6 ms·
This article seems to totally gloss over the advantages of cul-de-sac and suburban living. Having just moved from the a more dense area of the city (after 10+ y
by cortesoft 10y ago
This article seems to totally gloss over the advantages of cul-de-sac and suburban living. Having just moved from the a more dense area of the city (after 10+ years) to a much more suburban area, I am keenly aware of the new perks I now have.
The first one is obviously space. Suburbs can have bigger houses and bigger yards. That is a very nice perk. I am not saying that bigger is always better, but you can't just dismiss this as not being important at all. Having a backyard where I can BBQ and a garage I can park in are pretty nice.
Second, the article talks about the increased overall danger from traffic accidents in the city, but they don't talk about actual accidents in the cul-de-sac itself. If you live in a cul-de-sac, your kids can play in the street much more safely than if you are in a city grid. Being able to play in the street is a nice thing.
Again, I don't think that there isn't a cost to suburban cul-de-sac living, I just feel this article completely ignores the actual benefits, instead focusing on a few parts that I don't think people are actually claiming about the suburbs.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoI think the problem is that the people who enjoy the benefits are not the people bearing the cost. It's great for you if you want to live on a cul-de-sac in San Ramon, but it's not great that you now need to drive your car to work on an elevated freeway through Oakland. Without having ruined that neighborhood, the property in San Ramon would be all but worthless. If people in exurbs all rode the train to work then probably fewer people would be tut-tutting about their odd streetscape.
- mikeash 10y agoThat seems backwards to me. The natural state of things is no roads. In the human world, we typically start with property rights, and only take them away when it's deemed necessary. Looking at it that way, it's the road users who are enjoying benefits while foisting costs off on the residents whose property they drive past (or whose former property they drive over).
- rev_bird 10y agoParent commenter wrote: "[t]he problem is that the people who enjoy the benefits are not the people bearing the cost... if you want to live on a cul-de-sac in San Ramon... you now need to drive your car to work on an elevated freeway through Oakland." You wrote: "[i]t's the road users who are enjoying benefits while foisting costs off on the residents whose property they drive past (or whose former property they drive over)." I'm pretty sure you two agree.
- mikeash 10y agoI do think you're right. I thought they were saying that culs-de-sac screwed up transportation networks, but now I don't know why. Sorry! Consider that to be strenuous agreement instead, OP.
- baddox 10y ago> I thought they were saying that culs-de-sac screwed up transportation networks, but now I don't know why. I think there's some truth to that as well. Government roads in suburbs obviously drive down the population density and encourage the use of cars, which definitely makes mass transportation less viable.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoThis has been a really common theme of city planning discussions on HN. A lot of urban dwellers don't understand the appeal of suburban living, and would rather brand it as "wrong" than accept that not every living situation is there for their preferences.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- davidw 10y agoI'm pretty firmly in the "market urbanism" camp: I accept that people have different preferences, but please don't foist them on me. If you want to live in a suburb, fine: pay for it (all that infrastructure has a lot of costs associated with it), and stop trying to make things like corner stores or denser housing illegal. http://marketurbanism.com/ http://marketurbanism.com/
- zzleeper 10y agoI've lived in a suburban setting most of my life until a few years. Sure, there are advantages, but all in all not worth it. I've spend way more time doing stuff out of the house than what I would spend in my garage or extra large home office. And most of this stuff would not be possible or would be really hard if I lived further away, in an area with less pop. density.
- mahyarm 10y agoA lot of us grew up in a suburban setting, and did not like it. We moved to an urban setting for a reason.
- criddell 10y agoI grew up in a small town and thought life there was pretty good until I moved to a city for university. Once I got a taste of living in a city, I didn't think I would ever return and couldn't understand why so many people live out there. Then I had kids and we moved to the suburbs and I like living here better than any place I've lived before. Once self-driving cars are a thing, I'm buying one and moving even further out of the city. Interestingly, there's been a lot of office space being built around me. I think companies that have a lot of suburban employees are moving to the suburbs (including my employer).
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoI think I was four years old. My mother let my brother (5) and I walk our bikes down to the nearby cul-de-sac, and ride them there. (We lived on a narrow street, with little traffic, but still a through street.) Some time later, she heard the sirens. She looked out the window as an ambulance went past our house, down toward the cul-de-sac. She came running down to find is sitting on our bikes watching the ambulance go past. A car had hit a boy crossing our street. It paralyzed him. So, that's anecdote instead of data. But cul-de-sacs are a safer place for kids on bikes, scooters, skateboards, and just playing in the street. (Safer, not safe. I got mildly bloodied in a bike-on-bike collision in that exact same cul-de-sac...)
