3 ms·
> "Not Adobe’s Flash. Not .NET (through MonoTouch). If that were to happen, there’s no lock-in advantage." That is true, but not all of it - if Apple allowed c
by potatolicious 17y ago
> "Not Adobe’s Flash. Not .NET (through MonoTouch). If that were to happen, there’s no lock-in advantage."
That is true, but not all of it - if Apple allowed code generators there would be a glut of cross-platform apps being written in this middleware as developers try to write-once for multiple platforms (Android, BB, etc).
With this you will also see apps that do not follow Apple's HCI guidelines, eschewing Apple's aesthetic and workflow standards for lowest-common-denominator cross-platform UI. This would be a death blow to Apple's platform, since its primary advantage is having better UI than everyone else (this includes 3rd party apps).
IMHO this is more frightening to Apple's continued dominance than simple tools/language lock-in. If you didn't like Obj-C, Apple is not terribly pained to see you use something else... but if you bring Android-calibre UI onto Apple's platform Steve will be very sad.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"if Apple allowed code generators there would be a glut of cross-platform apps being written in this middleware as developers try to write-once for multiple platforms (Android, BB, etc). With this you will also see apps that do not follow Apple's HCI guidelines, " Good points but do they really matter as long as Apple controls the AppleStore ? It is not as if anyone can sell or deploy these without Apple's approval. I am not disputing your larger point (which is a good one), but how would an app that broke the HCI guidelines (say) get approved? Do such apps get approved today?
- acdha 17y agoThere are enough ugly apps on the app store that I find this argument unconvincing even if you accept the premise that this is reasonably Apple's job rather than customers choosing what to buy.