2 ms·
CFCs had relatively cheap, equivalent replacements, and did not make up the cornerstone of many national economies. The damage they caused was disproportionate
by vkou 10y ago
CFCs had relatively cheap, equivalent replacements, and did not make up the cornerstone of many national economies.
The damage they caused was disproportionate, compared to the economic benefit of using them over alternatives.
The nature of the ozone hole also didn't let people hide behind nonsense like "The climate changes naturally" and "Well, there are natural sources of carbon" and "The climate was different in the past."
- emodendroket 10y ago> The nature of the ozone hole also didn't let people hide behind nonsense like "The climate changes naturally" and "Well, there are natural sources of carbon" and "The climate was different in the past." I'm sure they would have found a way if the incentives were as strong.
- mikeash 10y agoYou don't even need strong incentives. The ozone hole was a target for the same types of people who now fight against the idea of climate change. For example, in one of his books, Rush Limbaugh dismissed the idea that humans could ever be responsible for any significant amount of ozone damage, because volcanos produce thousands of times more ozone-depleting chemicals.
- roc 10y agoIt didn't? I distinctly remember the same sort of FUD progression with regards to the ozone hole. 1. It wasn't actually happening/a problem. (It's hippy nonsense. [insert sarcastic comment about saving butterflies]) 2. It was happening, but it was natural, not caused by human activity (The ozone hole grows and shrinks naturally throughout the year! And its been bigger and smaller in the past!) 3. It was happening, caused by human activity, but there wasn't anything we could do about it (We can't force the other countries to change, and if they won't change it'll keep growing anyway!) There's really no difference in the playbook between it and global warming. It's just the financial incentives to delay are much stronger with carbon. Even the "equivalent replacements" for CFCs were widely regarded as overpriced and far worse at the time. (I still hear people bemoan the loss of freon AC to this day.) It's not so different from solar/wind vs fossil fuels.
- vkou 10y agoFair enough - I suppose the magnitude of financial incentives is the major distinction.
- abawany 10y agoMuch more recently, the Republican candidate running for the US Presidency still expressed skepticism that him using hair spray on his hair in his home had anything to with the ozone hole: http://www.factcheck.org/2016/05/trump-on-hairspray-and-ozone/ http://www.factcheck.org/2016/05/trump-on-hairspray-and-ozon... .