11 ms·
Lauri Love wasn't merely communicating, he was hacking into US government computer systems and stealing credit card info. If you are just opposed to all instan
by foldr 10y ago
Lauri Love wasn't merely communicating, he was hacking into US government computer systems and stealing credit card info.
If you are just opposed to all instances of extraposition, then ok, but that has nothing to do with this specific case.
- mindslight 10y agoThe specific crimes you list are generally accomplished completely through communication, and this seems to be true in this case. (I assume you meant to type 'extradition'). I'm not opposed to all instances of extradition. It seems perfectly reasonable that if someone commits a crime on US soil and flees, that their destination isn't a a safe haven and they be brought back to the jurisdiction they were in. But that's not what happened here - the alleged crime was committed while on British soil, and I don't think he's ever visited the US. So "extraditing" him is actually exporting him to a completely foreign jurisdiction!
- foldr 10y agoYou originally said that Love was "merely" communicating. That is not the case. He was also committing a crime. To say that he was merely communicating is like saying that a Nigerian scammer was "merely sending an email", or that a double agent was "merely carrying some documents in a briefcase". There is no legal precedent for limiting extradition to instances where the person being extradited has been physically present within the jurisdiction in question. If you hack into US government computers, it obviously makes sense for the US government to prosecute you. By the way, in relation to your Holocaust denial example, you should look into the concept of "dual criminality".
- mindslight 10y agoIt is "mere communication" in the sense that the whole action is communication, as opposed to eg also physically gaining access. The strict sense you're attempting for "mere" is nonsensical - every communication is for some ultimate purpose, and so can be described as that purpose. By a strict sense, asking Aunt Mildred for her cookie recipe wouldn't be "mere" communication, because you're also "making cookies". The dual criminality thing isn't surprising because it's the crudest way of resolving the immediate conundrum. But this case precisely highlights its flaw - a person has only violated the law if they are found guilty in a court. Lauri has not been found guilty in a UK court, and therefore his actions have not been found illegal under UK law! Not to mention the vastly different punishments between the places (owing to societal differences that he never opted into). So either the principle needs to be extended to take these things into account, effectively making him stand trial in a UK court but perhaps with a US prosecutor, or another basic principle needs to be found. Obviously there is no legal precedent, because if there were we wouldn't be having this conversation (it is the tendency for these systems to grow and erode rights). But I'm arguing that there should be - if someone is not physically present in a jurisdiction, how can they be said to have positively assented to that jurisdiction? In the age of instant global communication, we either have one world jurisdiction (role currently being filled by USG) or we need to adopt logical demarcation points between different ones. I believe freedom of speech scaled up to nation states makes a lot of sense, for the same pragmatic reasons that it makes sense applied to individuals - a receiver of information is able to easily filter much garbage, and so the onus should be on them to prevent being affected by it.
- foldr 10y agoIf that's what you mean by 'mere' then it doesn't matter that he was 'merely' communicating. Clearly it's possible to be 'merely' communicating in your sense and yet also committing a crime. The Nigerian scammer is 'merely' sending emails and yet also committing fraud. The idea that freedom of speech somehow makes hacking, fraud, or other such crimes permissible is simply silly. You're also misunderstanding how dual criminality works. The requirement is that the offence for which the individual is being extradited must be a crime in both countries. That requirement is met in Love's case but not in your hypothetical Holocaust denial case. I don't see why people should have to assent to being under any given jurisdiction. I didn't assent to being under British jurisdiction, but since I live in Britain, I am. You seem to be suggesting that the physical location of a person should impose hard-and-fast restrictions on which country's laws they may be subject to, but see no reason why that should be so.
- mindslight 10y agoReread my comment if you think I didn't understand dual criminality. What I'm pointing out is that the concept needs to be extended or augmented for the modern networked world. Previously it was adequate because one basically had to visit a jurisdiction to commit a crime there. But taking a look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography_by_region https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography_by_region, surely you wouldn't think it just for someone to be extradited from Iceland to Sudan for setting up a pornographic website. I started off this thread explicitly saying that I reject the idea of communication creating a legal nexus. Borders and physical locations are a strong Schelling point for determining jurisdiction. I'm referencing free speech for its aspect of "what is said cannot hurt me", which is another Shelling point. The Nigerian scammer is still committing fraud, but in Nigeria.
- foldr 10y agoYour previous comment certainly appeared to misunderstand dual criminality since you thought it was relevant whether or not Lauri had been convicted of a crime in the UK. Clearly, however, that is not relevant to the satisfaction of the dual criminality requirement, which is the requirement that the offence for which the person is being extradited is also an offence in the country they're being extradited from. With regard to your Iceland example, I doubt that Iceland and Sudan have an extradition treaty. If they do, I don't see in principle why someone who lived in Iceland but was involved in producing pornography in Sudan should not be extradited for it. In practice, however, the probable lack of an extradition treaty, and the probable flaws in the Sudanese justice system, would make it very unlikely that an Icelandic court would approve such a request. I'm not really sure why you bring the example up. People don't in fact get extradited from Iceland to Sudan, so it's not as if it highlights a problem with the present system. >The Nigerian scammer is still committing fraud, but in Nigeria. I don't see how that is necessarily the case, if the victims are in other locations.