3 ms·
> Or perhaps just obtain the raw, patient-level data from said company and analyze the data ourselves? Data can be faked, manipulated, unless you can trace it
by ekianjo 10y ago
> Or perhaps just obtain the raw, patient-level data from said company and analyze the data ourselves?
Data can be faked, manipulated, unless you can trace it back to its origin and ensure it was recorded properly. There are multiple cases (even recent ones) where investigators modified the results of their trials in order to make them look better than they were.
Only replication can alleviate that concern.
- Twisell 10y agoThough critical reading of raw data can reveal fake entry, witch is equally interesting. I agree that replication will always be better and should ideally be mandatory. But meta-review is still way better than nothing. And sometimes you just can't replicate for various reasons.
- dangerlibrary 10y agoI don't think it's obvious that meta-review is better than nothing. It can lend credence to incorrect/fraudulent results, making actual replication appear less important.