2 ms·
Many things that end up changing the world start out very small. Think about the Altair (hobbyist kit), Microsoft (dorm-room project), Linux (grad student proj
by nostrademons 10y ago
Many things that end up changing the world start out very small. Think about the Altair (hobbyist kit), Microsoft (dorm-room project), Linux (grad student project), Facebook (dorm-room project), Google (grad student project), Twitter (weekend project), the WWW (CERN project), penicillin (moldy petri dish), saccharin (unusually sweet bread), radioactivity (a cloudy day), etc.
Many other things that promise to be huge moonshots end up being huge fizzles instead. Think about AI the first time around, VR the first time around, pen computing the first time around, flying cars, supersonic transports, and of course the literal moonshot, which got us to the moon 6 times and then we never went back.
I'm sure many smart people will disagree with me on this, but when I see lots of money invested in a moonshot, I usually think "That's an awful lot of people who are about to spend years of their lives chasing an image of what the future looks like rather than discovering what the actual future will look like."
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoNone of these contradict my point though. You only mention where those started. They wouldn't be where they are today without outside investment. WWW, penicillin etc... are great examples of significant investment before there was a tangible way to afford growing and scaling distribution through revenue/bootstrapping. It's hard for frontier technology projects (ML/AI, AR/VR, Genetics, Robotics etc...) to even get out of the lab without significant investment, as the personnel needed have so many lucrative options and they are generally done by older people with relatively high personal burn rates (kids, mortgage etc...). chasing an image of what the future looks like rather than discovering what the actual future will look like That doesn't make sense. By definition you have to blaze a trail in new technology/markets - you don't chase an image. The image you have is the the world you build - and hopefully people respond.
- nostrademons 10y agoThe difference is in the feedback cycle. Innovations in the first category get released in a minimal form, exposed to real users, receive input from a variety of sources, and only then get capital to expand. Innovations in the second category are a "big idea", get lots of capital to build it out...and then very often, miss the mark when it comes to having a lasting effect on society, because without that feedback cycle, they don't fit into everyday life in a useful way. It's not a matter of "hopefully people respond", except for the initial first draft (which, if you're smart, you'll make as simple and minimal as possible). It's a matter of testing things out and then observing what people do respond to, then going down that path. Once you've validated the business model, you can take capital to bring it to more people, but taking capital itself does not help you identify that model any faster.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoWe're saying the same thing. I don't even reference the first example because those aren't really in the ballpark I'm talking about. Lean principles still apply to moonshots IMO.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoCouldn't agree more! VR the first three or four times around. Fusion - the first 70 years it's been 20 years away. :) As you say many (most?) things that changed the world either started very small, or were serendipitous (freak accident if you prefer). Even engineering led discoveries started with few, if any, applications. Take the laser, originally thought it might be useful in spectography and radar. No one was conceiving of CDs, fibre optics, tattoo removal, barcode scanners and the numerous other uses. The entirety of our industry is based on what followed from building a machine to crack German codes, and from trying to calculate artillery firing tables quicker. Right about the time the US was commissioning ENIAC, HM Gov was smashing up Colossus and burning blueprints, and we'd have to wait 30 years to hear of Tommy Flowers and Colossus. I think it's safe to believe most of the truly ground breaking ideas will come from entirely unexpected people, places and fields, and that there's a lot more good ones tucked away behind increasingly hard to fund blue sky research. We'll get some slick applications of AI, VR and data driven computing, and many of them will be marvelous (and many not), and a fortune will be spent. But the actual world changers are likely elsewhere. I hope at least some will be from the founders who've cashed out a Unicorn and are now using their funds to chase the undelivered dreams elsewhere (SpaceX etc). I just wish there were a few more so we can get there a bit quicker! :)