3 ms·
I would say if I had to choose between an electric scooter and an electric bike for _commuting_ I'd choose the electric scooter. It's more comfortable, can att
by mc32 10y ago
I would say if I had to choose between an electric scooter and an electric bike for _commuting_ I'd choose the electric scooter. It's more comfortable, can attain higher speeds and can also have a cargo basket (due to scooter weight, the basket doesn't upset the balance as much) and can carry a passenger too.
Another convenience in the form factor, to add, stopping and starting do not involve dismounting and remounting, just leg down, leg back up --this means fewer riders running lights or stop signs.
So, if something two wheeled would take over, I'd say the electric scooter rather than the electric bicycle. Now, if you are looking to get a workout during your commute, ok, a pedal bike is better, you have not choice but to pedal.
- mjmahone17 10y agoWith a big enough increase in bike paths, this calculation may differ: going slow enough to be allowed on a bike path, while still being able to split lanes when needed, could be a huge advantage. Additionally, if you live somewhere that is space constrained (like a small apartment without parking) an electric bike is significantly easier to find space for. It basically boils down to: do you have the storage space for a small car, and just want faster highway and street commutes? A scooter makes sense. Do you have to bring it up an elevator or want to use rail trails? E-bike all the way.
- mc32 10y agoI think you hit it. It depends on _how_ we adapt to these modes. In some places around the world bikes _and_ scooters, electric or otherwise, have access to the same separated lane. In many of these places, scooter parking is pervasive and is allowed to park on sidewalks, etc., so it depends on how we acculturate to these modes of transportation, for sure. For exercise, traditional bikes win out.
- r00fus 10y agoAs a car commuter who's seen a lot of accidents, quite a few are (probably newbie) motorcyclists who don't know how to split lanes (3 of the 6 I've seen in the past 4 years). Also, sharing the road with cars means breathing their exhaust. Count me in for the e-bike takeover.
- ygra 10y agoThe bike path I'm using to commute every day is shared with scooters. I'd rather take car exhaust, to be honest (although I'm not suicidal enough to take up with cars going 100 km/h on the road next to it). Every time I'm overtaken by a scooter I'm coughing the next minute or so while having to slow down to about 10 km/h. On the other hand, people are probably much more likely to switch from a scooter to an e-bike than from a car, simply because the convenience factor is very similar. And winter is coming right now, which luckily takes scooters away too, for some reason :)
- windowsworkstoo 10y agoWho's "dismounting" their bike when they stop...it's leg down or just trackstand.