- dpark 10y ago> So, that's anecdote instead of data. But cul-de-sacs are a safer place for kids You agree that it's not days and yet you assert the truth of cul de sac safety based on your anecdote. :/ I wonder if data actually backs this up or not. Arterials are almost certainly less safe than cul de sacs just based on traffic volume and speed, but I wonder if that's the case for reasonably quiet residential streets. I've seen idiots driving through small residential streets at dangerous speeds occasionally, but I've also seen idiots screech in and out of driveways to turn around on cul de sacs.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> You agree that it's not days and yet you assert the truth of cul de sac safety based on your anecdote. :/ No, I assert the truth of cul-de-sac safety, but not based on my anecdote. I assert it based on... let's call it intuition, or prejudice if you're going to be less charitable to me. I admit that I don't have the data. > Arterials are almost certainly less safe than cul de sacs just based on traffic volume and speed... Agreed, though again, neither of us have data here. > I've seen idiots driving through small residential streets at dangerous speeds occasionally, but I've also seen idiots screech in and out of driveways to turn around on cul de sacs. My suspicion is that the through residential streets see more of this, because the turn arounds in cul-de-sacs are by mistake, but going through the residential street is on purpose.
- 10y ago
- wst_ 10y agoWould you elaborate on how is it nice to play on the street? For some reason I can't think of it being nice - quite opposite - I think it is dangerous (not to mention I don't see any fun in it). No matter the traffic is smaller. One car is enough to kill your kid.
- criddell 10y agoOn a cul-de-sac, almost all the traffic is of people that live there. Hours can go by with absolutely no traffic.
- turar 10y agoAt the same time, for kids to play together, you need to get lucky and have other kids live nearby. A grid system is much easier to navigate for kids, even if their friends live 4 blocks over East and then 2 blocks North. In a cul-de-sac neighborhood, that same distance if drawn with a straight line is impossible to walk that way. It can quickly become daunting for kids to follow neverending mazes, often without any sidewalks. Sidewalks are another issue. In car-oriented neighborhoods they are often non-existent, or an afterthought on only one side of the street. Sometimes they just randomly end, only to start again half a mile down the road. In older grid neighborhoods, sidewalks are wide, often separated from the street with a tree line, and are on both sides of the street. They are almost inviting kids to come play on them.
- criddell 10y agoMy home is on a street that only feeds cul-de-sacs. Almost every house has kids in it. Plus, there are trails connecting all of the different neighborhoods. Within a short walk of my house (< 1/2 mile) are tennis courts, basketball courts, swimming pools, soccer/football fields, and multiple playgrounds. It's all maintained by the HOA. Also, there are sidewalks everywhere. My one big complaint is that the street lighting is pretty bad.
- wst_ 10y agoAnd that's I think is even more dangerous. You may get surprised the most by something that you expect the least. Well, I am glad you guys could stay safe, but I would rather send my daughter to play in some sort of kinder garden, park, or some facility made for that purpose rather then allowing her playing on the street. Still, it is my personal feeling only, because I've had never lived in a suburbs like this.
- Cogito 10y agoAren't these orthogonal concerns, mostly? There is no reason you need cul-de-sacs in order to have large lots. In fact, it's often easier to have more usable space in a grid system because you aren't dealing with as many curves. The suburbs have more space because they are the suburbs, not because they have cul-de-sacs. To your second point, suburbs don't suddenly become 'city grids' with all the traffic that implies just because they use a grid layout. Yes, traffic will almost certainly be higher in front of your house if you are not in a cul-de-sac, but that doesn't mean it's unsafe for kids to play there. There are a lot of quiet suburban streets, built on a grid, and kids definitely play in them. The article makes the point that grids actually decrease the amount of traffic, and its speed. It seems likely that the variation of traffic conditions is much lower; every street has some traffic, but no streets have lots of traffic. Grids promote walking and cycling, and are potentially serviced by public transport better (likely because they weren't designed car-first). So yes, there are benefits to living in a cul-de-sac, but I would think most of those benefits come from living in a suburb in the first place. The cul-de-sacs, as opposed to a grid system, just make suburbs a worse place to live overall.
