3 ms·
> It has been in decline for decades I don't have time to put together a great convincing case, so I'll just say that this is very different from my view. Some
by BurningFrog 10y ago
> It has been in decline for decades
I don't have time to put together a great convincing case, so I'll just say that this is very different from my view. Some high level regulations have been removed, sure, but meanwhile almost every corner of life now has regulations and regulators that have to be obeyed and asked for permission.
It would be nice to have some kind of objective measure(s) of the overall level of state regulation, rather than trade anecdotes/gut feels. Some economist has probably done that already.
- rayiner 10y agoI would guess your view derives from the fact that the parts of the regulatory state that have grown since the 1970's have more direct effects on individuals and small businesses: environmental, workplace safety, anti-discrimination, anti-money laundering. But there isn't much money in gaming those. The big-money sectors of the economy: telecommunications, transportation, manufacturing, and finance have been deregulated. And software has become a big-money sector of the economy and has remained almost completely unregulated. I handle appeals in regulatory cases, so I have occasion to research historical regulatory treatment of different areas. It's really eye-opening to go read ICC, FCC, or FERC opinions from the 1940s and 1950s and compare them to ones from today. Agencies back then had vast powers: they could deny entry of a competitor into a market if they felt it would harm the revenues of incumbents. If you were an air carrier, you had to publish your prices, and if the agency did not like them it could impose prices on you. Those agencies are a shell of their former selves. Agencies used to have to power to structure industries top-down as they saw fit. Today, they might have thousands of pages more regulations covering various minutia, but nobody is going to build a "corporate colossus" lobbying to influence agency treatment of minutia.
- ahh 10y agoI am unclear how that's an argument for thousands of pages of regulations covering minutia.
- hx87 10y agoIt's probably safe to say that business-level regulation has fallen while product-level regulation has risen.
- pmoriarty 10y ago"almost every corner of life now has regulations and regulators that have to be obeyed and asked for permission" If you honestly believe that about the US, you should visit Germany.
- ubernostrum 10y agoI've had this argument with other people in the past and am willing to have it with you: the idea of a new and unprecedented amount of government "meddling" in the otherwise "free" market is a myth. The sea change of the 20th century lay entirely in bringing the machinery of government to bear in favor of people it had previously been used against, and against people it had previously been used in favor of. And of course the people who previously were favored see this as new and invasive interference, because they had grown so used to being the favored parties that they simply took for granted that "free market" = "system rigged in my favor".
- convolvatron 10y agoI run a very small business metal fabrication facility in one of the most regulated and socialist of cities in the US, San Francisco. We deal with hazardous chemicals, highly flammable gases and markedly unsafe working conditions. Me and the rest of the people like me get an inspection once a year from the fire department to make sure minimum standards are kept (to ensure the safety of firefighters if they ever enter). tanks are tied up. flammables are kept in closed cabinets. We pay the city around $100 a year in fees tied to volume of hazardous materials. Otherwise they leave us completely alone. We have to keep track of whether sales are retail or come with a resellers cert from the state. When we have extra work, I bring in guys under the table. If I had real employees I would have to have additional insurance, and pay the city mandated minimum wage - which is a lot less than market value for a semi-skilled fabricator. Its completely* anecdotal, but this boogeyman of massive regulatory burden doesn't seem to be universal. From my tiny little patch I'm free to fail or succeed without any state interference.
- convolvatron 10y agoEDIT: if i pay someone more than $600, i have to file a 1099. sorry - all of this seems quite irrelevant, but personally i'm tired of having people claim that the small businessman is being repressed by excessive regulation and government tyranny. The small businessman is being repressed by the state of the market and the large businessman.
- tchock23 10y agoSomewhat related, but in my experience advising hundreds of small businesses over the past few years the worst (performing) are the ones that blame excessive regulation and government tyranny as a reason for their lack of progress. It's rarely/never that from the independent perspective of the advisor to the company... Not to turn this into a political discussion, but these same small business owners share a similar political leaning and are mostly parroting the canned narrative they hear on their respective talk channels...