4 ms·
I'm an economic immigrant- I work and live in a different country (the UK) than the one I was born, and brought up, in (Greece). Immigration is singled out as
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
I'm an economic immigrant- I work and live in a different country (the UK)
than the one I was born, and brought up, in (Greece).
Immigration is singled out as an issue because of its emotional impact (and
that impact is greatly amplified by the political debate that feeds off it).
Every other aspect of our common life has the ability to hurt some peoples'
bottom line and benefit that of others'. That's politics in a nutshell: when
some social condition changes, some groups benefit and some others stand to
lose.
But then, why is losing out to immigrants more of an issue than losing out to local competition? Why would you be more upset if a foreigner gets your job than if
a local does? The issue is that someone else got your job- that's the bit that
hurts you. That the person is foreign may be adding insult to injury, but
kicking all the bloody foreigners out is not magically going to give you the
skills you need to do the job you currently can't. It's not going to make it more profitable for an employer to hire you at a higher wage if you have the skills to do the job, either.
A lot more could be achieved on the immigration front if countries spent all
that energy towards training their local workforce better.
But let's not also forget that when a foreign worker is paid less for more
work his or her intersts are also harmed- better enforced labour legislation
is to the benefit of all workers.
As to the natural effect of prices coming down for all when there's more of a
workforce- on the one hand that can be addressed partially by a better trained
workforce (which is mroe productive and can therefore afford to ask for better
wages). On the other hand, maybe we can agree that once the market for a given
skill is saturated, the price of that skill is the closest possible to the
true value of the skill.
- r_smart 10y ago>why is losing out to immigrants more of an issue than losing out to local competition? The trouble is that the laws, in the US at least, are set up and (not) enforced in such a way as to advantage people coming from abroad. The H1-B is a good example. Employers want H1-Bs because they can lower wages (through job title manipulation and increasing the pool of available workers), while essentially handcuffing the employee to them. This isn't really fair competition. The local employee didn't lose because of being inadequate, they lost because of external forces making it extremely difficult to compete. Personally, I'm all for making legal immigration and naturalization a much easier and faster process, but I also want some of these weird visas done away with. They want to move here, let them come, but don't game the system to the detriment of local workers, and to some extent the immigrant, though they'll likely be living better than where they came from, but not as well as they should be.
- davidw 10y ago> That's politics in a nutshell: when some social condition changes, some groups benefit and some others stand to lose Perhaps, but there are many, many things that are 'positive sum games', some that are zero sum games, and some that are negative sum games. Immigration is generally a positive sum game, writ large.