12 ms·
Newton inventor claims ‘Shark Tank’ is all a lie
- n0us 10y ago“Sharper Image is the last company in the whole country I would have allowed him to even speak with,” Kaufman said. “We all know their reputation. They went bankrupt. Their name makes you think of a niche item that costs a lot of money, and that’s not what Nubrella is.” A 60 dollar sunshade strapped to a hat isn't niche?
- WalterSear 10y agoIt's 2016. If scifi taught me anything about 2016, it was that it involved outrageous plastic headgear.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoAny period of history can involve outrageous headgear. Even things we consider classy can change in a heartbeat. Fedoras used to be cool. Now they're weird and neckbeard-y.
- zyxley 10y ago> Fedoras used to be cool. Now they're weird and neckbeard-y. Fedoras are still cool... if worn with a nice suit by a well-groomed person. Fedoras worn with undershirts and untailored clothes were never cool in the first place.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- logfromblammo 10y agoI wear an Outback Trading Co. oilskin River Guide hat [0]. I don't care if it looks cool, because it keeps my glasses dry in the rain, and the sun out of my face the rest of the time. If I want to be fashionable, I can wear something else, but mostly I just want to be comfortable. [0] http://www.outbacktrading.com/river-guide-1497-brn-md http://www.outbacktrading.com/river-guide-1497-brn-md
- jsmthrowaway 10y agoTry a Tilley. I looooove my Tilley. I have this one: http://www.tilley.com/us_en/men/hats/ltm6-airflor.html http://www.tilley.com/us_en/men/hats/ltm6-airflor.html Owner's manual is worth a read, if you're unfamiliar: http://www.tilley.com/media/pdf/Tilley-Owners-Manual-EN.pdf http://www.tilley.com/media/pdf/Tilley-Owners-Manual-EN.pdf
- logfromblammo 10y agoThat looks fit for a different purpose. One of the reasons I wear a full-brimmed hat is to replace both sunglasses and umbrella, and the mesh portion of the Tilley that you linked allows rain to pass through the crown. The Wanderer [0] is likely closest to what I would wear. It's a bit more expensive than what I already have, but it looks like they have a lifetime replacement guarantee and a 2-year insurance policy against loss. All other things being equal, I'd rather pay less up front and take greater care with what I bought. [0] http://www.tilley.com/us_en/men/hats/warm-weather/tilley-wanderer.html http://www.tilley.com/us_en/men/hats/warm-weather/tilley-wan...
- DonHopkins 10y agoMaybe the sharks discovered some prior art that invalidated the sunshade patent, like the Halliburton Survivaball. [1] [1] https://youtu.be/JzSMjSxM5Vo?t=4m4s https://youtu.be/JzSMjSxM5Vo?t=4m4s
- ptero 10y agoSign in / sign up required. Boo :(
- TAForObvReasons 10y agoThe overlay "Wake up with today's top stories" has a "Close" link at the top, you can click it and read without signing in: http://i.imgur.com/UMewFHE.png http://i.imgur.com/UMewFHE.png
- bennylope 10y agoThat's what the "web" link below the article link is for.
- ISL 10y ago'web' link also failed for me.
- aluhut 10y agoI had a popup with a gray "Close" in the top right corner. I didn't read it so not sure if this is what stopped you.
- DiabloD3 10y agoA rather non-obvious close, so parent comment is correct. The popup does not have an obvious bold "close" or "X" in the right hand corner or the bottom right, it has a very light grey close in the upper left, and also does not respond to clicking outside the modal dialog. Thats enough to consider that a dark pattern.
- gcp 10y agoI also tried to hide the popup before I saw the close button. It's very hard to find. But I'm sure that's intentional?
- powera 10y agoMan with bankrupt company files lawsuit, more at 11. He's not claiming anything that the producers won't readily admit, so this should be fairly straightforward. He seems to have some merit to his claim that re-runs should show the original air date, other than that everything he claims is laughable.
