5 ms·
It's not at all clear that Clapper committed perjury. He took an oath long before he testified at that hearing to not reveal certain secrets to unauthorized peo
by tzs 10y ago
It's not at all clear that Clapper committed perjury. He took an oath long before he testified at that hearing to not reveal certain secrets to unauthorized people, and that oath was backed by laws passed by Congress.
He also took an oath later to testify truthfully at that Congressional committee hearing.
When those oaths conflict, which one takes priority?
Note that due to the nature of Wyden's question, Clapper could not simply say that he could not answer and give as the reason for not answering that it would require revealing classified information, because that itself would strongly imply that the answer was "yes".
Also, didn't Wyden already know the answer to the question? I thought I read that the members of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence (and also those of the corresponding House committee) knew about these programs. If so, then Clapper's answer (no matter what he said) would convey no relevant information to the Committee. At common law, that would rule out any possibility of it being perjury. I don't know if there is a similar exception in the relevant perjury statutes for Congressional testimony.
- imagist 10y ago> It's not at all clear that Clapper committed perjury. He took an oath long before he testified at that hearing to not reveal certain secrets to unauthorized people, and that oath was backed by laws passed by Congress. This is true, but it's bizarre that that the "Unauthorized people" would include Congress. > When those oaths conflict, which one takes priority? That might be a relevant question for whether or not he should be pardoned for committing perjury, but it's not a relevant question to deciding whether he committed perjury.
- hsod 10y ago> That might be a relevant question for whether or not he should be pardoned for committing perjury, but it's not a relevant question to deciding whether he committed perjury. I'm not a lawyer, but it could perhaps be an affirmative defense [0]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_defense https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_defense
- vaadu 10y agoWhen oaths conflict, lying to Congress is still a crime. His non-criminal response should have been "I am not at liberty to discuss program details" or something along those lines.
- niccaluim 10y agoAnd if the mere fact of the program's existence is classified? There's no way to respond without violating one of the oaths.
- EthanHeilman 10y ago"As you might expect I am unable to provide any comments which will confirm the existence or non-existence of such programs." They say that all the time.
- natmaster 10y agoYou shouldn't take oaths you can't keep. Taking both led him to lie, so no matter what he did he was violating his oath.
- Zigurd 10y agoThere are two reasons I can think of off the top of my head why that should not have been a problem: 1. Congressional committees that handle classified information can use closed-door sessions to hear these kinds of answers. There was no need for Clapper to lie. 2. Clapper also took an oath to uphold the constitution, before any other more specific oaths. It is difficult to see how lying to Congress fulfills this oath. At best your argument rests on whether Wyden knew the answer and the common law argument that no answer could then be perjury. But there was no reason for Clapper to lie to a committee of the Congress.