4 ms·
I have no idea what it can possibly mean to be "correct in your ... later treacherous [actions]." Do you mean: is it possible that the Post is correct that Sno
by lisper 10y ago
I have no idea what it can possibly mean to be "correct in your ... later treacherous [actions]."
Do you mean: is it possible that the Post is correct that Snowden should not be pardoned? Yes, that's possible. There are reasonable arguments to be advanced against a pardon. IMHO these arguments are wrong, but as I said in my blog post, reasonable people can disagree.
But even if one suspends disbelief and concedes for the sake of argument that Snowden should not be pardoned (is that what you meant?) that in no way excuses what the Post did. The Post is not an disinterested observer here, it is an active participant in the events, at best a co-conspirator, and at worst the actual culpable party. The editorial is entirely self-serving, and worse (because this is supposed to be a newspaper) it doesn't acknowledge that it is entirely self-serving. And it is self-serving at the expense of a man who (and there can be no reasonable dispute over this) has taken great personal risk to bring wrong-doing by the government to light.
So no, I don't see any possibility of any kind of redemption here. There are only two possibilities: either the release of the information was a crime that should be punished, or it was not. If the former, then the Post is at least as culpable as Snowden if not more so, and it needs to turn over the people who made the decision to publish for prosecution (or at least advance an argument as to why they should not be prosecuted while Snowden should be -- I can't wait to hear that argument), and it probably needs to close its doors like the News of the World did. On the assumption that releasing the Snowden documents was illegal, what the Post did was much worse than what NoW did.
- tptacek 10y agoSo the way you see this --- and let's just stipulate whatever needs to be stipulated to keep this simple --- regardless of the genuinely held opinions of the Editorial Page editors about clemency for Snowden, their paper's previous role in the Snowden story obligates them not to relate those opinions in an editorial? Maybe another way to put this is: is there an editorial they could have written that would advance their opinion about clemency and not been treacherous?
- lisper 10y ago> their paper's previous role in the Snowden story obligates them not to relate those opinions in an editorial? It obligates them not to do it as an isolated act. If they want to reverse course now they certainly can (it's always OK to admit you were wrong). But then they need to admit that they are culpable along with Snowden, submit the responsible parties (some of whom are surely on the editorial board) for prosecution, return the Pulitzer, and close up shop (or at the very least resign and turn over control to a completely new set of people).
- tptacek 10y agoIt's not exactly the role of a newspaper to "submit people for prosecution", is it? Could you flesh out a little bit what you mean by the WaPo taking an active role in arranging prosecutions? There's a difference between taking a position on clemency and a position on prosecution, isn't there? At any rate: am I adequately summarizing your belief by saying that regardless of what they write, if the Washington Post Editorial Page genuinely believes that Snowden shouldn't be given clemency, then they should also believe that the Washington Post itself should be shuttered (or turned over to a different team)?
- ScottBurson 10y agoLet's leave aside the question of what actions should be taken. The important question is this: Does the Post bear any responsibility for the decisions of its news editors to run the PRISM stories?
- lisper 10y ago> There's a difference between taking a position on clemency and a position on prosecution, isn't there? Suppose the U.S. manages to exfiltrate Snowden from Russia somehow. Do you seriously believe that, in the absence of clemency, there is less than a 100% chance he'll be prosecuted? Being against clemency without taking a position on prosecution is kind of like advocating jumping off a cliff but not taking a position on whether or not you fall to the ground. There may be a semantic distinction, but no practical one. > am I adequately summarizing your belief by saying that regardless of what they write, if the Washington Post Editorial Page genuinely believes that Snowden shouldn't be given clemency, then they should also believe that the Washington Post itself should be shuttered (or turned over to a different team)? And that they should also be charged and prosecuted as Snowden's willing accomplices. Yes. At least if they want to be honorable (and logically consistent). Look at the Post's justification for opposing clemency: "The complication is that Mr. Snowden did more than that. He also pilfered, and leaked, information about a separate overseas NSA Internet-monitoring program, PRISM, that was both clearly legal and not clearly threatening to privacy. (It was also not permanent; the law authorizing it expires next year.) Worse — far worse — he also leaked details of basically defensible international intelligence operations: cooperation with Scandinavian services against Russia; spying on the wife of an Osama bin Laden associate; and certain offensive cyber operations in China." It was the Post (and the Guardian) who made the decisions to publish these documents, not Snowden! He had neither the time not the inclination to make these kinds of editorial decisions. He grabbed what he could and ran. (And let's not forget that before he did this, he tried to address the problem -- which everyone concedes was a real and very serious problem -- through the "proper channels" and was smacked down.) He then relied on others, including the Post, to filter what he had and decide what should be published and what should remain secret. If things were published that should not have been, then the Post is at least as culpable as Snowden if not more so.
- maldeh 10y agois there an editorial they could have written that would advance their opinion about clemency and not been treacherous? I think the nature of the opinion itself makes it an unavoidable binary of betrayal / non-betrayal here, since to say now that the leaks were unjustified, is a complete reversal from their prior implicit stance. Given that Snowden approached them for editorial oversight, and they made the executive decisions to publish some documents, to declare later that those same reports were illegal would have to be a betrayal of their source's trust by definition, regardless of whether it is justified, moral or correct. I agree that hypocrisy is an independent dimension. They could do a complete moral cleansing by taking responsibility for their actions, but even that wouldn't negate the betrayal. As an aside, I am not put off by the treachery or disloyalty as much (since that can be inevitable at times - Snowden himself betrayed his employers out of his moral convictions), just WaPo's intellectual dishonesty as they went about it.
- tptacek 10y agoApart from outing an anonymous one or altering the information they provide, what does it mean to "betray" a source? I keep asking this and not getting a clear response. In accepting documents from Snowden and profiting from them, did the Post assume an obligation never to advocate against Snowden's interests? If you believe that to be the case, could you support that argument with evidence? Is this a rule of journalism I'm not acquainted with?
- tlb 10y agoSurely not. For instance, the Washington Post published the Unabomber's manifesto, but wouldn't have made any argument against prosecuting him.
- ScottBurson 10y agoWellll, that was a very different situation. Ted Kaczynski was not a leaker. They published it in the hope that someone would recognize it and identify him -- which is exactly what happened.
- rdiddly 10y agoThey're deploring something they participated in. In the most morally-neutral and non-judgmental terms, that is "inconsistent." If you do something that you regret either immediately or after a delay, that is customarily communicated by means of an apology. That reconciles the two inconsistent behaviors. Without an apology, their own participation is what makes it impossible for this to be considered a non-treacherous editorial. Now add: what the Post did was more severe and "damaging" (assuming you hold that view, which I don't) than what Snowden did. It's like a murderer writing an editorial saying "no clemency for the knife salesman!" Those knife salesmen! They really should be behind bars forever, so innocent and virtuous murderers aren't tempted to use those knives, which of course they must!!!
- _audakel 10y agoWith bezos in charge, all the people responsible for publishing the articles are probably long gone. No way for the post to give them up
- _audakel 10y agoWith bezos in charge, all the people responsible for publishing the articles are probably long gone. No way for the post to "turn them over" Non linear digression - snowden the movie was way better then the rotten tomatoes review.