4 ms·
While I think the subject of Powell's email getting hacked is very interesting -- he's admitted to the hack but have we learned any technical details regarding
by danso 10y ago
While I think the subject of Powell's email getting hacked is very interesting -- he's admitted to the hack but have we learned any technical details regarding how his GMail account was breached? -- this doesn't appear to be a very newsworthy insight.
First of all, he's not writing as a Secretary of State, so the number "200" could be conjecture, he certainly doesn't seem to be making an appeal to authority, i.e. "When I was at State, Israel told us etc etc etc". Who are the "boys in Tehran" who know that Israel has 200? CIA spies? The negotiators? Diplomats?
Meanwhile, President Carter has been giving speeches and interviews about this for years: http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/09/israel-nuclear-weapons-secret-united-states/380237/ http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2014/09/isr...
> Former CIA Director Robert Gates said so during his 2006 Senate confirmation hearings for secretary of defense, when he noted—while serving as a university president—that Iran is surrounded by “powers with nuclear weapons,” including “the Israelis to the west.” Former President Jimmy Carter said so in 2008 and again this year, in interviews and speeches in which he pegged the number of Israel’s nuclear warheads at 150 to around 300.
- tcoppi 10y agoWas it ever implied or said that his account was breached? It seems more likely that they are coming from the accounts of recipients at the DNC, based on the context of the article.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> It seems more likely that they are coming from the accounts of recipients at the DNC, based on the context of the article. Condoleezza Rice is definitely not a member of the DNC. https://www.buzzfeed.com/andrewkaczynski/colin-powell-called-benghazi-a-stupid-witch-hunt-and-condi-r https://www.buzzfeed.com/andrewkaczynski/colin-powell-called...
- tcoppi 10y agoThanks, I hadn't seen that. If it is true then it is more likely someone breached his email rather than these simply coming from hacks of the DNC.
- sandworm101 10y agoThey don't need spies to count the actual bombs. One can estimate the number through a combination of knowing which warhead tech Israel has acquired and an estimate of their production capacity. Whether it is Israel or North Korea, the math is the same. Or, assuming that Israel has had time to make far more bombs that it needs, one can estimate the stockpile through a measurement of potential delivery systems. 150 missiles + 50 aircraft = at most 200 warheads.
- daemin 10y agoSo the number of actual warheads could be far greater, but it is effectively only as many as the number of delivery vehicles. Especially in the event of a full nuclear war, since they won't exactly be able to go back and rearm with those spare warheads.
- sandworm101 10y agoThese things aren't cheap to build or maintain. And trying to keep 300 things secret is harder than 100. So no nation has a pile of extras lying around. Even the US/UK actually have far fewer warheads than delivery systems. Not every warhead on every missile in every sub is always armed. So counting the delivery mechanisms gives you an upper limit. I think this is the source of the 200 number. Of course Israel is a little odd. They are the one nuclear power obsessed with invasion of a very small territory. They may have some static plans, large warheads meant to be detonated at fixed positions rather than be 'delivered' by missile or bomber. That is a complication.
- Someone 10y ago"They don't need spies to count the actual bombs. One can estimate the number through a combination of knowing which warhead tech Israel has acquired and an estimate of their production capacity." And how do you think they estimate their production capacity or know which tech they acquired? They can know what they sold or gave them, but cannot rule out that others played a role, too. If they somehow manage to get those answers without spying, checking to what extent those answers can be trusted surely needs it. "one can estimate the stockpile through a measurement of potential delivery systems." They may be bluffing: trying to appear stronger than they are to prevent others from attacking you. They also may play the statistics game: if they have 3 bombs and build only 3 rockets, enemies may think they can take them all out. If they have 3 bombs and build 20 rockets, enemies may think twice even if they know they have only 3 bombs. Again, additional info is needed to figure out what information you got means_.
- AlgorithmicTime 10y ago>Who are the "boys in Tehran" who know that Israel has 200? CIA spies? The negotiators? Diplomats? The Iranians. The Iranians know that Israel has approximately 200 nukes pointed mostly at them.
- JshWright 10y agoSpecifically, the decision makers in the Iranian government.
- perseusprime11 10y agoHe's probably got that number from Quora. Sorry! I had to go there...