5 ms·
Following this line of thought, why aren't people currently working 7 days a week? People who work 56hrs will earn more than those working 48, and even more tha
by belorn 10y ago
Following this line of thought, why aren't people currently working 7 days a week? People who work 56hrs will earn more than those working 48, and even more than those that just work 40hrs.
One answer might just be norms. If only 10% of people work 56hrs, then you don't earn so little that you can't afford "that expensive thing that everybody has". What everybody has is based on norms and averages.
A question is then how we went from working 7 days a week, to 6 days a week and Sundays in church, to 5 days a week. How did people start to work less and live with the reality of earning less in comparison to those staying with the old working hours.
- denzil_correa 10y ago> One answer might just be norms. Or, it might be the perceived norms - 70% workdays, 30% personal days.
- creshal 10y ago> A question is then how we went from working 7 days a week, to 6 days a week and Sundays in church, to 5 days a week. How did people start to work less and live with the reality of earning less in comparison to those staying with the old working hours. Unions.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> A question is then how we went from working 7 days a week, to 6 days a week and Sundays in church, to 5 days a week. How did people start to work less and live with the reality of earning less in comparison to those staying with the old working hours. With blood. The socialist revolutions were in big part based on fighting for the workers abused in the freshly industrialized world. It's ironic if you see how fast people today want to get rid of all the safeguards that got us the quality of life we enjoy today, all in the name of cheaper products and "I will be an entrepreneur too!" mindset.
- conanbatt 10y agoSource? First, i think you mean unions, not socialism. Non-socialist countries also have had 5 day weeks. Also even though unions have increased worker rights in history, pure capitalism has also been doing that as well. Look at silicon valley, where empoyee perks, extra PTO and such have not been fought for but are provided.
- Mikeb85 10y agoThey were provided because labour demand outpaced supply. It's not the case for tech jobs in many North American markets, and certainly not the case for many other white collar jobs; even good paying ones. When supply begins to overshadow demand, whether due to immigration, more people getting CS degrees or whatever, you'll see a lot of those perks stripped away, and wages will stagnate or fall (relatively speaking).
- twoodfin 10y agojnordwick's excellent point is that demand can grow without any obvious bound. That has an impact on both ends of the labor market. Sure, people will be willing to work more to acquire the things they want, but that demand itself generates a need for jobs and leverage for labor. Somebody needs to design and manufacture the next iPhone or fancy TV. Somebody else needs to refurbish and maintain that lovely seaside Airbnb for jnordwick's next vacation. This can be a self-reinforcing cycle, and it's how the economic pie can grow even as everyone on the whole takes more.
- Mikeb85 10y agoDemand can't outpace supply forever. It can grow forever, but anything that's lucrative will eventually be sought out, and the price will come down. Labour included. Also, someone will always be willing to undercut others, which is why the arbitrage condition is basically a law of economics, and always leads to a price equilibrium.
- conanbatt 10y agoI agree completely with what you say, which if i understand correctly, is exactly what I said. It was demand from market forces that increased the wages of software engineers, not a union fighting for those perks.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>Look at silicon valley, where empoyee perks, extra PTO and such have not been fought for but are provided. Because those things have long been fought for and accepted. Silicon Valley, being in California, is far from "pure capitalism.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoWhile socialists do tend to be violent psychopaths - particularly in that era [1] - it's far from clear that such behavior is necessary. You can witness the same transition happening in India completely peacefully. Many middle class jobs are transitioning to 5 day weeks as part of capitalist competition to gain/retain workers. Nerdy software engineers - more or less the opposite of violent socialist revolutionaries - are some of the first to gain these benefits. I remember hearing recently the philosophy of an older (read: 70+) black civil rights activist criticizing Black Lives Matter. He said that back in the day, they had a 4 step process. 1) Have an ideology, i.e. figure out exactly what you want. 2) Ask for it nicely, and reduce levels of niceness in the requests gradually. 3) Peacefully protest. 4) Revolution. It seems like the socialist revolutions might have jumped to step (4) unnecessarily. [1] Just read some of Jack London's socialist fiction. One of his short stories is about socialist revolutionaries murdering innocent people and dropping their bodies on the doorsteps of peaceful capitalists.
- ionised 10y ago> While socialists do tend to be violent psychopaths Oh come on now, that's just silly.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoI'd suggest reading old socialist literature, Jack London being one of my favorites. Then observe the real life behavior of many socialists in that era. The past is a foreign country.
- PeterisP 10y agoWell, quite a few people in the first world are working 7 days a week or some other structure of 70+ hour weeks; and many of them earn a multiple of the median wage while doing so, so they definitely would be able to survive just fine in a different, lower paid job with less hours but they still choose to do what they do.