3 ms·
More generally, the Friedman-esque "flattening" of the world has made a lot of things less special. It wasn't immediately obvious to me what we were losing at t
by rconti 10y ago
More generally, the Friedman-esque "flattening" of the world has made a lot of things less special. It wasn't immediately obvious to me what we were losing at the time, but I now have a certain nostalgia for a time, just a couple short decades ago, when you could find things in your travels (foreign and domestic) that you couldn't simply order online or, at least, find on eBay. Souvenirs make so much less sense and feel so much less special when you don't need to travel to get them.
Of course, I do not view the past with such rose-colored glasses that I cannot understand that these goods have a wider market than ever and are accessible (both in terms of affordability and physical access) to more people than ever. The businessperson in a small village somewhere sure isn't sad that their market has become effectively infinite.
After all, many lament the bygone day of air travel when seats were comfortable and service excellent without realizing that they, like me, would not have been able to afford to travel by air at all 50 years ago.
To bring it full circle, it sounds like the author is recognizing that, while that world of nostalgia is lost to her as she is now able to travel by air due to increasing wealth, so too a poorer generation of Indians is now able to afford to travel by train (home-cooked meals or not) when before they could not travel at all.
- CalRobert 10y agoIt does feel weird to see that the world's souvenirs are largely made in China. I like my lamps I bought in Istanbul, but I could have bought not just a similar lamp, but quite possibly an identical one, online.
- csydas 10y agoWhile these issues are in part true, I think part of what maintains the allure of still going abroad or at least away from your current city is the discovery of what you want. Everything on the planet may just be a few clicks and a credit card away, but there are lots of things you don't realize you want because you didn't know they existed. Going and experiencing other cultures can help shape this. For a simple example, I never knew I wanted a cezve until I went to a place where they were more commonly used. Can I buy a cezve in the US? Absolutely, but I likely wouldn't have since the odds of someone using one to make coffee in the US is far lower. That's just a minor example, but it's representative of the allure that travel can still bring and what it ultimately brings - the chance to see and find things you didn't know about before. Souvenirs that aren't from shops labeled "Souvenir" still are usually much more unique and difficult to acquire without actually going to the source, and even the same activities just done with a different mindset or with a different cultural attitude can make all the difference.
- rconti 10y agoThat's a wonderful point. You still get to experience the culture -- what is popular and what makes a place unique, and what works well in that place. Often when I travel, I take note of things I like and wish to buy, but remind myself not to make an impulse purchase; I can always buy it once I get home, if I still want it -- and not have to carry it with me for the next 2 weeks! I think perhaps that very thought process is the reason I began thinking of travel as less "special".