4 ms·
I don't understand how someone can think this is true. Like, what, you drop your toast with jam on the floor, pick it up in a second, the jam is full of hairs/d
by StavrosK 10y ago
I don't understand how someone can think this is true. Like, what, you drop your toast with jam on the floor, pick it up in a second, the jam is full of hairs/dust/debris and you figure it's fine?
- tbrake 10y agoNo, no one thinks that way with regards to any kind of food item with stickiness and the 5 second rule. The thought revolves around dry foods and the (mistaken) impression they're unlikely to accumulate any kind of debris and dust. Peanuts, pretzels, etc.
- thomasahle 10y agoThat's my impression too. You explain the rule to children, so they can pick up peanuts they drop on the floor, but don't go eating peanuts they find dropped by other people a long time ago.
- rantanplan 10y agoYour logic has many bugs. What's wrong with just explaining that they shouldn't eat stuff from the ground. Period?
- jerf 10y agoDo you have children? "Explaining they shouldn't do X" and "the child don't do X" are, ah, much less correlated than you might like. At times they can be downright reverse correlated.
- coldtea 10y ago>What's wrong with just explaining that they shouldn't eat stuff from the ground. Period? Wasting food for no good reason. And making them paranoid about germs.
- rantanplan 10y agoThat makes sense(especially about the germs paranoia).
- coldtea 10y agoThe way I see it, if they're too small, you need to watch them anyway, or else they will put everything on their mouth, not just dropped food. If they are over that, they're smart enough to understand that they don't eat jelly sandwitch off of the floor, or something they dropped in a public street. But for a casual hard food stuff they dropped on the kitchen floor or living room etc, they can sweep it and eat it -- and get some germ resistance too. E.g.: Just as a baby's brain needs stimulation, input, and interaction to develop normally, the young immune system is strengthened by exposure to everyday germs so that it can learn, adapt, and regulate itself, notes Thom McDade, PhD, associate professor and director of the Laboratory for Human Biology Research at Northwestern University. Exactly which germs seem to do the trick hasn't yet been confirmed. But new research offers clues. In a recent study, McDade's team found that children who were exposed to more animal feces and had more cases of diarrhea before age 2 had less incidence of inflammation in the body as they grew into adulthood. Inflammation has been linked to many chronic adulthood illnesses, such as heart disease, diabetes, and Alzheimer's. "We're moving beyond this idea that the immune system is just involved in allergies, autoimmune diseases, and asthma to think about its role in inflammation and other degenerative diseases," McDade says. "Microbial exposures early in life may be important… to keep inflammation in check in adulthood." (WebMD) or: http://news.ubc.ca/2016/08/10/why-your-kids-should-play-in-the-dirt/ http://news.ubc.ca/2016/08/10/why-your-kids-should-play-in-t...
- jsz0 10y agoSociety. Kids that are raised outside of what is considered the acceptable social norm often have problems adjusting when they get older. For example I actively try to avoid eating out at restaurants with people who are too fussy about their food. It's usually an awkward uncomfortable scene. I'd much rather share a meal with a '5 second rule' type of person.
- rantanplan 10y agoOk, although I didn't get the part about "eating out at restaurants with people who are too fussy about their food". Are there adults out there who are fussy with their food? In what way?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jschwartzi 10y agoMy friends and I joke about it, but I didn't think anyone took it seriously.
- coldtea 10y agoIt's obviously not about debris/hairs/dust but germs. In other words, if a person saw hairs/dust/debris in their jam that fell on the floor, they wouldn't eat it anyway. But if something less sticky (and more solid) was dropped, say an apple or a pizza piece that fall on the bread side, they might pick it up, sweep it a little, and eat it. In fact, 5-second-rule or not, most people will be fine for doing so anyway, as long as they do it on their relatively clean home -- with germs that they are usually in contact anyway.
- StavrosK 10y agoEh, sure, if it's a pretzel or a piece of candy or whatever, we (in my country) will pick it up, blow on it a bit, wipe it a bit and eat it. It depends on where it fell and how sticky the food is, but obviously "time spent on the floor" isn't really a factor.
- coldtea 10y ago>Eh, sure, if it's a pretzel or a piece of candy or whatever, we (in my country) will pick it up, blow on it a bit, wipe it a bit and eat it. It depends on where it fell and how sticky the food is, but obviously "time spent on the floor" isn't really a factor. It might might not be a conscious following of the 5-second-rule, but I'm sure the people in your country would still pick it up fast and not let it collect germs kana eikosalepto before eating it.
- StavrosK 10y agoEikosalepto is a lot, but eh, you just wouldn't agitate it while it was down. Three, five or ten seconds don't matter that much.