6 ms·
The risk that favors Roth IRAs includes the risk that the tax code will change to include higher rates than the current tax code. Also note that any increased
by wyldfire 10y ago
The risk that favors Roth IRAs includes the risk that the tax code will change to include higher rates than the current tax code.
Also note that any increased or decreased "need" doesn't factor in to the calculation.
- hellogoodbyeeee 10y agoUS income taxes are at historically low levels too.
- lettergram 10y agoI would disagree - prior to WWI there was no income tax. Further, not every state implanted income taxes (some still don't have any)
- lloyd-christmas 10y agoundefined != 0
- lkbm 10y agoSeems like in the case of tax, it does. They weren't taking a random % of income in income tax based on what was in the memory cell from the previous call stack. They were taking 0%.
- whamlastxmas 10y agoSome states (Texas) don't have income tax but have very high property taxes to offset this. Or they have high sales tax.
- opo 10y agoThere is a difference between nominal rate and effective rate. The effective rates are fairly close to the past for high wage earners, lower for low wage earners. >...In 1958, approximately two million filers (4.4% of all taxpayers) earned the $12,000 or more for married couples needed to face marginal rates as high as 30%. These Americans paid about 35% of all income taxes. And now? In 2010, 3.9 million taxpayers (2.75% of all taxpayers) were subjected to rates that were 33% or higher. These Americans—many of whom would hardly call themselves wealthy—reported an adjusted gross income of $209,000 or higher, and they paid 49.7% of all income taxes. >In contrast, the share of taxes paid by the bottom two-thirds of taxpayers has fallen dramatically over the same period. In 1958, these Americans accounted for 41.3% of adjusted gross income and paid 29% of all federal taxes. By 2010, their share of adjusted gross income had fallen to 22.5%. But their share of taxes paid fell far more dramatically—to 6.7%. The 77% decline represents the single biggest difference in the way the tax burden is shared in this country since the late 1950s. http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887324705104578151601554982808 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014241278873247051045781516...
- maerF0x0 10y agoThis is an interesting point, but not something we can solidly plan on. Vs we can absolutely say what the best way to play the game is based on todays rules.
- angersock 10y agoIt's a pretty safe bet that the next 30-40 years is going to explode in entitlements spending and infrastructure costs. If the government folks don't pay them, then it's going to basically be Mad Max and your IRA (whatever the type) won't really help you much. If the government folks do pay them, then the money for that has to come from somewhere. It's very unlikely to come from businesses, because the little ones don't make enough and the big ones pay very bright lawyers and accountants to keep the .gov away (cough Apple cough). So, it's probably going to come from income tax. Get a Roth.
- tcoppi 10y agoIf you consider the risk of massive tax rate increases over 30-40 years significant, due to the need to pay for massive entitlement and infrastructure spending, also consider the risk that they will tax Roth capital gain withdrawls to pay for it as well.
- Jtsummers 10y agoIn which case you've lost nothing since that money wouldve been in a conventional account and taxed to hell anyways. Put it in the IRA and if things don't go to shit, your money is fine. Don't put it in the IRA and of things go to shit, lose the tax advantage. Do either and things go to shit, it doesn't matter which you did.
- tcoppi 10y agoNo, that money would have been in a 401k, so you would lose out on the initial benefit of not having paid taxes when you contributed if they raid Roths. But, if you've already maxed out your other tax-advantaged space, and you have more money to contribute, there is no reason not to put it in a Roth instead of a regular taxable account, assuming you are eligible, because then you can have tax-free growth at least(worth less than tax-free contributions, but still worth a lot).
- tcoppi 10y agoThe rates would need to go up enough so that your overall tax rate in retirement is greater than the marginal rate you pay taxes at today. That would be quite the taxation increase, probably above the historical norm at any point in the US, unless you're well above the 33% bracket, in which case the probability of your rates increasing is a lot higher.
- cbhl 10y agoIf you live in Silicon Valley, a new grad would probably be in the 28% or 33% bracket just to be able to afford renting a studio apartment on their own.
- loeg 10y agoGP is talking about Federal brackets. 33% starts at $190,150 AGI (after deductions) which is well above what a new grad could expect (from their employer) or require to pay rent, even in the valley.
- misnamed 10y agoIt's also worth noting that by historical standards tax rates are actually low. So if we assume the possibility of mean reversion they could well be higher. I see the Roth/Regular as a bet-hedging opportunity - ideally, put some in each type and then you are ensured against either scenario.