- ethanbond 10y agoReally? They admit that they say they're investing $200k and then don't invest $200k?
- Zyst 10y agoThe article mentions he already settled that for 20k. Now he's suing for damages that the re-runs are causing.
- powera 10y agoThere's a very clear disclaimer at the start of each episode that all deals are tentative and subject to due diligence and other factors.
- ethanbond 10y agoOkay but they filmed a follow up pretending he received funding
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mtmail 10y agoIn Germany's equivalent 26 of the 35 announced deals during the show didn't work out. Usually due-diligence but I can imagine in some cases that wasn't even started. I counted 114 presentations (19 episodes, 6 presentations average). So 26 actual investments is a 20% ratio.
- fnayr 10y agoSo the guy sues them, settles for $20k, sues them again for a different reason, and has the audacity to say he wants to appear on another episode and think there's even a chance of that happening?
- jahnu 10y agoIf it's profitable for them, why not.
- legitster 10y agoI was with it until he demanded more air time. That's such a weird demand out of this.
- xemdetia 10y agoI think it made sense in just a settlement- 'you want to keep rerunning that episode over a decade after it was recorded and aired, let me at least show "now."' I can see how such a product with such limited circulation could be completely overwhelmed by Shark Tank reruns/promos in marketing even though it's wildly out of date.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI'd love to hear the shark's side of this but I am not surprised to hear someone say that the show doesn't accurately portray the deals. Having participated in televised 'reality shows' (Robotica, Battlebots) it is clearly entertainment value rather than the putative subject matter that the producers are interested in. Mostly its little stuff, like the gift basket from Robotica was said would include "New Balance Running shoes" but instead had some fairly poorly made off brand shoes (the box said "Quolity Shoes" (yes with an 'o' instead of an 'a' in Quality). My wife and I agreed that it felt like the producers were trying to produce a show "experience" with props for the "contestants." But from the article there must be more since the guy sued and then settled for $20K? What did the contract say? And the licensing stuff is pretty crazy in TV (so many people want to be "on TV" it really is amazing).
- kbenson 10y ago> so many people want to be "on TV" it really is amazing I've never understood this. I have no desire to be on TV. It feels like I'm in the vast minority, but I wonder if it's just a matter of those that don't want to be on TV aren't, and based on their personalities are also less likely to have their views propagated by popular media?
- M_Grey 10y agoI think that's part of it, but also I think that most people overestimate the benefits of the average experience of televised 'fame', and underestimate the risks.
- webwanderings 10y agoI've always been of the opinion that all reality shows are produced with actors, or aspiring actors. None of the people are everyday, average folks. This view was reinforced after watching a few seconds of this Battlebots show which you speak of. Either that, or the producers hunt down and look for TV-suitable people from the average crowd. All those people who "want to be on TV" are in that category.
- 10y ago
- gerby 10y agoI'll never participate in Shark Tank.. one of two investors I'd even consider taking an investment from on that show, doesn't even appear in the majority of the episodes. That would be Chris Sacca.. I think he's brilliant.
- Golddisk 10y agoI remember seeing somewhere (can't remember if it was online, or on the show) where the Sharks talked about how a lot more goes into the deal then the little snippet of them talking that is shown on TV. Obviously that makes sense, as the info from the little snippet is often superficial. The exposure for the company presenting their items is probably one of the best parts. I would think if you are set to capitalize on that then you have a good shot of doing decently, even if the Sharks don't back you (although this guy even has problems with that). Sounds like this guy just struggled with his business and it basically ran into the ground.
- babuskov 10y ago> I remember seeing somewhere I saw an interview with Mark Cuban that was completely unrelated to the subject, but touched Shark Tank briefly and he explained how it worked.
- quickly 10y agoThis man is pathetic. All deals on Shark Tank are subject to due diligence. Many deals don't go through after the show. The worst part is "let me go back on the show and tell everyone the improvements of my product". Absolutely laughable. He thinks he's entitled to a product advertisement on Shark Tank -- he's also got one and now he wants another. This guy is a joke. Having said that, if it's true that they faked the update, including high-fiving Daymond John, that's pretty pathetic. But this guy agreed to film it and fake it, so...
