4 ms·
I have several friends who are homeless or who have been homeless. It's really difficult to overstate how hard it is to get back out of homelessness, once you r
by SwellJoe 10y ago
I have several friends who are homeless or who have been homeless. It's really difficult to overstate how hard it is to get back out of homelessness, once you reach that point, without significant outside help.
Think of all of the stuff most folks take for granted that are pretty much mandatory in most US cities in order to get and keep a job:
1. ID. So many of the homeless folks I know have had significant trouble obtaining ID after losing it or having it stolen, or having never had one because they left home at a very young age, etc. I can't count the number of conversations I've had trying to assist folks get an ID. Our governments don't make it easy (you need at least birth certificate and Social Security card, and some sort of mail showing where you live in some cases). For people without cooperative family or with no living parents, this step is very tough. It's stupid to think that lack of a tiny thing like ID is why so many people are without work and without homes, but, it's a reality.
2. Transportation. If you have no car in most US cities, it's hard to have a job. This one reason metropolitan areas are so much more densely populated by homeless folks; mass transit tends to be most accessible in the city center.
3. Staying clean. Would you hire someone who smells bad or looks dirty for any job? Homeless folks feel invisible because people don't want to be near dirty/smelly people of indeterminate mental health. Even if someone is perfectly able to do a job, being dirty is a guarantee they won't get the job.
4. No reliable way to reach them, if someone does decide to hire them. When I hear/see someone being hostile to a homeless or poor person because they are lucky enough to have a smart phone (I guess because a phone is an expensive thing), I'm just aghast. How the hell do they expect a homeless person to get out of homelessness without a phone, email, and a way to get online? So many low-level jobs have online application processes and require interaction via email and web in order to get the job.
5. Not getting a decent night's sleep, ever. Without a home, sleeping is a challenge every single day. If there are enough beds in the shelters (never the case in any city I've lived in), they have to be in the shelter by a certain time and have to be out very early (6AM is the "checkout time" at many shelters). This does double harm. The inflexible schedule prevents folks from holding jobs that conflict with that strict schedule, like second shift and night shift work, which often pays reasonably well, and has low barriers to entry. And, it also means they probably are running on an hour or two less sleep than a human actually needs to thrive. I hung out in downtown Eugene recently, and I was told that there was at least one fight, every single night. One broke out across the street within an hour of that conversation. I don't know that poor sleep is the cause of the frequent violence, but I'm confident it's a major contributing factor (and the science on sleep deprivation backs that theory up). Now, these were street kids, who don't go to shelters because the rules are too strict for them, and they sleep in sleeping bags and tents, but they, too, aren't getting enough sleep.
In short, having a home makes a huge difference in nearly every element of chronic poverty, and that, paired with a consistent income, are the things that most indicate whether someone will be able to become a self-sufficient functioning member of society again. This is a great idea, and it's awesome that Utah has had such great success with it. I hope more cities and states implement these ideas.
- back_beyond 10y agoAdditionally, not having a way to prepare healthy meals nor exercise regularly leads to a steady decrease in health. All these factors culminate into a hellish experience in which you regularly face defeat and look for an escape, something you can control, like drugs, alcohol, or death.
- hackuser 10y agoMany great points here. I think many of the responses you describe come down to fear: People are scared of someone different - what will they do? - and scared of the problem, which seems overwhelming. > It's really difficult to overstate how hard it is to get back out of homelessness, once you reach that point, without significant outside help. I'd add that when someone becomes homeless, they often are at their weakest point and now have to spend their limited capability on trying to survive (as you describe). On top of that, we're expecting they will overcome incredible challenges and boost themselves out of homelessness. It's just not realistic.
- throwaway_exer 10y agoTo further address #1, E-Verify requires a current ID - they won't even accept an expired passport, which is still accepted as proof of citizenship. Bizarre, since as a citizen you have a right to work in the USA. (I'm aware that one senator introduced a law that documents should have expiry dates enforced "because it's an expiry date" despite there being no particular benefit. It brings to mind the Republican party's efforts to verify voters - so that less people can vote in some areas without overt gerrymandering.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering
- ben_jones 10y agoI currently live in Eugene and have noticed a few peculiarities (near campus and away from downtown, YMMV): * Homeless rarely have their things with them, suggesting perhaps that housing and storage are provided (at some level) to them. * Those who panhandle near campus ask strictly for cash, and seem to some extent disappointed when they are given food instead. * Homeless are never on campus, EVER. This seems strange to me because facilities such as bathrooms, drinking fountains, out-of-sight benches, and rain-cover, are in abundance. Clearly they are kept away, but it surprises me how EFFECTIVELY they are kept away, almost as if they are afraid of it. * During the various University touring seasons (year round but more coming in Spring/Summer) there appears to be fewer homeless people in the more touristy areas near campus. This is purely anecdotal, but again it appears as if there is some contract with the local homeless to keep them away. * Every morning recycling bins are spilled with their contents spread out as if someone came during the night and rumaged through them. This is particularly evident in the many alley ways near campus where most garbage/recycling is found. I would think there was some type of reward program geared towards the homeless that incentivized collection of recyclables, but it back fired and led to a large amount of littering in the area. I have never been even close to homeless but I have always lived around it (San Francisco, Greater Bay Area, Eugene) and am somewhat fascinated by its societal implications. Eugene in particular is unique because it seems like a lot of people are trying really hard to make it better, yet are failing for a lot of reasons.