2 ms·
The problem is that you can't really prove anything with counts over evidence, a.k.a. statistics. You can to the extent that you define your own measure of proo
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
The problem is that you can't really prove anything with counts over evidence, a.k.a. statistics. You can to the extent that you define your own measure of proof, a.k.a. p value. And as prof. Ioannides has shown, it's perfectly possible to overrule your own good judgement and set the standard too low.
And if this is the case, then what's wrong with "some form of deductive reasoning", as you put it? It would be great if more people applied the formal rules of deduction to their conceptual papers, and the work produced this way would not be less objective, less rigorous, or of lesser quality, than work that gathers some data and crunches the numbers over it, then calls it a day- quite the contrary.
If that is not the done thing then the problem is not with the conceptual papers per se, but rather with the way they are produced and one should advocate for better methodology, not different methods.