- sctb 10y ago> This man is pathetic. Please leave these out of comments on Hacker News. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- nix0n 10y agoFyi: The man is from Newton MA, USA. He is not the Apple Newton's inventor.
- seltzered_ 10y agoAlso, here's a video of the invention itself: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i0nV2S5pO2I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i0nV2S5pO2I I like things that help battle the elements, but this isn't my cup of tea. It appears that he's also kickstarted the thing about three years ago (only to ~$10,000 in funding) and people are complaining about not receiving the item: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/36197580/finally-the-worlds-first-hands-free-umbrella-has-a/comments https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/36197580/finally-the-wo... My current system of dealing with rain in the Pacific Northwest is combining a well made rain jacket with a wool baseball cap (Ebbets Fields makes some) - it solves the problem of wearing glasses in the rain pretty well. There's probably some really niche uses for the nubrella, but there's other solutions already (camera rain covers, waterproof phones/phone cases/etc).
- bobbytherobot 10y agoI actually think this device would do little good for weather. * Rain can come at you from many more angles than just straight down * Wind will rip apart anything remotely a sail, like the top of his device * How do I put it on as I exit a car?
- dennisnedry 10y agoThank you, I kept looking for his name in the history of the Apple Newton.
- Hydraulix989 10y ago@dang, this actually was pretty confusing to me as well. Being that we're all on a tech/hacker forum, I also thought that "Newton inventor" meant that he invented the "Apple Newton."
- quickly 10y agoThis man is pathetic. All deals on Shark Tank are subject to due diligence. Many deals don't go through after the show. The worst part is "let me go back on the show and tell everyone the improvements of my product". Absolutely laughable. He thinks he's entitled to a product advertisement on Shark Tank -- he already got one and now he wants another. This guy is a joke. Having said that, if it's true that they faked the update, including high-fiving Daymond John, that's pretty pathetic. But this guy agreed to film it and fake it, so...
- 89vision 10y ago"(sharper image)...Their name makes you think of a niche item that costs a lot of money, and that’s not what Nubrella is.” Funny, when I saw the Nubrella, Sharper Image is the first thing that came to mind.
- inputcoffee 10y agoI am not speaking about this case in particular, because I have no idea what happened, but in general things like this must happen all the time even if the show is "authentic." I think a lot of diligence and deal details have to be worked out. They ask who else own shares but they don't even go through a cap table. I know the sharks have been disappointed when entrepreneurs turned out not to be "serious" and just show up for exposure. This person may have been scammed, but it is also possible that one red flag ended the diligence. ("Wait? how much debt?!") The thing that remains a mystery is this follow up episode. But that makes no sense on both sides. How do you get pressured to do a follow up episode if you never saw an investment?
- dpedu 10y agoOh no, who would of thought a primetime cable TV program isn't real?
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoHasn't the already been "invented"? I remember seeing something in a magazine a decade or so back about a Japanese person who did something very similar.
- DrSayre 10y agoEverybody who watches this show knows the Sharks can pull out of the deal later on. I enjoy the show, even though I realize a lot of it has to be staged. However, I don't like how they force the people to make a decision within minutes, but the Sharks can research the product some later and pull out if they want to.
- dhimes 10y agoIt was entertaining at first but I don't really bother to watch any more.
- jandrese 10y agoI've only watched a couple of episodes, but it seemed like the deals they offered were pretty terrible. Granted the products weren't great but when the deal is "<paltry sum> for a 51% stake in the company" I was like "Who would take that?" And of course they did. I guess Shark Tank is where you go when all normal investors have already turned you down.
- troygoode 10y agoI mean, they're not signing anything up there. The founders can also pull out of the deal after the presentation.
