3 ms·
I find the entire law on this to be pretty nebulous. Torrent sites inherently don't host the files people are stealing.
by tombert 10y ago
I find the entire law on this to be pretty nebulous. Torrent sites inherently don't host the files people are stealing.
- PieterH 10y agoThe law is clear: complicity in copyright violation, for profit. It became a criminal offence across Europe in the last decade. This puts costs for prosecution on the state, not rights holders, and it allows for jail time. Whether the law is fair or right, that's a different question. Many people lobbied hard against criminalisation of copyright and patent violations, and lost. The movie industry is just too powerful and had too many friends. But it's not nebulous. Help others commit a crime, you are an accessory and you are liable for fines and prison.
- abiox 10y agowhat "help others" means can be stretched pretty far.
- DanBC 10y agoI can understand (but don't agree with) jail time for the site owner. I don't know if I understand that for the mods, unless they got some money from the site. I really don't understand it for the users, unless again they got money from the site. As I understand it copyright infringement is only criminal if it's part of trade. The article describes those users as downloaders, which to me means the rights holders can sue for damages as a civil action, but not that the state can prosecute as a criminal case.
- SuperGent 10y agoThey charged them with receiving stolen goods. How this relates to French Law I'm not aware tho.
- kodt 10y agoCan we not charge all of the ISPs involved with transporting stolen goods?
- thesimpsons1022 10y agothe mods knew what they were doing. difference between someone who builds a road and someone who drives a truck full of drugs on that road.
- bbctol 10y agoI guess the mods here aren't driving, but they did give the directions?
- biot 10y agoThe moderators were making judgment calls on which drugs were not high quality enough, keeping only the drugs that met some minimum standard.
- 0xfeba 10y agoBut is copying a copyrighted movie "stealing" in that it deprives the owner (who still has the movie) of profits of that movie? Yes, potentially some people will go out to see the movie if they cannot pirate it. But not all. And it's hard to prove either way. That's not the same as "stealing a car".
- thesimpsons1022 10y agodidnt say anything about stealing a car?
- kodt 10y agoI think he is referencing this old anti-piracy ad that used to air in movie theaters. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_vHwfDNGdg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K_vHwfDNGdg
- overcast 10y agoThat's right, we shouldn't place blame on the sites hosting all of the illegal software torrents. They started it completely with the intent of only distributing media in the public domain. They were also totally unaware of people using their project to distribute the latest Adobe Photoshop release, and thousands of movies.
- cmiles74 10y agoEh, I think it's clear they don't host the actual intellectual property; they're mostly like signs pointing to who actually is hosting the IP. It seems like prosecuting those actually hosting the IP is too much work or would cost too much money and so the torrent indexers are prosecuted instead. I don't think their motives are relevant.
- overcast 10y agoTheir motives are entirely relevant. Especially when they speak out against it. The most prolific site ever, has the word PIRATE in it. I mean come on.
- alexandre_m 10y agoWell, you have to prove that you have no way to know what is being transited on your website and that you do everything under your control to not facilitate illegal behaviours. Otherwise, it's like saying I own a big warehouse where I allow criminals to meet and exchange illegal items, but pretend I play no part of it. I agree there are some gray zones on this for torrent activities, but when you have indexes with top movies of the week with filenames and metadata pretty clear about the content, how can you defend that?