4 ms·
Social Security was invented in 1935, and the first Social Security cards were passed out in 1937. The SSN system has been virtually unchanged since then. Ther
by dragontamer 10y ago
Social Security was invented in 1935, and the first Social Security cards were passed out in 1937. The SSN system has been virtually unchanged since then.
There's absolutely no disgrace about the SSN system: it did the job quite well decades before the invention of the computer. The disgrace is that no system has come to replace it in the last 80 years.
The US Post Office sent out a RFC suggesting that they're contemplating a national-identity system btw, complete with PKI infrastructure and cryptographic proofs. They're probably the best agency to verify the identities of millions of Americans (any American with a home / post office address can be verified by a Post Office employee).
But that's all speculation. I don't recall any news suggesting that the US Post Office has actually been approved to roll out this hypothetical identification system. (But honestly, I do think its a good idea and would support such an initiative)
--------------
In any case: Social Security Numbers aren't a problem. We all need to be tracked by the social security system so that we get benefits.
The problem is that every government agency is using SSNs as if they were good identifiers. I mean, yeah, its good for the government to "save money" here and recycle the Social Security Administration's hard work in listing all American Citizens. But this is definitely an area of the Government where I'd prefer more money were spent on a "proper solution", as opposed to the minor cost savings of centralizing it all on the shoulders of the Social Security Administration.
---------------
Repurposing the US Post Office would serve multiple purposes:
* The US Post Office has been downsizing recently. IE: Lost jobs, fewer benefits, losing money. Etc. etc. If the US Post Office took on more work and did something essential in today's computer-based society (aka: if they were the gatekeepers of a National-identity PKI certificate), it'd give all those Post Office workers a job in an age of declining snail-mail.
* Very large agency with a staff who specializes in physical contact with a huge number of Americans. There are very few agencies that have the size, scale, and connectivity of the US Post Office.
* A PKI-based national identity certificate would replace SSNs as the national identifier of choice. With proper security / proper certificate handling, it would be significantly safer than SSNs. Proof through physical access + identifiers (ie: Government-issued ids, like Passports + Drivers Licenses) is a solved problem with the Post Office. Post Office employees are regularly trained to verify Birth Certificates, Drivers Licenses, Passports and so forth. They know how to verify identities physically.
- fapjacks 10y agoWe could also then make it illegal to send unsolicited direct mail advertisements, since the USPS wouldn't rely on those scummy dirtbags for their bread and butter. I'm 100% in on this idea.
- colejohnson66 10y agoYou'd need the politicians to do that. USPS could stop allowing unsolicited mail, but that is a revenue source for them.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoThe problem isn't with the concept of SSNs. The problem is that everyone and their uncle asks you to disclose them yet we still have the delusional idea that they are secret.
- toufka 10y agoThough everyone and their uncle asks you to disclose SSNs, you don't actually have to. Tell AT&T that it's none of their business, tell your university, 'no thanks', etc. Though everyone asks, the only people you should tell are your bank, your employer, and the IRS.
- redblacktree 10y agoQuite right. Most will accept a driver's license number in lieu of SSN.
- mkhalil 10y agoThis doesn't really work in practice. Have you ever applied for a credit card without a social? Sure, they can't require you to provide it, but the odds for getting approved without it are virtually nil.
- raarts 10y ago> the problem is that every government agency is using SSNs as if they are good identifiers So much this. Especially with all the data breaches knowledge of an SSN has become meaningless. The practice of taking it as an identifier should be outlawed. It's time people start suing the organizations that enable identity theft by practicing this.