4 ms·
If we broaden our definition of religion, it loses much of its descriptive power, and we'll have to invent a new word to describe the Abrahamic religions with t
by barrkel 10y ago
If we broaden our definition of religion, it loses much of its descriptive power, and we'll have to invent a new word to describe the Abrahamic religions with their jealous God, which define clear in-groups and out-groups, that define modes of clothing and ritual that mark out believers and non-believers, that require some kind of sacrifice to belong, and that are fundamentally underpinned by the idea of a Covenant, a contract that rewards people for following the tenets and punishes those who don't.
Personally, I think religion is a fine word for this. I'd rather keep it that way. Ritual without belief and concomitant warm fuzzies of doing the Right Thing is something else.
- meric 10y agoConforming to ritual is a method of ego/identity-destruction on the path of mysticism. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haqiqa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haqiqa
- sriku 10y agoThis seems a strange stance given how've already generalized it in day to day communication even in the tech world with its own religious wars.
- barrkel 10y agoI don't think so; I believe my definition also applies to e.g. Apple device ownership and Green ideology.
- gnipgnip 10y agoThat's a very interesting observation. I'd had to read an eye-opening book called "The Heathen in his Blindness" [1] to understand the cultural grounding I stand on. As an Indian, whose own mother tongue has been neglected by the neo-colonial state, and thus whose own epistemological roots are muddied up with those from an over-bearing English imposition, it has become very difficult for me to see the difference between Abrahamic traditions and the contemporary Indian ones (in the city atleast). The latter simply don't make sense anymore (which is likely why a lot of people are irreligious). On the other hand, more than half of the traditional schools in India don't believe in a creator, and it's not clear if any of them actually believe the "devas" (godlings?) exist. Buddhism for instance borrows heavily from the Indian pantheon of devas, but expressedly keeps mum about their existence; those on the "Astika" side like Mimansa, while attesting the grounding of the Vedas, don't believe in the existence or literal use of many of the categories in contemporary Hindu life. Other than these, there was also a school of determinism (slaughtered off by Ashoka), a (much maligned) materialist school, along with who knows how many others - many of them were atheistic (in the Abrahamic sense). I'm not even sure what the semantics of "creator" is in the Sanskrit literature; there is a lot it, but its study is seen with utter contempt (centers of Indic study are now in N.Y, Heidelberg and Kyoto). Likewise, Yoga, meditation... gained mass appeal in India, after they took off in the West. Edit: Updated for clarity.
- gnipgnip 10y ago(continued...) It's almost a curse to be able to see all this, and be able to do very little to ameliorate it. Considering the poverty of my native tongue, it'd be very difficult for me to express it to the masses. Even if I learn the millennia old language, no one would understand it. [1] http://www.cultuurwetenschap.be/pages/the-heathen http://www.cultuurwetenschap.be/pages/the-heathen Edit: Update for clarity.
- Iv 10y agoI think the mistake is to conflate "religion" with "Abrahamic religions". In my opinion, a religion is characterized solely by an act of worship that has a supernatural justification. > with their jealous God Does not even describe what many catholics actually believe. Does ignore polytheist and atheist religion. > define clear in-groups and out-groups Living in Japan, I was surprised to discover that religion is not considered exclusive. A lot of people go both to Shinto places and Buddhist places here. And that's ok. They also don't mind when tourists come to say hello to a kami. It is not disrespectful as it would be in a christian church. > Personally, I think religion is a fine word for this. Well it is called "Abrahamic religion". Buddhism and arguably taoism are atheist religion. Sikhism, hiduism (and even some forms of islam) recognize some other religions as being on the good path. Asking every religion to have the same characteristics as abrahamic religions is a bit like saying that a language that do not use latin characters is not really a language.
- barrkel 10y agoWell, Green ideology (environmentalism, recycling etc.) is also a religion IMO. It has rituals, it has targets of hate and love, it has a promise of salvation and a threat of doom, it requires daily sacrifices of convenience to follow, etc. Whereas if you're very loose about what you think is religion, you can't use the word by analogy any more. Any old ritual might be described as a religion. A morning commute might be a religion. I think that's too dry.
- Iv 10y agoTry the definition I gave: "An ideology that requires acts of worship that have supernatural justifications". Some ecologists are indeed close to having a religion. If you recycle your trash to help your own self-sustainability, it is not an action that has a natural justification. If you light some candles on the crescent moon to help the harvest, yes, you are acting religiously. > Any old ritual might be described as a religion Depends on the justification. Do you do that because of nostalgia or because of habit? Not religion. Do you do it because you think the ley lines will feed you energy for the day? Religion. > A morning commute might be a religion Are you doing your morning commute because you want a salary by the end of the moon (not a religion) or because you think that commute helps prevent the Ragnarok (religion)? This is not an analogy, this is a pretty well-defined notion. And you need a wide encompassing definition if you want to be inclusive to all the religions usually recognized in the world. Jealous god, covenant and hell, these are far too restrictive christian-centric (protestant-centric actually) criterion, and would exclude the religion of at least a billion of believers.
- smallnamespace 10y ago> we'll have to invent a new word to describe the Abrahamic religions Why not just use 'Abrahmic religions' then? The fact that we apply the term religion to Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism, etc. means that the conventional definition of the word does not coincide with those qualities of Abrahmic faiths that you described.