5 ms·
Most peoples electricity usage is relatively inelastic and no one wants the cognitive overload of checking electricity prices before they put the TV on.
by flukus 10y ago
Most peoples electricity usage is relatively inelastic and no one wants the cognitive overload of checking electricity prices before they put the TV on.
- ptaipale 10y agoHowever, wouldn't it make sense to e.g. adjust heating/air conditioning depending on electricity spot price? That's then just a gadget that gets the information and guides the home system. It'll probably be more meaningful in some industrial plants though, if there's any such energy-intensive industry.
- rdl 10y agoI'd be pretty happy to pause an EV charge many times. Since Teslas are data-connected, they could possibly do this with no grid interface beyond the power connection.
- greglindahl 10y agoThis is one very nice aspect of a grid when there are a lot of electric cars which charge at night, and have big enough batteries that they don't need to fully charge: you can absorb a lot of variability of overnight wind energy. And if electric cars also plug in at work... jackpot.
- WalterBright 10y agoEven better than that, it could be set up so that your house drew power from the car battery when rates were high! You could set it to, for example, draw from the car battery until the charge drops to 80% or some settable limit. Then all the rechargeable cars become part of the battery moderation of the whole grid!
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoThe Tesla engineering head said giving power back isn't likely, as it would degrade the battery too much, but he stressed how much benefit to grid stability could be delivered just by altering when the batteries drew power to charge.
- greglindahl 10y agoSure, there are some research projects for that, but note the wildly different cost: charging a little different doesn't degrade the car's battery. All it takes is an Internet connection, a good prediction of how much charge the driver will need, and a micropayment of some kind. That's a no-brainer compared to paying the owner for shortening the life of the battery.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThe future of transportation - grid balancing batteries that have wheels and incidentally take you somewhere you need. ;).
- toomuchtodo 10y agoThis is a revenue model Nest uses (partnering with utilities to shed AC loads in households who have opted in).
- nl 10y agoTV isn't the problem. Most of benefits come if you have a system which can regulate slightly your use of air conditioning and heating (and a few other things like pool pumps). In some cases you can save 50% of a daily powerbill by turning off the compressor in an air conditioner for 15 minutes.. but the right 15 minutes. Few people would get up and turn off the air con for that, but a system that let you say how much you want to spend on it that you setup once makes a lot of sense.
- hvidgaard 10y agoIt's a different beast. The price is high during those 15 minutes because of supply and demand. If you implement a smart grid that regulate load, you upset the supply and demand balance and the power might become so cheap that new self regulating systems are not worth the initial cost.
- nl 10y agoIndeed. What a great problem that will be.
- paulmd 10y agoOnce the smart-device interface is properly defined and the software is written, the hardware cost should not be a problem. You will end up with some kind of "smart device" router that connects to your internet/home network to talk to the power company, and uses a commodity wifi interface to talk to your smart devices. The cost of an ESP8266 is already sub-$7 at hobbyist volumes, you can expect the additional hardware cost to easily be driven to trivial levels with widespread adoption. The problem is purely in getting a standard system out there and designing devices that incorporate the new control model.
- WalterBright 10y agoIt is completely unnecessary for appliances to talk to the power company. They only need to talk to the internet. The power company just posts the spot price on a web site.
- WalterBright 10y agoOh, I disagree. A/C is very power hungry, and can be adjusted to cool the house lower than normal during cheap power times and let it go a bit higher during expensive power times. It can also "pre-cool" when power is cheaper. The same goes for an electric water heater. The charger for your Tesla can also adjust when it charges based on power prices. The dishwasher/washer/dryer can be set to come on at night when the power rates dip. Exterior lights can dim if the power rates go up.
- jakub_h 10y agoA/C can also freeze water to shift the load very cheaply.
- WalterBright 10y agoThat's a fine idea. I didn't think of that. But I'm sure there's a LOT of low hanging fruit like this that would greatly mitigate the need for the power companies to store power.
- azernik 10y agoThis has been the promise of "smart-grid" attached devices; the implementation hasn't caught up with the dream yet, but in theory, yeah, there are a lot of very elastic loads that can be used to smooth out the demand curve, or to match a jittery supply curve.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt ain't gonna work if you need people watching the electricity prices and deciding what to do. It need to be devices talking directly to the power grid. And that need standards for things like communication protocols. Does anyone here know how are those coming along?
- WalterBright 10y ago> And that need standards for things like communication protocols. All that is needed is a way to get the spot price of electricity from the internet, similar to how I can get the current temperature in Anchorage. Devices don't need to talk to the power grid.
- Scarblac 10y agoMaybe this is an actual problem for "Internet of Things" to solve -- appliances that can time when they turn on until the price of electricity dips. Of course there should be some mechanism involved to prevent all washing machines to turn on at exactly the same moment the moment it dips...