7 ms·
Interesting quote from the BBC article: > If all this makes you worried about China's long-term cosmic ambitions, then you are not the only one. I think it's
by Tepix 10y ago
Interesting quote from the BBC article:
> If all this makes you worried about China's long-term cosmic ambitions, then you are not the only one.
I think it's dumb that China is not allowed to participate in the ISS.
- mc42 10y agoOn one hand, I think that it's a matter of policy due to NASA's downright prohibition on working with China [1] "China has been barred from the ISS since 2011, when Congress passed a law prohibiting official American contact with the Chinese space program due to concerns about national security. “National security,” of course, is the lingua franca excuse for any country to do anything it jolly well wants to do even if it has nothing to do with, you know, the security of the nation. But never mind." - [1] On the other hand, I agree with you. To paraphrase Andy Weir, scientists can always work together. Things get messy when politics are involved. [1] - http://time.com/3901419/space-station-no-chinese/ http://time.com/3901419/space-station-no-chinese/
- fla 10y agoI find it funny that the United States Congress decides who takes part in the _international_ space station program.
- arcticfox 10y agoMaybe if the other members of the international community invested as much into it, they'd get an equal say. The split is something like NASA 80%, Russia 10%, rest of world, 10%. (Although it depends how you adjust for inflation)
- kuschku 10y agoIf you look at it based on what the contributed things are actually worth, it’s more like 50 25 25. The US just happens to be very inefficient in space investments, because lots of politicians try to use it to get jobs into their states
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gizmo686 10y agoAdding a new partner to the ISS requires unanimous agreement of all existing partners. As it happens, the US is the only one who opposes China, but, in concept, any of the participating space agencies (or their controlling government(s)) could block participation.
- afarrell 10y agoLike cryptography[1], rocketry has an inherent political character. If you disagree, then how would you feel about training a team of North Korean scientists in the type of long-range rocketry involved delivering a payload to a target as small as ISS? I personally trust China with rocketry far far more than I trust North Korea, but "Do we trust this country with knowledge useful for killing large numbers of people?" is totally within the scope of a government to decide. [1] http://web.cs.ucdavis.edu/~rogaway/papers/moral-fn.pdf http://web.cs.ucdavis.edu/~rogaway/papers/moral-fn.pdf
- blacksmith_tb 10y agoBut haven't China proven (again) that they already have that technology? Unlike the DPRK (who don't seem too eager to get into orbit, either). Not working with China in space feels like a rehash of the cold war space race, except the US and the PRC are quite a lot friendlier, at least in terms of trade, and travel.
- ATsch 10y agoNK is indeed working on delivering payloads to orbit. Their latest mission was declared a success, although most watchers determined the orbit was so bad it would be coming down soon. I didn't follow the mission closely so I don't know what became of it.
- throwawayReply 10y agoAnother interesting quote: > Most interestingly perhaps for a layperson, the space station will carry an atomic clock ... > This is expected to make future mobile navigation more accurate, Xinhua cited scientists has saying. Are they laying the (political) groundwork for reducing the inaccuracy they put into civilian GPS, much as the US did in the 90s (96?).
- djsumdog 10y ago> If all this makes you worried about China's long-term cosmic ambitions, then you are not the only one. I too saw that as a weasel phrase. Propaganda isn't limited to countries we claim don't have free speech. Little things like this are probably not due to government's direct control over media, but they're a result of the natural fears people tend to have been given due to their government's political stance and foreign policy. The western world depends on China to be their manufacturer. Many of our startups and industry that deal with durable goods are dependent on their vast manufacturing power. Yet we use their government as a means to also hold them at an arms length. Why not let our space agencies work together?
- komali2 10y agoI don't understand how "national security concerns" is not a valid risk. Of all the countries in the world, China is 1 of 2 that are actually capable of standing up to US military might, and the only real advantage the US has is a more robust intelligence system via satellites. Satellites that for example can early detect missile launches, track missiles, guide missiles, etc. If I was a US military adviser I would absolutely be putting full pressure on avoiding any situation that gives the Chinese or the Russians more insight or access to the space program. I think war and military stuff is stupid and antithesis to the advancement of the human race, but I can see how someone who's job it is to be concerned about that sort of thing is very concerned about that sort of thing.
- 794CD01 10y agoWhen you get to the point where you truly think it's a problem that someone else on the planet could potentially "stand up to you," it's time to reevaluate your own behavior.
- umanwizard 10y agoWhy? Any country in the world would love to be in the position of security that the US occupies. Any one. Why shouldn't we do everything we can to hold on to that treasure we have?
- otaviokz 10y agoThanks for pointing that out. I'm sick of news agencies simply echoing this kind of nonsense as if it was "what everyone thinks" for no special reason.
- bluetwo 10y agoYou might think it is dumb that China is not allowed to participate in the ISS, but does it make you curious why this is? Is China an innocent victim of politics? Or did they warrant the ban from ISS?
- knowaveragejoe 10y agoIf the popular sentiment here is to be believed, both China and Russia are just misunderstood "good guys" being stepped on by American imperialism.
- M_Grey 10y agoThe ability to launch heavy payloads into orbit strikes me as having obvious military and intelligence implications. China and most of the rest of the world are not friends, it's more like detente with a brutally co-dependent economic relationship.
- tn13 10y agoChina is a country with expansionist mindset and a single minded focus to steal technology from others. USA might collaborate with China but after benefiting from USA will China reciprocate I think the answer to that is "NEVER". I think American decision to not giving China access to ISS is political and knee jerk but might be a very pragmatic one too.
- eternalban 10y ago> If all this makes you worried about China's long-term cosmic ambitions, then you are not the only one. Classic psyops. A non-manipulative variant would follow up with "So and so nation/organizations have expressed their worry that ..". So "you are not alone" but do you know the 'company' you keep? Of course BBC "News" is an old hand in the propaganda business.