on the top, so it's time for Android (+1 for Google for a wise strategy to become a new RedHat of mobile segment) or even Maemo. It is also good news for Nokia with its N900 pilot project, but they are too slow and stuck with their crappy Symbian. NextStep was much wise investment. =) btw, RIM acquired QNX. =)