5 ms·
ugh god, please! I've been looking for something as Linux/Unix friendly and sturdy as an IBM thinkpad for what feels like an age now. From what I can tell onl
by dijit 10y ago
ugh god, please!
I've been looking for something as Linux/Unix friendly and sturdy as an IBM thinkpad for what feels like an age now.
From what I can tell only the Macbook is of the same class, even business line notebooks have horrible keyboards, screens and touchpads. (in the best case you pick any 2 of those to be good.)
- ekianjo 10y agoI highly prefer older thinkpads' keyboards to the Macbook ones. And i'm not just talking about the fingertip pressure quality, but the layout as well.
- sedachv 10y agoMacbook chiclet keyboards are the worst possible keyboard in terms of key placement and shape (flat-top keys) in terms of typing speed and accuracy. There is a good paper about this in the first edition of Handbook of Human-Computer Interaction (copy is at home right now, will update with a better reference later). Even the "skateramp" shape of classic Thinkpad keyboards is not as good for speed and accuracy as the bowl-shaped keys of older keyboards and typewriters. The "skateramp" shape was a cost-cutting technique to enable keys to be cheaply labeled (bowl-shaped keys need to have the labels molded in in a two-step process: https://deskthority.net/wiki/Double-shot_molding https://deskthority.net/wiki/Double-shot_molding).
- sedachv 10y agoHere is the citation: Handbook of Human-Computer Interaction, Martin Helander, ed., 1990. Chapter 21, Section 4, "Key Size and Shape" on p. 483
- JohnStrange 10y agoBut Macbooks still only come with glare screens, or has this changed?
- yojex 10y agoMacbook Pros used to have brushed non-glare screens... and now the "Retina" has glare again. Why?
- terinjokes 10y agoFrom what I've seen and heard, the modern glare screens Apple uses on the Retina models has less glare than the predecessors. However, I see Retina-quality screens from a few other manufacturers, and those are offered in non-glare variants.
- yojex 10y agoA friend of mine has a 2011 or so MacBook Pro with a brushed/matte screen and it undeniably has less glare than the Retina screens. In fact it almost has no glare at all. No idea why Apple discontinued that.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoÆsthetic preference?
- Anasufovic 10y agoI believe color reproduction is better on the glossy screens.
- Theodores 10y agoGoogle Pixel has build quality far in excess of anything else I have seen including those Apple computers and those Thinkpad computers that others uphold as the benchmark of quality. I am delighted with the 2013 model, still available but only 4Gb RAM. RAM aside (not a problem for me) the keyboard is best out there as is the trackpad and the speakers. I believe the screen is the best too, because I prefer the 2:3 aspect ratio, but it may not have the most pixels etc. Everything is subjective but I think that the best hardware for a linux dev box is a rather high end Chromebook.
- dijit 10y ago4G of ram is really underpowered. my Thinkpad from 2010 has 8G and is smaller and still has a pretty good screen for it's size (1440x900 @ 12"). Newer laptops should not be a compromise like that or a downgrade, especially not at the price of a Pixel.
- yojex 10y agoYou should qualify "underpowered" with some specific use cases, as 4gb is definitely enough for some.
- dijit 10y agoConsidering the device was designed with chrome in mind and chrome routinely consumes 50% of my 8G (so, yeah 4G) I do believe that "Chrome + anything else" would qualify as over the limit of this device's ability to deliver. FWIW I don't need much ram otherwise, I live in the CLI which tends to be much leaner. But I do not have to justify needing more ram, I desire it, I currently have it, and the cost of my machine twice over is still less than the cost of a Pixel.
- yojex 10y agoPoint taken. I overlooked the detail that it is a Chromebook. Is it possible that Chrome is further optimized on these machines?
- lmm 10y agoI haven't put Linux on it myself yet, but how about the Surface Book? Keyboard, screen and touchpad are all wonderful.
- flukus 10y agoI thought thinkpads were linux friendly? Have you had problems with it?
- Neeek 10y agoNormally I'd have the same opinion about most laptops being shoddy built with a missing wifi or audio driver for linux here and there, but I've been playing around with the 14" HP Probook from 2012 I think? I haven't had much trouble running ubuntu on it and I'm very impressed with the build quality. Second hand, sandybridge i5 with some extra RAM thrown in, couldn't be happier :) I should also note that I'm by no means a power user, I'm still learning the ropes on Linux but I'm pretty fed up with Windows so I figure now is as good a time as any to make the transition! EDIT: It also occurred to me that you were probably talking about more current laptops, in which case I can't really help you, but apparently neither can apple so I guess we wait :(