- angryasian 10y agoThe thing is that either side can pull out of the deal after the show. I've heard that some of these pitches and discussions can go on for an hour or more and television edits it down to 15 minutes.
- zxcvvcxz 10y ago> Nubrella is currently out of cash, Kaufman said, and potential new investors won’t bite, assuming the “sharks” and Sharper Image backed out of those deals because of some hidden defect in its product or business plan. Be careful who you deal with, and force them to act sooner rather than later. When dealing with the Sharks I don't know if you really can force them to act and cut a check, they can just say they will and run re-runs, potentially screwing your future investment opportunities.
- poppup 10y agoTV is a lie? Is that really news?
- downandout 10y agoMark Cuban said in a Howard Stern interview that about half of the deals made on the show fall apart during due diligence. So it's not particularly surprising that he never got his $200k. The only "fraud" I see here was perpetrated on viewers, if indeed they later aired a show (that this inventor voluntarily participated in) with an entirely fictional narrative about making a deal with Sharper Image. Shark Tank probably has an innocent explanation, and the truth is probably somewhere in the middle. But my BS detector went through the roof when he suggested that as a settlement for his lawsuit, he would accept being allowed to go back on a show that he claims is a fraud. This makes him sound like nothing more than a desperate, failed business owner that is attempting extort his way back onto the show for the free advertising it offers.
- helthanatos 10y agoIt sounds to me that he is lying... A lot. He accepted a settlement and now is suing again because that wasn't enough? He doesn't want people to think his item is niche and expensive... But it is. He raised the price from something already expensive to "I think I'll just carry around a tent". When you improve something, normally you improve defects and make it better, so it should cost around the same price. Why double the price for something a little better? This guy seems to not know how to run a company at all.
- canttestthis 10y agoI don't agree with that at all. It's up to him to set the price for his improved product, whether it's 10% more or 100% or 1000%. It's unfair though when an old version of his product is presented at an old price point using present tense verbs on TV. Of course viewers are going to think it's a bait and switch when they try to buy it. It harms his business.
- helthanatos 10y agoIf his product improved enough to price it so much greater, he should have versioned his product. If his "improvements" were just a farce and he just wanted to increase the price, then it is a bait and switch. Either way, this boils down to him being bad at business. But with reruns, they should include a disclaimer that says the original date and that prices may have changed.
- Justin_K 10y agoI learned that many of the entrepreneurs on the show aren't even true applicants. A friend of mine works for a small company that's experienced rapid growth and a lot of publicity - there is a team at Shark Tank's production co that are aggressively trying to get them on the show. The sad reality is that it's not even about applying and catching a break anymore... I'm not surprised.. it's TV. That said, I think this guy's story sounds fishy.
- agentgt 10y agoHa... I live in Waltham right on the edge of Newton and I think I saw the guy and I assumed it was just a new fangled baby Bjorn. At the time I just assumed the baby wasn't attached. If I lived somewhere else it probably would have made a bigger impression on me but I honestly see weird devices all the time in the Boston area (particularly fairly bizarre recumbent bikes and skating devices particularly as you approach Cambridge).
- EdSharkey 10y agoA small fry is unhappy things didn't work out after he went for a swim in the _shark tank_, eh?
- JeremyMorgan 10y agoNot incredibly surprising but this guy seems pretty shady, and I'm sure we're not getting the whole story. Everything on television is at least a little bit fake. If I'm being completely honest I enjoy ST just to see the pitches and check out interesting new products. I couldn't care less what happens after the show. I bet a lot of viewers are like me.
- glibgil 10y agoWhat is it with inventors and umbrellas? I can't think of a bigger non-problem. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M-Yx9GGqW5U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M-Yx9GGqW5U
- vogt 10y agoI worked for one of the Sharks specifically in dealing with their Shark Tank investments. It is not a lie. The verbal agreements on the show are just that. This founder is saying things out of spite because his deal fell through in due diligence, which in my experience is 100% on the founder almost all of the time. Founders will hide things like law suits, giant piles of debt, etc thinking that the Shark teams won't find it. Or sometimes the product has serious flaws that the founder wasn't transparent about on air. I stopped working for the shark before "Beyond the Tank" came out so I can't speak to the sharper image thing.
