5 ms·
Fortunately, the world has agreed to do something about this global warming business... By entering a vague international agreement with no clear targets, or e
by vkou 10y ago
Fortunately, the world has agreed to do something about this global warming business...
By entering a vague international agreement with no clear targets, or enforcement power.
If I were a fossil fuel lobbyist, I couldn't have drafted a better agreement then the Paris Accord. There's a collective target, there's every reason for the participants to defect, there's no proscribed steps that signatories must take, and there is no mechanism for censure of defectors.
- jedmeyers 10y agoWho, in your opinion, should wield the enforcement power in such cases? And what would be the mechanisms of said enforcement?
- caio1982 10y agoCommercial treaties are signed all the time to make a few bucks, the same contracts could predict economical penalties for breaking these agreements. Money talks both ways, but it takes a lot of courage and political will to enforce such penalties.
- vkou 10y agoEconomic. The simplest way to enforce carbon reduction is to tax goods that come from high-carbon polluting nations/industries. This is, of course, politically unpalatable.
- caio1982 10y agoWhile I agree with you regarding all the points you made, let's try not to get too cynical with age if we can. I was a kid when Earth Summit happened and we humans managed to stop and slightly reduce the Ozone Hole within a generation time. And it all started pretty much the same, with politics and all: something had to be done, if it was an ultimate silver bullet or not it does not matter because it is all about political momentum, IMHO.
- flatline 10y ago> we humans managed to stop and slightly reduce the Ozone Hole By "we humans" I assume you mean Dow Chemical or whoever the primary inventor of CFC replacements was at the time. Yes, it was a good thing, but there was a relatively easy and uncontroversial fix. What we are talking about here involves people with huge vested interests in fossil fuels - people dependent on them for living and commerce, entire nations solely dependent on them just to function - there are much larger systematic problems at play that must be overcome to reverse the current trend. I'm still mildly optimistic that we can improve the situation, but if the ozone was like steering a rowboat, this is like trying to do a 180 in an aircraft carrier.
- vkou 10y agoCFCs had relatively cheap, equivalent replacements, and did not make up the cornerstone of many national economies. The damage they caused was disproportionate, compared to the economic benefit of using them over alternatives. The nature of the ozone hole also didn't let people hide behind nonsense like "The climate changes naturally" and "Well, there are natural sources of carbon" and "The climate was different in the past."
- emodendroket 10y ago> The nature of the ozone hole also didn't let people hide behind nonsense like "The climate changes naturally" and "Well, there are natural sources of carbon" and "The climate was different in the past." I'm sure they would have found a way if the incentives were as strong.
- mikeash 10y agoYou don't even need strong incentives. The ozone hole was a target for the same types of people who now fight against the idea of climate change. For example, in one of his books, Rush Limbaugh dismissed the idea that humans could ever be responsible for any significant amount of ozone damage, because volcanos produce thousands of times more ozone-depleting chemicals.
- 10y ago
- blaze33 10y agoI recently attended a conference organized with Jean Jouzel (vice-president of the IPCC) who said the Paris Accord was a success as in it allowed us to get out of the Kyoto Protocol mindset which had binding targets for only 37 countries nothing whatsoever for the rest of the world. Another conference led by an economist studying climate change/economy interactions stated that we still lack two things to start doing something effective against climate change: - Compulsory and audited accounting and reporting of greenhouse gases emissions for all countries. What are you doing anyway if you don't known who emitted what and when to start with? - Some sort of internationally agreed on economic incentives to push the economy in the right direction. An example would be to have fossil fuel producers collect a tax (which would be reinvested / shared in some way) Short of this we have no binding target and the 2°C limit remains wishful thinking for the time being...
- justsaysmthng 10y agoThey celebrated with a nice dinner afterwards though: http://www.newyorker.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Cassidy-A-Potluck-Dinner-in-Paris-1200x630-1448998933.jpg http://www.newyorker.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Cassidy-...