4 ms·
I remember getting into a long discussion with an engineering director at Google about "the entitled attitude" that engineers had. Their argument was that money
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I remember getting into a long discussion with an engineering director at Google about "the entitled attitude" that engineers had. Their argument was that money spent on "lifestyle perqs" was money not spent on better computers or improved networking, or heaven forbid higher salaries where the engineers could spend the money on something for themselves.
They weren't wrong. But at the same time, they really weren't looking at it from the employee's perspective. Being a bit cheeky I mentioned that Google could save lots of money if they stopped heating and cooling the buildings. With the obvious counter argument that if the place was uncomfortable "everyone" would leave. But that is just as wrong. Not everyone would leave, only the people for whom working for Google wasn't as important as being comfortable at work. There were plenty of people who would sit there sweltering just to be "working at Google." And many of those people would do great work and build great things.
But the really good people, the people who constantly invent new things and have the skills to communicate their ideas and get them implemented, those people can work literally anywhere and if they can do what they want to do anywhere else, they will leave. So this "tax" of free soda and snacks is just a cost of doing business. And if you look at the revenue per employee, you do yourself no favor trying to maximize that number beyond the value that meets your net income numbers.
The other thing that a number of middle managers miss is that once you are paying a person more than their "wants" level, you get more loyalty and commitment spending additional dollars on snacks and sodas etc than you do on cash.
- fdsaaf 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficiency_wage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficiency_wage
- bane 10y agoThe amazing thing I've noticed is that employees of many startups have no problem paying a "startup tax" wherein they pay n times the current going rate for x service so long as the service is provided by their company, and the cost is deducted from their pay (+ some inevitably worthless stock options). In other words, pay some employees below market rate, add in worthless stock options, and so long as you keep the "free" soda and dry cleaning cleaning coming (at a 2-4x cost over what they'd pay for themselves) coming, they're fine. Even if the fee they're paying is far more expensive than just going out to get those services themselves. Once that ends, growth hacking ends and everybody gets burned.
- ryankupyn 10y agoAbsolutely true in my experience. What employees want, even more than additional money, is a lower mental load dealing with the everyday necessities of life, which an employer is perfectly placed to provide, since employees spend 40+ hours a week in the office. A more cynical benefit of sodas/snacks/exercise classes/laundry/dogwalking/social events provided by the company is that it makes leaving a lot less appealing. A competitor can easily offer a higher salary, but when departing means completely restructuring an employee's daily routine, it can be a powerful force keeping people in place.
- crdb 10y agoIt's not just comfort, it's signalling. A company with a laid back culture, open kitchens, free food, a nice expensive architect-designed office is signalling that it is prosperous ("we don't cut costs here, we don't need to"). A company getting less prosperous is also about to get less promotions, less bonuses, and maybe some layoffs. If you are 10 years old and you see your dad replacing his BMW by a beaten up Toyota, yes, he could just have decided to stop taking on so much credit, but chances are you'll think he's not doing well, even if he reassures you it's for perfectly valid reasons. So you mentally brace for giving up on that new bike you wanted for Christmas. "They've cut the kitchens." "Really? We just got an extra Jura coffee machine in every conference room..." "Interesting, sounds like your cash flow is good at the moment. Are you guys looking?" And the earlier you leave, the less affected you are - you benefit from the still strong brand, you get decent garden leave, you have little competition on the job openings and your former colleagues will be nice to you in case they need a hand out of the sinking ship later.
- rdtsc 10y ago> those people can work literally anywhere and if they can do what they want to do anywhere else, they will leave. I often wonder if the management team knows this. The people who are really good are also often: 1) more expensive 2) less likely to tolerate bullshit 3) will not be as submissive and willing to follow orders from the new managers Since more bullshit is coming down the pipeline and orders from new managers will have to be followed closely, they do something like this, know exactly what effect it will have. It is a variation of "we are not laying you off, just moving you to the basement". No company wants to be known for laying of the creator of language X, or famous technology Y. But if it seems they move on from their free accord then the company saves face. However, I think I would prefer a higher paycheck every pay period instead of free lunch or soda and so on. What I don't have faith in is that the money saved from free stuff there will directly go to my paycheck. For example, one way to fix the problem, at least for current empployees is to immediately give raises according to how much it was perceived it was costing the company in free soda or lunches, but that just doesn't happen I guess.
- slgeorge 10y agoBut the really good people, the people who constantly invent new things and have the skills to communicate their ideas and get them implemented, those people can work literally anywhere and if they can do what they want to do anywhere else, they will leave. So this "tax" of free soda and snacks is just a cost of doing business. And if you look at the revenue per employee, you do yourself no favor trying to maximize that number beyond the value that meets your net income numbers. Do you have any proof for this paragraph? :-) I mean, demonstrate that there are 'really good people who constantly invent new things' that are in some way better than other people. I accept that it's convention (or touch stone) amongst SV participants and developers on HN. And we all like to believe we're especially talented. But, then if this is true it must also be true for CEO's right, there are some that are 10x more talented and therefore they should get Y more salary etc. I agree with your underlying point "it's a cost of doing business", but not with your reasoning - to me the reasoning is that it's the social signaling for the industry: if everyone else gave away free shoes then company X hiring people has to do the same or be so 'different' in some way that it can go against the grain. As you say everyone totes up the benefits/draw-backs of their work place, team and tasks to decide if a role is good for them - I think that's quite a messy process and more than simply to do with whether there's free soda! >And if you look at the revenue per employee, you do yourself no favor trying to maximize that number beyond the value that meets your net income numbers. The challenge here is that's exactly how FD's are incentivised (in the UK at least). It's often a case that their bonus will be defined as a percentage associated with cost saving or margin: it's effective as it gets one department in the business focused on whether costs are delivering real value, the downside is the one this article is talking about "knowing the cost of everything and the value of nothing".
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI have been thinking about the proof question. I've been around enough, and in enough companies, to feel the truth of it is self-evident but the engineer in me is always looking for ways to develop objective measurements. So evaluating folks is one of the things we end up doing as managers (often annually) and I look for people who have contributed to projects and those who have both contributed and started new projects. People who suggest new projects are often (but not always) less fearful about "rocking the boat" in the sense that every new project suggestion is potentially a judgement against an existing project. It is primarily their mental attitude that lets them operate freely, and in doing so I have experienced people who contribute more by inventing new things can communicating that to their peers. My hypothesis is that this lack of fear is the same thing that moves them to leave when the environment becomes less hospitable, they don't internalize that perhaps leaving may not include arriving anywhere else. For folks who are afraid they won't be able to find work again, they are unwilling to leave simply because the working conditions have gotten less comfortable. I feel I understand the mechanics that underlies the basic assumption but I don't have a good way to prove it.