4 ms·
> Only emails related to official business. The distinction is crucial to these questions of law, but is consistently forgotten or elided, even by this Hill art
by ars 10y ago
> Only emails related to official business. The distinction is crucial to these questions of law, but is consistently forgotten or elided, even by this Hill article.
It's not forgotten. No one believes her. (Except maybe you.)
She deleted the personal emails. Who does that? At most you don't turn them over, and then store them somewhere. Hard disks are cheap.
But no, she deleted them, making 100% sure no one could ever dispute her.
And I seem to remember an official email she did not disclose being discovered when the other person in the email disclosed it. So she is known to have withheld official emails.
- mozumder 10y agoIt's fine that she deleted her personal emails. Everyone does that. No one really cares about this issue except the House Republicans. They really are trying their hardest to figure out something here, but are obviously coming up empty. It just makes them look foolish.
- curried_haskell 10y agoAre you serious? Can you see you yourself right now? Take a step back, back from the politics, and think about the kind of behaviour you are defending right now. It's not even Hillary's behaviour that makes me lose the most faith in western democracy. It's people like you. The people who go around justifying this corruption because your candidate did it and the other candidate's party is trying to dig it up. You make me sick.
- sctb 10y agoWe've asked you to please comment civilly and substantively or not at all, and now you've added personal attacks. We ban accounts that continue to post this way. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- stonetear 10y agoI'm not a Republican and I care about this issue deeply.
- imron 10y agoPlease stay away from weight rooms, swimming pools, and avoid running alone at night.
- snowwrestler 10y agoDeleting personal emails is common and legal, even for the Secretary of State. You're essentially arguing that a person who desires privacy is therefore suspicious. I would hope that folks here on HN recognize that's a bullshit argument.
- mkohlmyr 10y agoNot quite. His argument is that she had the option to achieve privacy (by complying with the request and simply keeping her private emails). Instead they decided to not let anyone ever have the possibility to verify if she complied. She chose to achieve privacy by making any future investigation impossible. Is it legal? I guess, assuming she told the truth (and made no mistakes) about which emails were relevant. But personally I would like to hold people in office to a higher transparency and ethics standard than "strictly legal".
- snowwrestler 10y agoIf I came on here and said that Google should keep a copy of every email ever written or received in Gmail, just in case the police wanted to look at it later, how many folks here would think that is a good privacy policy? I'd guess not many. But that is what you're suggesting Clinton should have done with her personal email. If a piece of information is stored so that it can be given to someone else later, that's not really very private. Privacy means the right to keep things away from others, and it includes the right to delete things. Now maybe you want to argue that certain public officials should not permitted to have privacy while they are in office. That's fine, make that argument, but it's not the state of things now, legally or culturally. And consider that there might be unintended consequences. It might deter some great people from considering public service. And it might put a hole in the legal concept of privacy that others will try to widen later. I would argue that if we're going to be serious about legally protecting privacy, we need to be consistent. "Protect privacy, except for politicians I don't like" is not a particularly strong legal framework.
- ars 10y agoThe problem is you are taking her word for it. I think she's a liar, and her actions just reinforce that. I do NOT demand she hand over personal email! No. Only that she make it possible for a 3rd party to sort her emails into private/public. She has the right to delete personal email - but only if it's actually personal, and I don't trust her to be the one to decide that. She brought this on herself by mixing them in the first place. Want to maintain your privacy when you know you job requires publicity? Keep your public and private lives separate. She chose not to.