- beachstartup 10y agothis is basically how all business works. nothing is real until the money is in the bank. and until it is, there's a million things to go wrong. it can still go wrong after, too, it's just less likely.
- Zigurd 10y agoYou certainly should not spend the money before you have it but a first tier investor's term sheet carries a lot of weight . If you don't have hidden problems, good investors don't go looking for excuses to back out of deals. The likely reason the failure rate on Shark Tank is so high is that the prospective deals are chosen for variety and for being interesting rather than being brought by experienced founders or for being highly plausible investments.
- jorgecastillo 10y ago"Nothing is real until the money is in the bank." This is pretty much how life works too!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pyre 10y agoWhat about the show where they faked signing a deal with The Sharper Image? Was that not a lie?
- jimjimjim 10y agoReality TV is not. Every reality show is a distortion to further the show's brand or to generate drama.
- logicallee 10y agoI'd like you to give more of your credentials. I've been in contact with several of the of the entrepreneurs featured there, one of whom is a YC-backed entrepreneur (MTailor), and also for what it's worth I have another contact (via email) that I don't want to name. I haven't been on the show or anything like that. Why would you say that it is a "lie"? A lot of deals fall through. What specifically would you consider a "lie"? Examples of a lie would be if there were never any money that ever changed hands, etc. Other than that, it seems to be genuine >but no investor can adequately research a business in the 15 minutes it takes to shoot each pitch. You claim to have worked on shark tank but somewhere I heard that the pitches are much longer (up to an hour+) and get edited down, whereas you claim that it is 15 minutes, about the running time. So who's right? For this reason I would like you to name what crosses the lie threshold for you, and give just a bit more of your credentials. For the rest of us reading this I will state that the biggest "lie" isn't a lie at all: getting exposure on shark tank is a huuuuuuge amount of value for any company. But this is not something that any entrepreneur mentions (or it gets cut). I've never heard anyone say "Do you realize that when this airs, based on my talks with other founders we will get about five hundred thousand hits to our web site? So far we have a 7% closing rate on every single visitor who has ever come to our site." or anything like that... it's the elephant in the room that nobody really mentions, except a few times the sharks refer to it obliquely as 'gold-diggers' etc. but it's not mentioned in a positive light, for example when negotiating about valuations. I haven't seen anything else that seems to be a lie to me! (And this includes personal contact as mentioned at the top.)
- eggdude 10y agoI think his definition of "lie" is very broad in the sense of presenting something to be different than it actually is. For example: - The show makes it seem like the pitch lasts 15 minutes when it generally lasts much longer in reality (I've talked to a friend who has been on the show that has verified this). - The show makes it seem much more dramatic than it actually is by overlapping dialogue, rearranging and timing reaction shots, and using music (to the extend of fabricating a conversation) - The show makes it seem like an exact deal is made in 15 minutes when there is much more involved before and after the show
- madenine 10y agoWorked for a company that was on Shark Tank and Beyond the Tank. Its a TV show - its there to entertain viewers and sell ad time not generate funding for businesses. When they filmed BTT, there were narratives that they wanted to push, certain things they wanted to be said, etc. Bottom line, the money my employer got from ST/BTT was dwarfed in comparison to the marketing/PR benefits of just being on the show and working with the Sharks' teams - being associated with the show opens a lot of doors. I remember seeing an article from the founder of a company that was on ST estimating that the PR/Exposure was probably worth in the ballpark of $3m. I'd agree with that; a random re-run years after the initial episode would still bring in a huge amount of traffic - at no cost to us. I'd estimate we got 3-5 re-runs every quarter. I'll throw it out there too that there was a huge delay between filming BTT and when the episode aired.