3 ms·
The article somehow seems to conflate road layout with population density, peppered with some vague arguments in favour of high density building. I agree that
by wongarsu 10y ago
The article somehow seems to conflate road layout with population density, peppered with some vague arguments in favour of high density building.
I agree that a lot of America's traffic problems are related to their low-density suburbs, and there are many arguments why these suburbs are not all that great. But that is completely seperate from road layouts: you can build a cul-de-sac with high-density buildings, add a few footpaths and get basically all the advantages listed.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoI got exactly the same impression. The cul-de-sac per se isn't even addressed. Taking it as symbolic, the article's main argument for grid layouts seems to be little more than "everyone was doing it 100 years ago, and we found a handful of favorable correlations, so they must have been on to something".
- dx034 10y agoExactly, add a few footpaths to cul-de-sacs and you encourage walking/cycling while having low traffic noise. Works well in many European countries.