5 ms·
> Really? Yes. http://blog.rongarret.info/2016/09/the-greatest-traitors-in-american.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2016/09/the-greatest-traitors-in-...
by lisper 10y ago
> Really?
Yes.
http://blog.rongarret.info/2016/09/the-greatest-traitors-in-american.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2016/09/the-greatest-traitors-in-...
- tptacek 10y agoCan you simultaneously be a traitor and correct in both your original, faithful actions and your later, treacherous ones? Could Baron have done the right thing given the ambit of the Post's newsroom, and the Editorial Page also the right thing in putting forward the argument against blanket clemency? Clearly, the Post's Editorial has quietly excused a lot of its own conduct. I'm less interested in the argument about the Post's hypocrisy --- because I'm sure I'll end up agreeing with you about that.
- jsmthrowaway 10y ago> Could Baron have done the right thing given the ambit of the Post's newsroom, and the Editorial Page also the right thing in putting forward the argument against blanket clemency? No. There is no dissonance here whatsoever. Editorial just cost WaPo an unfathomable number of sources. If you're playing the right move game and consider solely the masthead's interest, carpetbombing loyalty to sources is an extremely stupid move for a masthead to make. I think this is something Greenwald missed given his characterization of WaPo acting in its own self interest; the editorial is inexplicable in that frame of reference. There is more to it, without question. I bet Barton Gellman is having a good day.
- tptacek 10y agoI'm even less interested in the argument about whether it was in the Post's best interests to publish this.
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoEditorial exists to advocate for the interests of the paper. That's the key.
- tptacek 10y agoI disagree that that's the point of the Editorial Page.
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoThen you're wrong and arguing a definition of 'opinion' that appears in no dictionary of which I am aware. Mine is not a controversial statement within the industry, so I'm rather surprised to run into an argument and pushback outside. What do people think editorials are? They have this opinion for a reason and were willing to bite a source to advance it. Follow the reason.
- tptacek 10y agoI have no trouble believing that there are lots of HN people that think this is somehow all about Bezos.
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoUh, no, but thanks for feeding me an opinion that I don't have. Jeff Bezos didn't even enter this picture for me. You're better than this, come on. WaPo considered its network of government-friendly sources against a single, prominent government-unfriendly source. That's the calculus and why they can't advocate his pardon. I'm not writing a Dan Brown novel here and I'm pretty annoyed with you straw manning me to your preferred target. This would be like Barbara Starr biting Defense. Is this really news to you, that the Washington Post tends to maintain formation with the city in its name?
- tptacek 10y agoSorry, I thought you were referring to other comments on this thread about Bezos in solidarity. I took a rhetorical shortcut that didn't work out for me. I do not understand this cui bono logic. I think it's the role of an Editorial Page to take positions on matters of current events and public policy, and do so so in good faith (ie, to relate the genuinely held and reasonably informed opinions of the staff). My take on the role of an Editorial Page seems like it's pretty much the opposite of your take, which is that the Editorial Page exists to advance the interests of the paper itself.
- lisper 10y agoI have no idea what it can possibly mean to be "correct in your ... later treacherous [actions]." Do you mean: is it possible that the Post is correct that Snowden should not be pardoned? Yes, that's possible. There are reasonable arguments to be advanced against a pardon. IMHO these arguments are wrong, but as I said in my blog post, reasonable people can disagree. But even if one suspends disbelief and concedes for the sake of argument that Snowden should not be pardoned (is that what you meant?) that in no way excuses what the Post did. The Post is not an disinterested observer here, it is an active participant in the events, at best a co-conspirator, and at worst the actual culpable party. The editorial is entirely self-serving, and worse (because this is supposed to be a newspaper) it doesn't acknowledge that it is entirely self-serving. And it is self-serving at the expense of a man who (and there can be no reasonable dispute over this) has taken great personal risk to bring wrong-doing by the government to light. So no, I don't see any possibility of any kind of redemption here. There are only two possibilities: either the release of the information was a crime that should be punished, or it was not. If the former, then the Post is at least as culpable as Snowden if not more so, and it needs to turn over the people who made the decision to publish for prosecution (or at least advance an argument as to why they should not be prosecuted while Snowden should be -- I can't wait to hear that argument), and it probably needs to close its doors like the News of the World did. On the assumption that releasing the Snowden documents was illegal, what the Post did was much worse than what NoW did.
- tptacek 10y agoSo the way you see this --- and let's just stipulate whatever needs to be stipulated to keep this simple --- regardless of the genuinely held opinions of the Editorial Page editors about clemency for Snowden, their paper's previous role in the Snowden story obligates them not to relate those opinions in an editorial? Maybe another way to put this is: is there an editorial they could have written that would advance their opinion about clemency and not been treacherous?
- lisper 10y ago> their paper's previous role in the Snowden story obligates them not to relate those opinions in an editorial? It obligates them not to do it as an isolated act. If they want to reverse course now they certainly can (it's always OK to admit you were wrong). But then they need to admit that they are culpable along with Snowden, submit the responsible parties (some of whom are surely on the editorial board) for prosecution, return the Pulitzer, and close up shop (or at the very least resign and turn over control to a completely new set of people).
- dvogel 10y agoThe point is that the editorial board's denunciation of Snowden is empty, dishonest, and to be ignored unless it comes with an equally contemptuous charge against the WaPo news dept.