3 ms·
One should note that meta-analysis is a form of rigorous independent verification. It most definitely is not. Meta-analysis performs aggregation of existing re
by tremon 10y ago
One should note that meta-analysis is a form of rigorous independent verification.
It most definitely is not. Meta-analysis performs aggregation of existing research data in an attempt to validate specific research results for a larger group than initially tested. As such, it is primarily an inductive proof. That it can also validate or invalidate prior research is more of an artifact than a goal.
A rigorous independent verification can be performed deductively. No inference required.
- Fomite 10y agoThere are steps in properly performed meta-analysis that are very much about verification of a field of research as a whole, rather than a single study. For example, methods to detect likely publication bias, or heterogenity statistics that will indicate whether or not a given literature is in a state to be pooled at all. Both are methods to reveal "Something is wrong here..."