4 ms·
What does progressive really mean? If you think drugs should be legalised then relaxed drug laws are progressive to you. But if you think drugs must be eliminat
by chrisseaton 10y ago
What does progressive really mean? If you think drugs should be legalised then relaxed drug laws are progressive to you. But if you think drugs must be eliminated then maybe you would think that harsh drug laws are progressive towards that goal? I'm not really sure 'progressive' means anything then. Anyone except literal conservatives not wanting to change anything thinks that the changes they want to make are in order to make progress towards a better world.
- reitanqild 10y agoI thought it was more or less universally framed to mean liberal left? Somewhat like people say far right and mean nationalsocialists.
- mantas 10y agoOn this side of the pond, liberal is associated with the right. European liberals are more like moderate republicans in US. Nowhere near european left.
- mantas 10y agoWho is literal conservatives though? If they're the ones who want to keep status quo, then center-left would be current europe's conservatives. The traditional right-leaning conservatives would be kinda progressive at the moment..?
- pmoriarty 10y agoThe accusation towards conservatives which want to change the status quo is usually that they're being reactionary -- usually trying to change society back to some idealized, mythical "golden age" that never actually existed, and to bring society back from the ashes of moral decay to some kind of ancient purity (of "blood", race, ethnicity, culture, or nationality).
- mantas 10y agoIf that golden age never existed, wouldn't that technically be progress?
- pmoriarty 10y agoThe golden age may not have existed as a reality, it reflects old ideals that did exist -- especially for those of certain privileged classes, sexes, and races, and to the detriment of the rest. That's why they're opposed and called regressive or reactionary by progressives. I'm sure conservatives would consider it "progress", but I doubt many of them would want to adopt the term "progressive" to their cause, as that term has an anti-conservative connotation. And certainly those who do label themselves "progressive" would not call that "progress" but "regress". Also, it should be pointed out that the golden age that conservatives often refer to did not exist as they describe, but aspects of it did exist in a much seedier and painful form. For instance, the golden age that some conservatives paint of the institution of slavery being a benefit to and desired by slaves -- that did not exist. But slavery and slaves did exist. Those conservatives that do favor slavery would have us go back to a slave-owning society, and would paint a rosy picture to convince those gullible or uneducated enough to think it would be a good idea, or to try to give themselves a fig leaf of respectability or deniability.
- mantas 10y agoSo it's just a label for leftists. Even if they are being conservative at the time. Fun story. During the collapse of USSR, a local band wrote popular song that had a line saying "conservative idiots strangled us in wires". Later on, most of independence movement formed Conservatives party. As in, the word itself is party title. Song quickly dropped the "conservatives" word :)
- cylinder 10y agoYeah it's kind of an empty word. As this article and many other observations show, everything is multifaceted. You have a culture like America which embraces the outliers at the top and elevates them often at the expense of the average person. Creatives and ambitious types are well regarded but the downside is big egos and self-absorption are chronic, along with disdain and lack of support for the poor, and these types often rise to power in government and private organizations. Or you can look at how "more equal" societies always have some element of "tall poppy syndrome," conservative cultural outlooks, conformity, blandness and bullying of those who dare to be different. There is no perfect society as some personalities will thrive in the same society that another personality will despise. I have met Scandinavian entrepreneurs who truly feel in their element in the US and have no real desire to go home (look below the surface eventually and you'll find a bit of narcissism and ego there too) and I have met Scandinavian salarymen who are seek a regular comfortable family life and eagerly seek to return home.