6 ms·
U.S. Signals Backing for Self-Driving Cars
- callesgg 10y agoWhat are the uber self driving system based on? What are the regulations regarding their safety?
- bertil 10y agoThe presence of a licensed driver in the car. That the driver is not touching the wheel is a little out-of-bound in that context.
- seanot 10y ago"The instructions signaled to motorists that automated vehicles would not be a Wild West where companies can try anything without oversight, but were also vague enough that automakers and technology companies would not fear overregulation." That ought to set back automated car evolution by twenty years. It's always fun to watch lawyers trying to write rules for industries in which the technologies change before the ink dries in the federal register.
- rayiner 10y agoFor example?
- jacquesm 10y agoThe internet comes to mind.
- rayiner 10y agoGovernment regulation of the Internet has been sparse and technologically-neutral. The CDMA Safe Harbor comes to mind. Not to mention the fact that Congress has gone to great lengths to deregulate any part of the Internet that changes rapidly. Is there an example you're thinking of?
- dmix 10y agoCrypto-currencies.
- rayiner 10y agoWhat about the government regulations for crypto-currencies makes them susceptible to being obsolete in light of technological changes?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- imglorp 10y agoThis is a hard problem because driving software is so complicated with many special cases. Life and safety code in general is hard. Do you want to mandate they apply aerospace coding technology? Like the other guy said, this could set them back 20 years. Mandate a traceability culture like ISO9000? How about third party audits? Escrow the code and mandate telemetry for NTSB to examine after an incident? Even if there are a few bugs, they'll still be safer than humans. Google's up to 1.5 million miles driven with no fatalities. The human metric to beat will be 1.2 fatalities per 100M miles.
- kalleboo 10y ago> Google's up to 1.5 million miles driven with no fatalities. The human metric to beat will be 1.2 fatalities per 100M miles I thought Google's speed limit was 25 mph? What's the human metric for fatalities at 25 mph?
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoGoogle's own designed cars are, not the Lexus models. But their stats are junk stats in another way: Test drivers simply intervene super regularly to avoid any sort of autonomous incident.
- jacquesm 10y agoThis is a very hard problem to solve. The longer the interval between interventions the bigger the chance that the 'driver' will not be able to intervene in time because they no longer have situational awareness.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI think the best judge of self-driving aptitude, though, would be "average contiguous self-driving miles driven". The total miles driven figure doesn't mean anything if a driver has to intervene every time you approach an intersection or something. Every time the test driver intervenes, reset the clock.
- pazra 10y agoOne thing I find surprising is that most geeks seem to be all for Self-Driving cars, yet are heavily against government surveillance. Yet self-driving cars are not only going to offer up much more surveillance data, but also offer a potential 'kill switch' backdoor that would allow nefarious agencies to drive you into a brick wall at 80mph and make it look like an accident. Once manual cars go away completely, you will not only loose control of your data, but also the certainty that your motor vehicle isn't going to act against you.
- trynumber9 10y agoAt least in my country if the government wanted to kill me they could do it with or without self-driving cars.
- okwhatthe2 10y agoAgreed. Security technologies are about to become front-and-center the way quality control of food and engineering are. Transparency is key
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI suppose this depends. If you have open source technology that isn't reliant on a cloud service to figure out how to drive, potentially we could be okay. Though a lot of companies are treating cloud tracking as a given right now.
- s_q_b 10y agoIf the security services target you, and truly wish to kill you, current methods will more than suffice. The Israelis like magnetic mines, the Russians polonium, the Yanks... Well to be perfectly honest I'm not sure, but it almost certainly involves some combination of clandestine airpower, special forces operations, OCO, and morbid obesity. Right now, the chain of devices that can track and kill you is enormous, from your router to your standard ICE Jeep. You're most likely already being tracked on traffic camera, the electronic toll system, cellular towers, passing Wifi, and the endless set of embedded Linux devices that you don't even consider. If you are targeted, there may be many obstacles to your removable from the board, including political, economic, or legal ramifications. But technical means will not be one of them.
- Shivetya 10y agoMaybe we will end up with the highways portrayed in tek war and other scifi, where you don't do the driving on limited access roadways but can or have to do it on side streets. it certainly would be easier to mark visually and electronically limited access routes like interstates. that in turn would make it simpler to create safe self driving cars. still I am not impressed as to where the tech as implemented on roads with current cars is today. they only work in ideal situations, the exact opposite of most safety equipment. its obvious they cannot rely on visual acquisition of objects, Tesla's system failed spectacularly in that area, so what will win out? RADAR? Laser? Combination of both?