7 ms·
> We can all agree this is a problem. Funny how nobody seemed to think so until now.
by mcphage 10y ago
> We can all agree this is a problem.
Funny how nobody seemed to think so until now.
- umanwizard 10y agoWho cares? Literally what point are you making? Dude, do you think this is a football game? That scoring a point against your opponent negates points scored against you? I suspect a big chunk of the people complaining about this would have complained even harder when Bush did it (if what you say is true), if they had been old enough to be aware what was going on, and had social media like we do now. So, what is your point? How does Bush doing it matter literally at all to whether Clinton should get in trouble?
- mcphage 10y ago> Literally what point are you making? The point I'm making is that I don't think you, or anybody else actually cares about the emails—they care it's something they can criticize Clinton for. Before her, nobody gave a shit. After her, nobody will give a shit. They don't matter, except that they can be used to criticize Clinton. So of course nobody complained about it with Bush, because nobody cares about them. > I suspect a big chunk of the people complaining about this would have complained even harder when Bush did it (if what you say is true), if they had been old enough to be aware what was going on They wouldn't have. The rest of us had much bigger complaints to make, that complaining about deleting emails would have been a laughable waste of time.
- oldmanjay 10y agoAre you trying to claim that no one complained about Bush? If so, I have to assume you are rather young.
- mcphage 10y ago> Are you trying to claim that no one complained about Bush? No, we complained constantly. But we had more important things to complain about then where his email server was.
- umanwizard 10y ago> The point I'm making is that I don't think you, or anybody else actually cares about the emails Based on what evidence? > they care it's something they can criticize Clinton for. I'm no fan of Trump either. I wish Clinton were a good candidate so she would wipe the floor with him. > So of course nobody complained about it with Bush, because nobody cares about them. I was 12 years old when Bush was elected. That's why I didn't care about whatever he may or may not have done. You know absolutely nothing about me or anyone else and you are presuming people's motives without any evidence or justification.
- Retric 10y agoBased on nobody criticizing the several prior people in that same position that did the exact same thing. Sure, if it was just one or two that's one thing, but A email is public in the first place and B when your the fifth person in a row to do something you generally assume that's just how it's done.
- nitsujio 10y agoMcphage is trolling when he says nobody cared about Bush's emails. Politifact tells the truth of it: http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2015/mar/15/juan-williams/media-reaction-george-w-bushs-email-controversy/ http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2015/mar/15/... Mcphage is trolling. Let's not feed him anymore.
- PKop 10y agoI served in Iraq and Afghanistan. I was held to a high standard in regards to OPSEC and security around classified information. Being as careless or purposely negligent as she was would have gotten me or anyone else court martialed. Hillary Clinton is a grown ass woman. She knows what she'd doing. She held a position of high responsibility, that deals with highly sensitive intel that impacts many facets of national security, and had an obligation to keep her correspondence secure as well as open to FOIA requests. That she didn't, and has repeatedly lied about it, should concern everyone. That she was willing to leave her server open to possible hacking simply for personal convenience and gain, should concern everyone. It does me. How is it just deleting emails? She's literally hiding her tracks and doesn't want people to see what she's talking about. And when caught, she lies and deletes the evidence. I honestly do not understand how someone like you, who ostensibly is lecturing us about simply being rah rah for "our team" can NOT care about this. Honestly how can't you? You are literally telling us not to look at it through the lens of our favored political party. So then don't. How is this defensible? I'm a little less familiar about previous instances, but if you're referring to Colin Powell's actions.. from what I've read they are no where near the extent to which she used private server for gov't communication.. BUT! I absolutely do not support him doing it either! If he broke a law, he should be prosecuted. I'd be ok with it happening even now. Do laws and regulations have any meaning anymore if they don't apply to those at the top? We all have our favorites, and surely there is hypocrisy when we like to look the other way when it's "our guy/gal"... next time something like this happens I'll definitely care then too. A big part of it is about what kind of precedent it sets for future politicians. How much more will they hide from the public with no threat of consequences?
- gjolund 10y agoGreat response, looking forward to seeing their reply.
- koube 10y agoHe's not talking about Powell's actions, where Powell recommended that Clinton use a private email. He's talking about the Bush administration, who avoided any email controversy on their private email server simply by deleting all 22 million emails. None of them broke any law, as laid out by Comey, who is famous for bashing heads with politicians. The law was executed by Comey faithfully and there was no crime to prosecute.
