4 ms·
To be clear, this is not the first nor will it be the last time Google's "Jigsaw" has gotten involved in politics. It's CEO, Jared Cohen, worked for Hillary Cli
by ocdtrekkie 10y ago
To be clear, this is not the first nor will it be the last time Google's "Jigsaw" has gotten involved in politics. It's CEO, Jared Cohen, worked for Hillary Clinton at the State department, and once at Google, had emailed back and forth with her about Google helping encourage revolution in Syria. I don't want to see a Trump White House, but I am also sad that if Clinton wins, Google's influence in the White House will continue, or expand.
Considering Google's width of influence and overall power, it should be looked at as an international threat, because we have no way of knowing what they'll use that power for next. Anti-brainwashing is great, until you realize it's not much different than straight-up brainwashing. Google is proud to admit it uses manipulative tactics to subconsciously trick it's own employees into eating healther. Again, laudable goal, questionable moral ethics.
I actually had an extended argument with a Googler here on HN earlier this week about Google's apparent happiness to manipulate people's views to suit it's goals.
- makomk 10y agoAlso, as with anything in politics, it's easy to justify truly horrific things using noble-sounding arguments. For example, who wouldn't want to protect civilians? No-one, which is why when Clinton's State Department and the UK government used it to justify catastrophic military intervention in Libya few questioned it. Yet according to recent committee report, the threat was questionable and the groups we supported dangerous: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/sep/14/mps-deliver-damning-verdict-on-camerons-libya-intervention https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/sep/14/mps-deliver-da... It wouldn't take much of a slide down the slippery slope at all for Google to back those groups, or their Syrian equivalent, in the name of stopping murder - or for them to discredit claims that the groups we're backing are killing civilians.
- finid 10y ago> I don't want to see a Trump White House, but I am also sad that if Clinton wins, Google's influence in the White House will continue, or expand. It doesn't matter who the next president will be. Google will still have it's role to play in the govt. Isn't their guy responsible for search part of a Pentagon? initiative or something?
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoMuch of Google's partnership with the executive branch (of which the Pentagon is a part) is likely due to their close relationship with the Obama administration. Whether or not they'll be able to arrange the same deals with an opposing party's staff is anyone's guess. Money definitely talks to both parties though, and Google makes it rain in politics.
- cromwellian 10y agoGoogle doesn't hide the fact that it puts snacks that are bad for you in a ranked order and makes healthier snacks easier and more convenient to get to on lower shelves. They also label healthy stuff green ink, bad stuff red ink, and semi-ok stuff yellow. How is this any different than planners designing buildings to encourage exercise, or personal interactions? There's nothing immoral about this, and everyone is told about it, but we know people don't always read the labels, but actually sorting healthy to unhealthy by convenience, leverages the laziness of most people into eating healthy. If I have to bend over to the lowest shelf to eat a Snickers, but a banana or apple is right in front of me, maybe I'll eat that? There is nothing immoral or unethical about, and it publicly know. If you provide any range of snacks for employees, like any store or restaurant, you face a decision on how to order the food. Most restaurants and stores optimize their menus or shelves to hawk stuff that has the highest margin and least cost. If Google instead sorts their snacks according to say, popularity in the market, and puts all the Kit Kat or Snickers bars on the front shelf, then isn't that immoral? Lining the pockets of corporations that promote unhealthy disease causing foods, getting people addicted to sugar, and subconsciously steering them towards junk food? By "doing nothing" or "doing what was always done before" you are in fact, doing something knowingly bad that will harm health. I'd say it's even MORE unethical to 'default' to putting the snacks in order of demand or popularity. Google has also been trying to use data science internally to correct unconscious bias in promotions and interviews. Everyone is made aware of this, it's not a Milgram Experiment. Perhaps we should continue to let people rank resumes based on visible metadata like applicant name, even though we know it biases the reviewer -- even people who are progressive and even women are prone to this biasing effect. We could do nothing, or we could try to change the result -- and people will cry unethical, social engineering and manipulation. You've been doing anti-Google rants for years, almost a daily obsession, but it doesn't seem like you've toured their offices even once. Maybe you should take a look at how the cafes and microkitchens actually work.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI've toured Mountain View and spent some time at the San Francisco office, FWIW. I doubt anyone would let me in the door these days though. ;) The cafeteria in Google San Francisco started my obsession with dried apple chips. ...I ate all of the ones that cafeteria had. And bought more at a local convenience store after I left for the day. I may or may not have recently bought approximately twenty bags of apple chips at one time. The brand of apple chips sold in California is way better than the ones sold here.
- rixed 10y agoYou describe white house influence at Google, then express concerns about Google influence. Looks like you are either willing to vilify Google or to launder the white House. What interests could possibly motivate Google in Syria ?