5 ms·
To me it clearly means that the system is autonomous while the autopilot is on. What else should it mean?
by maxxxxx 10y ago
To me it clearly means that the system is autonomous while the autopilot is on. What else should it mean?
- the8472 10y agoPilots aren't allowed to leave the cockpit just because the plane is on autopilot.
- alistairSH 10y agoYet, there are documented cases where the pilots have had enough faith in the system to take a nap or play around on their laptops.
- maxxxxx 10y agoThey certainly don't have to be ready to intervene within a fraction of a second as you have to do with Tesla.
- mikeash 10y agoReal-world autopilots cover a wide range of pilot aids, down to something as simple as a gyroscope mechanically connected to the rudder in order to automatically hold heading. Most are more capable than that, but typical autopilot features would involve holding heading, altitude (or rate of climb/descent), and speed, or navigating towards a particular point. Fully autonomous autopilots are extremely rare, and I'm not aware of any commercial system where the pilot is allowed to ignore the airplane while the system is engaged. So, again, how did you get this idea?
- throwaway729 10y ago> So, again, how did you get this idea? Because, as JonnieCache pointed out, the colloquial definition of Auto Pilot is more informed by entertainment than by the aerospace industry. What's more baffling is why anyone would assume that the average person knows what "auto pilot" means in an aerospace setting. I mean, why in the world would that be common knowledge? In fact, I've seen enough bone-headed assertions about collision avoidance capabilities of modern aircraft that I'm pretty certain even people who think they know what auto pilot means, actually don't. FWIW you can test this by finding people outside of the tech echo chamber who don't know what a Tesla is and asking them to describe the capabilities of a car with an Auto Pilot.
- mikeash 10y agoYou're not answering the question, you're just repeating the basis of it. I accept that people think it means it's autonomous. Stop repeating that as if it were new to me. What I want to know is why people think that. "Because everybody thinks that, if you'd bother to ask them" is not an answer to that question.
- throwaway729 10y ago> What I want to know is why people think that Re-read the first sentence of my post. Perhaps you could answer my question: why would you assume someone with no knowledge of the aerospace industry would understand what the term auto pilot means in that context? Why would anyone assume the TCAS specification has a greater effect on public perception than the latest comic book movie?
- mikeash 10y agoDo you have examples of this misconception being propagated by entertainment? I'm having trouble thinking of any, but that might just be my low level of knowledge. I'm not going to answer your question because you're trying to make me defend a position I'm not taking here.
- seren 10y agoI believe it comes from the fact that, colloquially, being "on autopilot" means doing something mindlessly, without being aware, or without thinking. So when people engage their car autopilot, they allow themselves to be on autopilot, literally and figuratively.
- throwanem 10y ago"Because entertainment commonly portrays it as such, and few people are familiar with the workings of pilot aids installed aboard commercial aircraft" is an answer to that question. Perhaps it is not one you like. Perhaps also it is not one which is accurate. I'm not really familiar with a lot of entertainment that includes this trope, which is not necessarily a surprise; what is a surprise is that TV Tropes, which is generally very detailed on such matters, doesn't seem to have anything covering it, either. That certainly suffices to inspire some doubt in my mind as to whether "oh, it's just entertainment" is an accurate answer, or a just-so story.
- maxxxxx 10y agoTesla wants to get the credit for using the word "Autopilot" but it doesn't want to take responsibility. If they sold cars only to airline pilots you would have a point but to regular car buyers "autopilot" means it's autonomous.
- mikeash 10y agoMy point is just that this is the only source of meaning for the word I'm aware of, and so I'm wondering where the other meaning comes from. Apparently the answer is "movies."