- gjolund 10y agoI ran IT for a financial firm that went through an FBI investigation, if i had done this (like they asked repeatedly) I would have gone to jail.
- gjolund 10y agoI ran IT for a financial firm that went through an FBI investigation, if i had done this (like they asked repeatedly) I would have gone to jail.
- ben174 10y agoOn the football game analogy: yes, there are two teams. One of these teams will win. Both teams suck but at the end of the day, most people will want to vote for the person who made the most points. It's actually exactly what it is.
- umanwizard 10y agoI am not discussing who you should vote for. I am discussing whether Hillary Clinton is a corrupt person. Those are two different questions. If Trump[1] is even worse, then sure, vote for Hillary. But that doesn't mean that she's good or that people have to like her. As an aside: if that were the argument Hillary fans had been making the whole time: "Yeah, we know Hillary is bad and corrupt, but at least she's way better than Trump, so you should vote for her", then I would respect them a lot more. Instead, it's mostly been a chorus of "OMG, why are you dragging up conspiracy theories about her e-mails! You right-wing simpleton! Go back to Breitbart and argue about lizard people!" Nothing is more annoying than people being smug when they're actually wrong. [1]: Trump is Hillary's competition, in case anyone didn't know. Not sure why anyone is still talking about Bush.
- psyklic 10y agoThis reads very presumptuously. The FBI stated she was reckless yet did nothing illegal. Reckless neither implies bad nor corrupt.
- metiscus 10y agoHere is the thing. When you are cleared onto a classified project or given access to classified data, you sign several documents in which you accept responsibility for safeguarding our national security by protecting that information. If an employee of Lockheed Martin engaged in similar behavior, e.g. making references to SCI information outside of a SCIF, with only properly cleared personnel they could go to prison. Regardless of the markings she caused SCI information to be transmitted in the clear which shows a certain level of disregard for the policies that are in place to protect us and it would appear that she did so for her own convenience (if you assume the most pure motives). The reader will have to decide if this behavior, while adjudicated as reckless but not criminal is a simple instance of poor judgement by her handlers or indicative of deeper issues with the candidate.
- joemi 10y agoIs it possible that by Bush setting a precedence, it being done now is OK?
- umanwizard 10y agoWhy would that be the case? How do you think the law works? Just because the President breaks the law doesn't magically change the law...
- joemi 10y agoHonestly, I don't know the applicable laws very well (or at all). This was just an honest question. Given all the contention over the HRC email thing and specifically over this reddit revelation, I'm not so sure that the situation we have is clearly defined within the laws (otherwise why wouldn't everything be clear cut and decided already?).
- koube 10y agoThe law behind the mishandling of classified information is from the 1950s and is mostly outdated. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/jurisprudence/2016/07/the_hillary_clinton_email_scandal_shows_the_espionage_act_is_outdated.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/jurisprudenc... What is clear however, is that judging Clinton's mishandling of emails as a crime, when only one person in a hundred years in completely different circumstances has been prosecuted for the same crime, would be unprecedented. http://www.politico.com/blogs/under-the-radar/2016/07/heres-the-other-gross-negligence-case-comey-cited-in-clinton-email-testimony-225266 http://www.politico.com/blogs/under-the-radar/2016/07/heres-...
- patrickg_zill 10y agoThere was a guy prosecuted this year for similar security lapses. He went to jail. Snowden wrote in wired, though the article doesn't cover the latest news https://www.wired.com/2015/09/snowden-people-get-fired-prosecuted-hillary-clinton/ https://www.wired.com/2015/09/snowden-people-get-fired-prose...
- mc32 10y agoOne other aspect is that expectations change. While it was acceptable to send and receive email in plain text at one point and access email over http, that's likely not the case any longer. In a fast paced environment, procedures and expectations can be expected to evolve accordingly.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ethanbond 10y agoUhh Bush is one of the least popular presidents ever, for a wide swath of reasons. It's not like he was some god above public opinion.
- forgottenpass 10y agoFunny how nobody seemed to think so until now. I did. This was just one of many mini-scandals under Bush that never really seemed to boil over. I thought it was a problem then, still think it's a problem now, but now know why nobody held him to the fire: they were doing that shit too.