4 ms·
Even though solipsism is considered unfalsifiable, it can't explain why the world is so regular and yet complex, much more complex than human imagination. We ca
by visarga 10y ago
Even though solipsism is considered unfalsifiable, it can't explain why the world is so regular and yet complex, much more complex than human imagination. We can feel the limits of our imagination, but reality is much more complex. So there is the proof that there is an external world. It's not all in our imagination, because our imagination is less complex than the world we experience. If we said that our own imagination created the world, then it must be a Godly power. Basically we attribute divine powers to our own minds, which is absurd.
- mcguire 10y agoIn what way do you feel the limits of your imagination?
- visarga 10y agoIt's easy: there are many systems that are more complicated than what we usually can imagine. For example, the detailed structure of a material, or the internal structure of a language. We don't usually imagine coherent systems of such complexity. If there ever was a man trying to imagine something hugely complex, then he was surely Tolkien with LOTR. He imagined languages, countries and peoples in an amazing detail. But that shows how hard it would be to try to imagine something as complex as the real world. Our minds don't have such generative powers, thus the world doesn't come from our imagination.
- mcguire 10y agoAre you imagining the detailed structure of a material or are you imagining someone telling you about the detailed structure of a material? How much is first-hand sensing and how much is second hand reports? Also, that which does the imagining, your subconscious, say, has to be more complex than what you might perceive it to be.
- armitron 10y agoThere is no proof of an external world, since nobody has ever experienced it. Everything you consider to be a part of that external world is mediated through your mind. In short, you exist in virtual reality which is really manifested by your mental map which is layer upon layer of memories, personality traits, beliefs and thoughts. That does not necessarily mean that "you" create _the_ world, only that your mind gives raise to the subjective reality you have access to, the only reality you have access to. There may be an external, objective world out there, but we wouldn't be able to directly access it.
- mcguire 10y agoAbsolutely. That's the point of the solipsism argument: you have to assume there is an objective external world or you get into a trivial corner. At which point you need to explain consciousness in other people, which you cannot perceive directly.
- armitron 10y agoWell the assumption of an objective external world I find a bit silly. We can assume that other minds exist since we have direct experience of our own. It's a small leap from one mind to many (a leap nonetheless). But to assume an objective external world exists when nobody has ever experienced such a thing, is a leap of quite different proportions, akin to believing in a bearded man in the sky.