4 ms·
Ask HN: Would you join a social network run by a non-profit?
- sharemywin 10y agowhat would you like to see different from FB, LinkedIn etc.
- f_allwein 10y agoprobably the wrong question to ask. As has been pointed out, the key feature is "are my friends on it or is it easy to get them on it?" I can't think of a feature that would get the average FB user to switch.
- sharemywin 10y agoif even someone comes up with a feature facebook it needs to not implement it after it catches on. pinterest, periscope, etc. not saying I have a good plan just interested in other peoples thoughts.
- anotheryou 10y agoMost of us even joined one by a for-profit. The problem is how to get my friends to move with me anywhere. Locked-in, network-effect, hen and egg problems
- nuevoyork 10y agoif you pay me $5 i'll join :-)
- NumberCruncher 10y agoA non-profit is run by real people and a social network needs an infrastructure. There are a lot of bills to be paid. The money paying the bills was obviously earned by someone doing things for profit or is donated by a lottery winner. I don't trust lottery winners, especially when they want to manage my personal data "for free". If you're not paying for the product, you are the product. That's why I only use social networks with a realistic monthly/annual fee, like Xing.com or meetup.com.
- blowski 10y agoWhat about Firefox, Linux, jQuery? Am I their product? A lot of Facebook's infrastructure is about advertising and tracking. Also, if you could run some kind of P2P social network you distribute a lot of the costs. So I disagree that the choice is between a large corporate-owned social network or no social network at all. A non-profit network is feasible, if tremendously difficult.
- NumberCruncher 10y agoAs a Linux user I have to admit this is a good argument. I like how DHH thinks about it. Make a simple product (with his own words: it is not rocket surgery) which solves problems, do it for-profit and put a price on it. After earning your salary and paying your bills you can still do rocket surgery for fun and give back to the community. Or do it also for profit promoting yourself as a professional or even your product. That's totally fine for me because in Rework he even points out that this is the part of the Basecamp marketing strategy (Out-teach your competition). If someone brands his social network as "non-profit" only to put ads on my screen hoping for my paid op-out, that is not OK for me. I trust humans who work for real money and sometimes give back to the community but I don't trust saints. Anyhow, we may be different and that is totally OK.
- sharemywin 10y agoNot trying to come off as a true saint. I just believe marketplaces shouldn't be run by corporations. All these corporations are sucking the life out of the economy by imposing monopolistic taxes on everyone in their "networks". Why because VC only fund monopolies and the stock market rewards giant hoards of cash off-shore. Is it fueled by jealousy, some, but imagine if all the businesses your talking about didn't have to pay 70 cents a click to advertise and they were rotated or some other more user friendly way display ads. or if you bought enough through a marketplace to cover your own costs you didn't need to see any ads. Non-profits aren't bound to maximize profits they just have to cover costs. I think it would be more of a protocol than a service.
- sharemywin 10y ago
- 2AF3 10y agoI'm waiting for a distributed system, any non-profit has to comply with government censorship.
- sharemywin 10y agoThe problem with completely anonymous encrypted "speech"(assuming speech enables transactions) is it comes with some nasty side effects. Murder for hire, child porn, terrorism recruitment among others. Does any government have it right absolutely not. But, to me those are the types of battles you would need to be willing to die for as well as your sons and daughters because your enemies are.
- Aldo_MX 10y agoWhy not treat anonymity as opt-in? Not everyone is paranoid about government espionage, data mining, etc, but if you are, then you'll have to deal with the additional baggage that anonymity brings to the table.
- sharemywin 10y agohow could you be sure the site/app wasn't a honeypot for government.
- Aldo_MX 10y agoYou can't, it is impossible to build a decentralized and distributed database which prevents access to bad actors.
- chrismonsanto 10y agoI don't care either way as long as there are people I care about socializing with on the service.
- sharemywin 10y agoI'm pretty sure a lot of people feel they way you do.
- nathcd 10y agoThe tracking and data mining is only one problem, another is having my data locked in a silo. What I'd like from a social network is for it to be more like an RSS reader: my posts should be followable via RSS, and my news feed should just be an RSS reader from which I can follow others on the same network and from outside the network. That's a pretty simple way to get me interested. I also would like if messaging would be handled by something like an email address (like Facebook added and then removed once upon a time), or better yet a derivative of email that's easier to self-host and encrypted by default (maybe something like matrix.org). To me, working to break down the huge silos is the best thing a non-profit social network could bring. And, to be completely honest, I'm not sure I'd even join it, because in this system I'd be able to participate without joining the network so I could just self-host my website (and RSS feed) and use my own feed reader as I do now. EDIT to expand on this after thinking about it a bit. Since podcasting has been the most successful use case for RSS so far, perhaps a good way to go forward with the above idea would be to allow attaching arbitrary files to posts, and to embed images/audio/video (as they're be embedded on Facebook). This would make it easy to host a podcast/video feed, or image feed on the network while still being a part of the larger open podcasting/video/visual art communities, and it'd be easy to follow. This could provide a decent avenue for advertising the network to certain segments of potential users. And (as long as you embedded items with simple img/audio/video html tags) communities like the free software community and the open web community would probably be pretty ecstatic about it at the very least.
- sharemywin 10y agoyou'd make a great microsoft exec. embrace and extend. it's a good idea btw.
- nathcd 10y agoI'll put you down as a reference next time I apply to Microsoft! :) If you're working on a social network, can you share more about what you're thinking about building and what stage you're at?
- _nalply 10y agoAs long as I am sure that I am not the product and the non-profit manages to overcome the network effect. Bonus points for using or interfacing to standards like e-mail, RSS, IRC and the like. Additionally if most of the infrastructure is peer-to-peer. For example a social network based on WebRTC. This way a lot of centralized infrastructure goes away.
- znpy 10y agoYes, as long as I am okay with how such social network treats its user and its data. I am still quite saddened hat Snake, the cryptographic social network, didn't get the appropriate funding when proposed on indiegogo. https://snake.li/ https://snake.li/
- 3ch1dna 10y agoI'm really disappointed that I had never heard of it until now. That looks like something I would actually join.
- bbcbasic 10y agoNo I'm bored of social networks. My email and phone number really are sufficient
- anilgulecha 10y agoNon-profit is an orthogonal matter. I think I'd much rather join a network where I'm in control of data. With tech-progress in p2p and the blockchains, I think the building blocks are already present for this kind of a network. If this were run by a non-profit, all the better.
- p333347 10y agoThat depends on whether there are enough real people on it, and it is a vicious circle because everyone would think the same. That said, if you can create one without all the stuff people hate about current social networks, you might make it attractive for enough people to join and set the ball rolling, and I might consider joining. (I am not being facetious.) So it being run by pro profit or non profit is a non issue.