4 ms·
Voter ID isn't about ID; it's about racism and classism and making it more difficult for the non-rich-white minority to exercise their rights.[1] [1] https://w
by alistairSH 10y ago
Voter ID isn't about ID; it's about racism and classism and making it more difficult for the non-rich-white minority to exercise their rights.[1]
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2016/08/03/courts-are-finally-pointing-out-the-racism-behind-voter-id-laws/?utm_term=.e587cf25a02f https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2016/08/03/...
- int_19h 10y agoVoter ID as usually suggested or implemented in the USA is that, yes. But try taking your American hat off for a little bit, and ask yourself why most countries in the world, including all those (by US measure) "socialist" European countries, do require some form of identification to vote. Voter ID, by itself, is not racist, classist, or anything. It is a reasonable and prudent measure to ensure that only those eligible to vote can vote. We can argue whether it's really necessary or not based on how much voter fraud there is in practice, but if you do have a national ID anyway, there's no particular reason not to use it for voting. The problem with US voter ID laws is that they are not coupled with an actual national ID system, and instead rely on existing IDs, which aren't free. On top of that, the laws are written in such a way, and also combined with other policies (e.g. closing DMVs that issue IDs in certain areas), so as to make vote suppression a deliberate side effect. It is entirely possible to implement voter ID without such side effects, though.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> Voter ID, by itself, is not racist, classist, or anything. It is a reasonable and prudent measure to ensure that only those eligible to vote can vote. Even on the assumption that everyone has the moral right to vote, and that therefore the check you mention is a crime against humanity, voter ID is still an important and prudent measure to ensure that people vote no more often than they're supposed to.
- alistairSH 10y agoIn theory, that makes sense, but has there ever been proof of large-scale voter impersonation in the US? To my knowledge there has not. And any proposed ID system is more likely to disenfranchise voters than prevent fraud.
- int_19h 10y agoThere hasn't been such proof, and what information we have indicates that the levels are very low. But the problem is that you don't really have easily available and reliable data in the absence of IDs. To some extent, this is symbolic. In most developed countries, and especially in US, resident non-citizens - especially permanent residents - have most of the legal and economic rights and the advantages enjoyed by citizens. Political rights, including right to vote, is one of the few things that are reserved for citizens alone. If it is to mean something, ensuring that it is only exercised by those who have it makes sense, even if you don't actually catch any miscreants - you could consider it an honor guard of sorts. But, by the same logic, it is crucial that those who do have the right to vote can exercise that right.
- alistairSH 10y agoAll true, but the parent was questioning policy in the US.