- ajmurmann 10y agoI didn't understand the article to be against suburbs but against the cul-de-sac supporting layout that makes it hard for people to get around without a car. If suburbs were designed differently we could have both space and easier walkability and bikeability. How would you feel about a grid with parks sprinkled in instead of cul-de-sac? I have a small public park across the street and it gets heavy usage from the kids that live around it. Traffic is still pretty low despite the street connecting the neighborhood to the main thoroughfare that leads to the freeway. My wife used to own a home in a development in California that was actually designed around cul-de-sacs. However, there were walk ways between houses that allowed you to get around on foot quickly and be in less than 5 minutes at a small mall that had a grocery store, cafes etc. That also might solve some issues discussed in the article. I do think that the boneheaded zoning in the US that practically aims to ruin walkability is as always a huge factor as well.
- jdswain 10y agoThere are quite a few interestingly designed cities in the UK. I used to work in Bracknell which is similar to what you suggest with walking paths and basically parks around many of the houses, especially in an estate called Great Hollands (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Hollands https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Hollands). They also have small roads that are dedicated to buses, with underpasses so that they avoid intersections. I didn't live there so I don't know a lot about it, but it did look really good and I used to go for runs along the paths there. Another interesting one to visit is Milton Keynes. This city has a large grid layout with roundabouts at the intersections, and smaller communities inside each grid block. The grid layout is intended to allow for large flows of traffic.
- jeffwass 10y ago>How would you feel about a grid with parks sprinkled in instead of cul-de-sac? Check out Savannah, Georgia. One of the first planned cities in the USA. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squares_of_Savannah,_Georgia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squares_of_Savannah,_Georgia
- muninn_ 10y agoAs others have pointed out, you can still obtain the benefits of the suburbs while not having to live in a suburban desert. If you wanted to fix the suburbs, you'd have to change zoning laws and make those areas much more walkable. That would mean allowing businesses to be sprinkled in with the homes. The most successful communities (which are now being or have been gentrified) are walkable, mixed-use development neighborhoods. They have parks sprinkled throughout in addition to businesses, shops, restaurants, schools, and streets that are not through streets, have two lanes, cars parked on either side, and a bike lane between the parking spaces and the sidewalk.
- dpark 10y agoI don't see how you can have those benefits in the suburbs. Restaurants fail at a very high rate. How can you afford to run a restaurant in the middle of the suburbs where the population density is so low? Other business face a similar dilemma. Can you afford to build a shop in the middle of a sparse neighborhood? Will the residents shop there or just drive to the big box just past the edge of the development? And on the off chance you manage to build a successful urban-esque neighborhood in the middle of the suburbs, how do you prevent the massive influx of traffic that would undoubtedly come from the nearby suburbs? And how will you justify preventing that traffic when it impacts the livelihoods of the shop owners who took the risk to open there? I don't believe that you can build a mixed-use, walkable neighborhood in the suburbs where lots are a third of an acre each. Density is what makes mixed-use possible.
- muninn_ 10y agoIn regard to traffic, I think you just let it happen, and provide metered parking on the streets. If the traffic gets bad enough then people will use the bike lanes between the cars and sidewalk, or the sidewalks. One mistake I think we make is this idea that we have to prevent vehicle traffic at all costs. Not only does it absolutely never work, it costs money and generally causes the areas where you're attempting to improve traffic to transform into drive through areas. Then we wind up with fast food chains everywhere... . I also should have been more clear in my original post. I was trying to be subtle and make enough suggestions about improving a suburb that we actually turn it into a neighborhood :)
- retrogradeorbit 10y agoWhat makes a gridded layout have smaller blocks? I live in a gridded layout and I have a large backyard, as do all those in my suburb. And when I compare with the suburbs with the cul-de-sac layout I see their backyards are smaller! This is in Australia, and maybe it's different where you are, but there is nothing in the grid layout stopping larger blocks. On your second point I wouldn't dismiss the articles argument completely. Where I live there are often children playing in the street. Games of football and cricket. Kids skateboarding and roller skating. Cars drive quite slowly because it tends to be local traffic. With all the stop signs it's far more efficient for cars to traverse the suburb on one of the arterial roads, so most of the traffic drives out of the grid to get anywhere. When I find myself driving in cul-de-sac suburbs I find I get frustrated and tend to drive faster, because getting where I am going is a huge convoluted drive. Where I want to go is literally 200 meters away and to get there I have to drive 3 km. It's very frustrating.
- gnopgnip 10y agoI live on a cul de sac in Alameda with a bike/walking path that connects it to other streets. If you want to get to a house one street over it will take you a few minutes to drive but it is a short walk to cut across. The speed limit is 25 in most of the city.