3 ms·
This article unfortunately conflates the value (or absence of value) of the death penalty with the unpleasantness involved with carrying it out. If the process
by mhb 10y ago
This article unfortunately conflates the value (or absence of value) of the death penalty with the unpleasantness involved with carrying it out.
If the process were better would he still be opposed to it?
- willvarfar 10y ago> After much contemplation, I became convinced that, on a moral level, life was either hallowed or it wasn’t. And I wanted it to be. Also > I could not see that execution did anything to enhance public safety.
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoI'm not sure he really conflates the two things any more than necessary. The unpleasantness he describes is the result of moral doubts about killing a person who no longer poses a threat to anyone. What he does, in my view, is to suggest that these doubts are justified and society as a whole should have those doubts as well. In other words, he gives a human face to the agony that society should feel about this. He isn't saying, oh the death penalty is great, but it feels so bad to administer it for some reason, so let's save ourselves the trouble, shall we?